Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Cyclocross and Gravelbiking (Recreational) (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=23)
-   -   1X drivetrain option for gravel bike (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1162789)

Noctilux.95 12-24-18 09:43 AM

1X drivetrain option for gravel bike
 
I'm looking to buy a Basso Palta gravel bike this spring which offers only a 1x drivetrain option. Is Sram the only manufacturer that makes 1x drivetrain for gravel/cyclocross? Is Shimano rumored to coming out with 1x option soon?

GrainBrain 12-24-18 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by Noctilux.95 (Post 20717296)
I'm looking to buy a Basso Palta gravel bike this spring which offers only a 1x drivetrain option. Is Sram the only manufacturer that makes 1x drivetrain for gravel/cyclocross? Is Shimano rumored to coming out with 1x option soon?

Shimano has offered 1x for quite awhile in 10,11 and 12 speed on mtb. Now Shimano has road derailleurs that are clutched as well.

​​​​​​

Noctilux.95 12-24-18 09:54 AM


Originally Posted by GrainBrain (Post 20717304)
Shimano has offered 1x for quite awhile in 10,11 and 12 speed on mtb. Now Shimano has road derailleurs that are clutched as well.

​​​​​​

I'm aware of the MB 1X Shimano offers. I have XT 1x11 on one of my MB's. Problem is XTR/XT cranks only go up to 34T.

mstateglfr 12-24-18 10:43 AM


Originally Posted by Noctilux.95 (Post 20717296)
Is Shimano rumored to coming out with 1x option soon?

Get a shimano shifter.
get a clutched rear derailleur.
get crank arms and whatever 1x narrow wide chain ring you want.

there it is- a shimano 1x drivetrain.

Noctilux.95 12-24-18 11:15 AM

The rear derailleur would have to be an XT/XTR to accommodate larger cog cassette. So Ultegra 8070 hydro shifters, XT 11-40 cassette, and a third party (maybe Easton) 40T crank. Sound right?

Elvo 12-24-18 11:46 AM

I wouldn't recommend 1x for socal "Gravel" unless you are putting an 11-42 on the back or higher

Noctilux.95 12-24-18 01:36 PM


Originally Posted by Elvo (Post 20717457)
I wouldn't recommend 1x for socal "Gravel" unless you are putting an 11-42 on the back or higher

The bike is 1X specific.

fietsbob 12-24-18 03:02 PM

Business..
 
OK, I expect Shimano is watching Sram sales numbers and wants to get some of that market too ... if not dominate it ...

tyrion 12-24-18 03:24 PM

You can use Shimano Di2 road shifters with Di2 mountain RD.

EdwinHeadwind 12-24-18 03:33 PM

I'm running SRAM Force 1 X 11 on my gravel bike, and I want for nothing. Flawless performance.

fronesis 12-24-18 04:16 PM


Originally Posted by EdwinHeadwind (Post 20717757)
I'm running SRAM Force 1 X 11 on my gravel bike, and I want for nothing. Flawless performance.

Me too.

I’ve seen a surprising amount of hostility to 1x...but it all seems to come from people who haven’t ridden 1x.

DrIsotope 12-24-18 08:18 PM

Honestly, if you;re going 1X, just go with SRAM. They're much better at it. Cheaper, too. Complaints about my Rival 1? None.

Metieval 12-25-18 07:27 PM

I love 1x,
I hate SRAM.

shoota 12-26-18 10:02 AM

I hate 1X.
I love SRAM.

gus6464 12-26-18 05:44 PM

My only gripe with SRAM is that their hydro brakes are finnicky to setup. They can be setup to be quiet though but might not be an easy task.

ogmtb 12-26-18 07:22 PM


Originally Posted by gus6464 (Post 20719924)
My only gripe with SRAM is that their hydro brakes are finnicky to setup. They can be setup to be quiet though but might not be an easy task.

My experience has been quite the opposite.

My Guides, on two different bikes, weren't finicky to setup and were/are quiet. My kid's Guides weren't finicky to setup and are quiet. My Red HRDs weren't finicky to setup and they are also quiet.

Bryan C. 12-26-18 10:14 PM


Originally Posted by tyrion (Post 20717746)
You can use Shimano Di2 road shifters with Di2 mountain RD.

I'm patiently waiting to see if the new XTR 12 spd is compatible with the road Di2 levers. That would be a pretty sweet setup.

EdwinHeadwind 12-27-18 10:08 AM


Originally Posted by gus6464 (Post 20719924)
My only gripe with SRAM is that their hydro brakes are finnicky to setup. They can be setup to be quiet though but might not be an easy task.

Agreed. Shimanos are truly "set it and forget it," but I had to fuss with my SRAMs constantly. Love the shifting, though.

bigredgrad01 12-27-18 11:00 AM


Originally Posted by Noctilux.95 (Post 20717421)
The rear derailleur would have to be an XT/XTR to accommodate larger cog cassette. So Ultegra 8070 hydro shifters, XT 11-40 cassette, and a third party (maybe Easton) 40T crank. Sound right?

You can probably run Ultegra RX for 11-40. I am running R8000 RD with 11-40 XT just fine. But if you are going with DI2, probably better off getting an MTB RD, so you can go bigger.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:06 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.