Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Cyclocross and Gravelbiking (Recreational) (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=23)
-   -   Cargo Bibs and a Technical Tee? (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1171898)

TimothyH 05-01-19 11:06 AM

Cargo Bibs and a Technical Tee?
 
I don't suppose anyone here has yet bought into the idea put forth by Rapha - cargo bibs with pockets and replacing the jersey with a lightweight and looser fitting technical tee.

The idea has merit completely apart from the company which thought it up and what anyone thinks about their products. A tee is more socially acceptable off the bike but more importantly, bibs are inherently more stable than a jersey and contents would not bounce on rough surfaces as much.

I think it is a great idea for gravel or bikepacking and would be tempted to try them if I thought I would get use out of them. They are rated to 30°C which isn't going to cut it during Georgia summers.

https://road.cc/content/review/24215...rgo-bib-shorts

Cadence made a similar product, the Adventure Bibs, but they seem to be out of business.

Anyone know of something similar?


-Tim-

TimothyH 05-01-19 11:22 AM

I found these....

Yeti Enduro: https://www.backcountry.com/yeti-cyc...bib-shorts-men

Aerotech (gel pad though): https://www.aerotechdesigns.com/atd-...ib-shorts.html

Eliel: https://www.elielcycling.com/collect...go-bibs-shorts




-Tim-

tiredhands 05-01-19 11:53 AM

This is what I've been wearing now that I'm riding faster and further. I don't have a body shape that's what you'd call "aero," so I'm a huge fan of the cargo bibs. Better than looking like the Michelin Man! I've got one from The Black Bibs and I've got my eyes on a cheap set from Spexcel. I've been wearing cheap "cool tech" tees from Wally World but I might get a MTB jersey for more articulation. My challenge, it seems, will be to find cargo bibs with minimal padding for riding on leather saddles.

TimothyH 05-01-19 12:11 PM


Originally Posted by Spoonrobot (Post 20909548)
You know how much I like t-shirts.

I also know how much you dislike most homebrew solutions, but they work so well for me I can't help but post ;)

I printed off a couple of the pics of Evan Murphy's fridge shorts and gave them to my seamstress along with a pair of regular bibs and an old jersey. Couple days later I had my own pair of cargo bibs for a tiny fraction of the cost. I rode with them a bit and turns out I don't actually like that much cargo on my bibs. About one regular size jersey pocket is workable for me, other than that and the shorts start sagging and/or moving around while I climb out of the saddle that the chamois was sliding around and causing irritation. So I had the big pockets removed and just one regular pocket added to most of my shorts. Something to consider if you want to test it out without a big outlay for something that may not work. Or maybe even just DIY it.

Louis Garneau makes an MTB liner short but the pocket is sized for a phone as well as the shorts require an overshort so most likely too warm for you.


I'm sorry if I came across as not liking DIY. That's not really the case. I just don't like things "southern engineered" AKA jury rigged. If it works well them I'm all for it.

So, yeah, your post is really interesting and the point about heavier cargo impacting how the padding sits or causing it to move around is something I've not considered.

So who is your seamstress?

The idea caught my eye since my bikepacking trip. Forgoing a traditional cycling jersey would be one less thing to worry about.

Thanks for the feedback mon frere.


-Tim-

gus6464 05-01-19 12:12 PM

Bike shorts with a hiking shirt like the ones Columbia makes with the roll up sleeves are what's up for me. If the ride is very long I just use my hydration fanny pack. It's what I'll be wearing for the BWR this Sunday.

TimothyH 05-01-19 12:15 PM


Originally Posted by tiredhands (Post 20909552)
This is what I've been wearing now that I'm riding faster and further. I don't have a body shape that's what you'd call "aero," so I'm a huge fan of the cargo bibs. Better than looking like the Michelin Man! I've got one from The Black Bibs and I've got my eyes on a cheap set from Spexcel. I've been wearing cheap "cool tech" tees from Wally World but I might get a MTB jersey for more articulation. My challenge, it seems, will be to find cargo bibs with minimal padding for riding on leather saddles.

Thanks for the links.

The Spexcel bibs are designed to look like the Rapha product.


-Tim-

redlude97 05-01-19 12:24 PM

Just go full hipster with a handlebar bag

tiredhands 05-01-19 12:27 PM

I forgot - there's also one from Specialized that I'll snag if/when it goes on sale. I have one of their SWAT liner bibs, which has great storage and fit, but is too sheer to wear alone. Some cyclists seem not to mind being a little flirty, though.

tdilf 05-01-19 01:17 PM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 20909471)
I don't suppose anyone here has yet bought into the idea put forth by Rapha - cargo bibs with pockets and replacing the jersey with a lightweight and looser fitting technical tee.

The idea has merit completely apart from the company which thought it up and what anyone thinks about their products. A tee is more socially acceptable off the bike but more importantly, bibs are inherently more stable than a jersey and contents would not bounce on rough surfaces as much.

I think it is a great idea for gravel or bikepacking and would be tempted to try them if I thought I would get use out of them. They are rated to 30°C which isn't going to cut it during Georgia summers.

https://road.cc/content/review/24215...rgo-bib-shorts

Cadence made a similar product, the Adventure Bibs, but they seem to be out of business.

Anyone know of something similar?


-Tim-

Tim, Mavic has started a new clothing line geared towards casual gravel.
https://shop.mavic.com/en-int/allroa...l/apparel.html

TimothyH 05-01-19 03:01 PM


Originally Posted by tdilf (Post 20909672)
Tim, Mavic has started a new clothing line geared towards casual gravel.
https://shop.mavic.com/en-int/allroa...l/apparel.html

This is good to hear.

I’ll reserve judgement until I get back onto a PC to look at the products closer. Hopefully it is more than just road or MTB gear recycled with a gravel label.

Real feature of of use for gravel are a good thing - ability to carry more stuff, robust shoulder reinforcement for carrying hydration packs, etc.

thanks for the link!


-Tim-

mstateglfr 05-01-19 06:34 PM

Cant say ive ever found myself needing to carry stuff in my bibs.
But i wear a jersey so it hasnt come up before.
...and when I don't wear a jersey and instead wear a tech tee, I just use my under saddle bag which is 6-7.5liters, depending if its expanded. I used it for longer rides and just stopped caring if its on the bike at all times.
Stays out of the way and doesnt make me carry too much in my jersey.

But hey- lots of options are great in life.


These rapha bibs look similar in style and intent to the currently popular women's athlesure yoga pants that have a built in cell phone pocket.

TimothyH 05-01-19 09:41 PM


Originally Posted by Spoonrobot (Post 20910039)
Ha I said "my seamstress" like it's the 50s and I'm a man in a gray flannel suit. I just used a regular alteration place in Smyrna that did my job interview suit, but it looks to have closed. The lady made it seem like it was a pretty normal request but she did say the pictures made it much easier. Cost was $20 back in Spring 2017 so it couldn't have taken more than a half hour or so - I think any place that does alterations should be able to accommodate the project.

It wouldn't surprise me if you rode in a gray flannel suit.


-Tim-

sputniky 05-01-19 09:46 PM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 20909471)
I don't suppose anyone here has yet bought into the idea put forth by Rapha - cargo bibs with pockets and replacing the jersey with a lightweight and looser fitting technical tee.

You mean this "new" idea that was first introduced by Specialized five years ago?

http://www.pinkbike.com/news/specialized-swat-apparel-first-ride.html

Yeah, SWAT bibs work well.

TimothyH 05-01-19 09:55 PM

People seem to be wound up tighter than a banjo string lately.

The slightest thing sets people off and nobody knows how to have a conversation any more.

sputniky 05-01-19 10:22 PM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 20910285)
People seem to be wound up tighter than a banjo string lately.

The slightest thing sets people off and nobody knows how to have a conversation any more.

I agree.

Why does my post set you off? Why are you wound up tighter than a banjo string?

It seems that you took some innocuous information (that Rapha is merely copying an idea that has been around for a while) personally.

Why is that?

Hondo Gravel 05-01-19 10:23 PM

I’m mad at Timothy too :lol: I don’t know why? And yes I’m just kidding.

Koyote 05-02-19 06:30 AM

Back to Tim's original question:

I haven't tried cargo bibshorts, but I suspect that it would feel funny to have stuff in such pockets. Spoonrobot's feedback kind of confirms that. If I really need to carry more stuff, I will add a handlebar bag or top tube bag to my bike.

I have thought about those high-tech fabric t-shirts, though. Rapha is not the only company that makes one, though theirs looks nice - if I can snag one at a good sale price, I will probably get it eventually. I mean, what the heck...I do most of my training rides solo, on a pretty heavy bike (26+l bs) with a handlebar bag to carry plenty of stuff; what's the harm in wearing a less-than-aero shirt? It might make the ride slower, but it'll be an even better workout.

TimothyH 05-02-19 07:26 AM


Originally Posted by Koyote (Post 20910548)
Back to Tim's original question:

I haven't tried cargo bibshorts, but I suspect that it would feel funny to have stuff in such pockets. Spoonrobot's feedback kind of confirms that. If I really need to carry more stuff, I will add a handlebar bag or top tube bag to my bike.

I have thought about those high-tech fabric t-shirts, though. Rapha is not the only company that makes one, though theirs looks nice - if I can snag one at a good sale price, I will probably get it eventually. I mean, what the heck...I do most of my training rides solo, on a pretty heavy bike (26+l bs) with a handlebar bag to carry plenty of stuff; what's the harm in wearing a less-than-aero shirt? It might make the ride slower, but it'll be an even better workout.


The thing about getting a handlebar bag is that I'll already be carrying frame, saddle and bar bags with tent, pad, quilt, stove, food, etc.

The Rapha technical tee interests me because it is made of the same fabric as their Pro Flyweight jersey which I own. It wicks and dries instantly and I can actually feel evaporative cooling on my chest as I ride in hot weather. It is uncanny. Any technical tee will do though but yeah, if the Rapha goes on sale then I'll consider it.


-Tim-

Koyote 05-02-19 07:46 AM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 20910663)
The thing about getting a handlebar bag is that I'll already be carrying frame, saddle and bar bags with tent, pad, quilt, stove, food, etc.

The Rapha technical tee interests me because it is made of the same fabric as their Pro Flyweight jersey which I own. It wicks and dries instantly and I can actually feel evaporative cooling on my chest as I ride in hot weather. It is uncanny. Any technical tee will do though but yeah, if the Rapha goes on sale then I'll consider it.


-Tim-

Right. For bikepacking, where speed is almost irrelevant, those may be great choices.

And ditto on the Rapha flyweight stuff. I have the Classic Flyweight jersey, and it is tremendous in very hot weather -- it seems like a cliche, but it is almost like not even wearing a jersey.

TimothyH 05-02-19 07:53 AM


Originally Posted by Hondo Gravel (Post 20910308)
I’m mad at Timothy too :lol: I don’t know why? And yes I’m just kidding.

:lol:

I love this place.

IronM 05-05-19 09:39 AM

I suppose it depends on what you're riding. Myself, just day rides usually not over 5 hrs (I'm older.. that's about all I'm good for) & I just wear the same bibs/jersey I use on the road. During summer month I often carry a 3rd bottle in the center bottle, taking up a lot of space that could otherwise hold a 2nd tube (I run tubeless, but...), extra food, a back-up pocket pump, etc. I've been considering a handle-bar bag for over-flow stuff so that I'm not food or hydration limited while up in very remote areas. I like to pack enough stuff (canisters, a back-up bump, small tools, back-up hanger, chain quick-links) where help is nonexistent. I probably need to carry more 1st aid stuff than I do - which is nothing.

I could not imagine carrying anything in cargo shorts - I would think that would chafe while riding but could be wrong.

TimothyH 05-05-19 10:42 AM

I met someone yesterday with the Rapha carbo bibs.

He carries his food for day rides in the side pockets and says he loves them.

sputniky 05-05-19 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 20915017)
I met someone yesterday with the Rapha carbo bibs.

He carries his food for day rides in the side pockets and says he loves them.

Personally, I'm holding out for the bigger pockets of the Rapha protein bibs.

I will carry a few tri-tips for day rides in the side pockets and I will say I love them.

ericzamora 05-05-19 02:30 PM

I've started wearing Zoic Ether MTB shorts, with a bib shirt underneath for gravel rides. An REI synthetic hiking shirt on top. The shirt is not designed for cycling, it does not promote an extra long length in back, but i have no issues with it. The Zoic shorts are a very thin but tough material, and of course have extra pockets if needed, but the idea of carrying something in a thigh area pocket doesn't seem that great to me.

Voler offers their Stow Bib bib short with 2 pockets in back. Made in California. Actually, two models, one geared towards MTB. Just $79. I don't see the need to pay close to $300 for something similar unless the chamois is lacking in the Voler product.
https://www.voler.com/browse/product/li/1110806

eric/fresno, ca.

TimothyH 05-05-19 05:27 PM


Originally Posted by ericzamora (Post 20915281)
I don't see the need to pay close to $300

Rapha Core Cargo Bibs - $150
https://www.rapha.cc/us/en_US/shop/c...uct/CCB01XXBLK


-Tim-


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:25 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.