Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Forum Suggestions & User Assistance (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=160)
-   -   Top Left "Bike Forums" logo (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1261230)

Barry2 10-19-22 10:00 AM

TRENDING... & Top Left "Bike Forums" logo
 
Top Left "Bike Forums" logo now goes to "Trending Posts"
Can we please have the List of forums back please?

Pretty Please

Barry

Barry2 10-19-22 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by hazetguy (Post 22684487)
What is up with the "trending" garbage taking up the main forum page, and it now being the default homepage?

Not quite how I phrased it...... but yes!

:)

Barry

daverup 10-19-22 11:41 AM

I also would like to see "trending" gone as the default.

Barry2 10-19-22 02:04 PM

For those wishing to render their opinion....
1. This thread is a great place.
and/or
2. "Contact Us" <<<Here is a Contact Us link, or at the bottom of this page. :) Nudge, Nudge, Wink, Wink

Thanks

Barry

Deal4Fuji 10-19-22 02:14 PM

Agree ! I always start with "new posts" and doing that takes you right into the old look we all like

Barry2 10-19-22 02:23 PM


Originally Posted by Deal4Fuji (Post 22684749)
Agree ! I always start with "new posts" and doing that takes you right into the old look we all like

Can you please give us the link for the old view?

Barry

Polaris OBark 10-19-22 02:25 PM

The problem I ran into was that everything except the first six threads has a date of 2018. I inadvertently necro-posted, and got a (polite, deserved) spank.

I think this should not be a landing page, or we are probably going to see a lot more Zombie threads.

unterhausen 10-19-22 03:12 PM

As a workaround, there is a menu along the left side that will take you into a given subforum. If you go into "general" at the top will be a link to "bike forums" and then another one to "bike forums." If you click on the second one it will give you the old view. You can do a similar thing for the other groups of subforums, like the racing forum. Except the link to the 33 is broken, at least for me. So you go into Junior racing and then click on the link to the racers forum at the top and then you can get into 33.
I'm probably just babbling at this point.

Barry2 10-19-22 03:28 PM

I think unterhausen means >> HERE <<

Barry

ShannonM 10-19-22 04:12 PM

Add another vote for either unwinding this change completely, or, in the unlikely event that more than 8 people don't hate it, at least providing a "don't tell me what posts are 'trending,' whatever the hell means, just give me the list o' forums" URL so that we can change our bookmarks and then pretend that this abomination doesn't exist.

--Shannon

OldCruiser 10-19-22 04:42 PM

I vote for the old home page . Don’t like the change .

Trakhak 10-19-22 04:48 PM

Is this another unasked-for "We have a present for you . . . "?

IBJoel 10-19-22 05:23 PM

Hi guys!

Apologies about this. While the Trending Homepage is going to be the default from now on (i.e. you will see it if you are logged out), there SHOULD have been an option to disable. I will ask tech to fix that, ASAP.

That said, the Trending Page does still have easy access to the entire list of forums.
  • On desktop, it will be on the left, under "Forum Directory".
  • On mobile, it will be in the hamburger menu on the right.

Thank you for the feedback and your understanding.

Barry2 10-19-22 05:28 PM


Originally Posted by IBJoel (Post 22684945)
Hi guys!

Apologies about this. While the Trending Homepage is going to be the default from now on (i.e. you will see it if you are logged out), there SHOULD have been an option to disable. I will ask tech to fix that, ASAP.

Thank you for the feedback and your understanding.

IBJoel ,
With all due respect, the page serves no purpose.
If you're logged out, it's not going to make the site appear easy to use and entice opening an account.
If you're logged in, it will promote posts in the incorrect sub forums.
If you know there is a way to opt-out (and where to find it), then the two above are mute. But why force an opt-out, lets go opt-in.

Sincerely

Barry

IBJoel 10-19-22 05:33 PM


Originally Posted by Barry2 (Post 22684947)
IBJoel ,
With all due respect, the page serves no purpose.
If you're logged out, it's not going to make the site appear easy to use and entice opening an account.
If you're logged in, it will promote posts in the incorrect sub forums.
If you know there is a way to opt-out (and where to find it), then the two above are mute. But why force an opt-out, lets go opt-in.

Sincerely

Barry

Our data from other sites contradicts your assertions

jon c. 10-19-22 05:43 PM

I have to assume that's the case. I've never encountered a change in a site I use frequently that was an improvement for me. But I figure they must work for someone.

Still puzzled as to why the trending posts are from 2018.

tds101 10-19-22 06:52 PM

I despise the new start screen when I log in. Please, get that opt out option up soon. UGH!!!

Deal4Fuji 10-19-22 07:15 PM


Originally Posted by Barry2 (Post 22684759)
Can you please give us the link for the old view?

Barry

Here's the link for the new posts page that gets (me) back to the old format:
https://www.bikeforums.net/search.php?searchid=14518923


Here's what I see logging on BF
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...f357c8e0f8.jpg


==============================================================================


Selecting "new posts" takes me right to the old view
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...03aa073992.jpg

unterhausen 10-19-22 08:26 PM


Originally Posted by jon c. (Post 22684955)
Still puzzled as to why the trending posts are from 2018.

I have a new theory that tomorrow all the trending posts are going to be from 2019

I can see how this might work if all the posts were actually trending.

Moe Zhoost 10-20-22 08:12 AM


Originally Posted by IBJoel (Post 22684949)
Our data from other sites contradicts your assertions

Can you share the data plus the analysis. Curious minds want to know.

IBJoel 10-20-22 09:21 AM

I've asked tech to roll back the change until we add the opt-out option in the User CP. I'll provide detailed instructions on how to turn it off when we roll it back out.

Did anyone use the hamburger menu for navigation? It contained links to essentially all forums, which would then display in the regular fashion.

IBJoel 10-20-22 09:23 AM


Originally Posted by hazetguy (Post 22685544)
Some feedback:
Sorry, but accessing the entire list of forums is not "easy" anymore. It is cumbersome to navigate, and fills up the page until you scroll to the EXACT subforum / category you want to look at.

I checked out a vast majority of the other IB owned forums, on both a desktop and mobile devices.
Their main site pages are crisp, clean, well organized, actually professional looking, and when you click on the "forum" access tabs, to the not-logged-in user such as myself, the main forum pages display as it "used to be" here, with SIMPLE AND EASY front page access to all categories and subforums. None of this "hamburger' nonsense, or you gotta go looking in lengthy multiple dropdowns to get where you want to go.
https://www.racingjunk.com/forums/
https://honda-tech.com/forums/
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/
https://mbworld.org/forums/
https://www.audiworld.com/forums/
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/
https://www.f150online.com/forums/
https://www.yotatech.com/forums/
https://www.healthboards.com/boards/index.php
https://www.doityourself.com/forum/

Heck, even flyertalk has their forum dropdown well organized, with "trending" posts on the main page at the same time.
https://www.flyertalk.com/

The only other IB site that I could find which has the "new" BF type arrangement is Fodor's travel, after you click their EASY TO USE main page forum dropdown menu and click on "View All Forums".
https://www.fodors.com/
https://www.fodors.com/community/trending.php


After seeing these other IB owned sites, I was pretty saddened as to how Bike Forums seems low budget and haphazard in comparison.

We used the same format as FlyerTalk? And Fodor's "View All Forums" just directs you to the Trending Page. I'm not really sure what your point is here. I'm also not sure how a drop down is functionally any different from a hamburger menu, besides where you click on the page?

So the issue with the Auto Comm sites you mentioned is that... they look 25 years old. The redesign is closer to more modern forums. We are also working on "Subscribed Trending"

unterhausen 10-20-22 09:25 AM

I don't recall a hamburger menu. I was using the menu along the left side of the page.
I think the issue of any such menu is you can't tell if you want to go look at new activity. Granted, it does say if there are new posts.

livedarklions 10-20-22 09:28 AM


Originally Posted by IBJoel (Post 22685641)
I've asked tech to roll back the change until we add the opt-out option in the User CP. I'll provide detailed instructions on how to turn it off when we roll it back out.

Did anyone use the hamburger menu for navigation? It contained links to essentially all forums, which would then display in the regular fashion.


The hamburger menu was a clunky way to browse the forums. Definitely not an improvement over the current forum and subforums page.

Thank you for the rollback!

IBJoel 10-20-22 09:40 AM


Originally Posted by livedarklions (Post 22685657)
The hamburger menu was a clunky way to browse the forums. Definitely not an improvement over the current forum and subforums page.

Thank you for the rollback!

I wanted to confirm you were on mobile only?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:16 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.