Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Routing hydro brake line inside Roubaix frame (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1211435)

TiHabanero 08-27-20 12:57 AM

Routing hydro brake line inside Roubaix frame
 
Working on routing rear brake line inside 2019 Specialized Roubaix frame. The frame has a BB sleeve bonded into it and the line runs on top of the sleeve and into the non drive side chain stay. There is a rubber foam tube that goes over the brake line so that it does not rattle against the frame at the BB and in the chain stay. I have pulled the brake line up from the bottom routing it over the BB sleeve and the next challenge is to slide the tube onto the line using soap solution.

One hour frame swaps are a thing of the past.

cpach 08-27-20 01:04 AM

Well that certainly sounds fun. At least with a hydraulic line you shouldn't need to ever replace it for maintenance.

Dan Burkhart 08-27-20 01:37 PM

Yeah, internal routing can be lots of fun, whether it's cables or hoses. My least favorite is the under the chainstay brakes on tri bikes with internal routing. Those are a real time sucker.

TiHabanero 08-29-20 05:25 PM

I found out just how forgiving the Shimano hydro hose is. The access hole in the BB shell is about 1.5 x .75 inch in size. Had to fold the line back on itself with the foam sleeve on it to get it routed above the BB sleeve. Line did not kink! Honestly, not sure why Specialized designed the routing over the sleeve instead of under it, unless of course, it was not designed by Specialized, but the manufacturer of the frame. Naw, I have seen Specialized do stupid stuff before, so I am sure they designed this as well.

Troul 08-29-20 07:05 PM


Originally Posted by TiHabanero (Post 21667944)
I found out just how forgiving the Shimano hydro hose is. The access hole in the BB shell is about 1.5 x .75 inch in size. Had to fold the line back on itself with the foam sleeve on it to get it routed above the BB sleeve. Line did not kink! Honestly, not sure why Specialized designed the routing over the sleeve instead of under it, unless of course, it was not designed by Specialized, but the manufacturer of the frame. Naw, I have seen Specialized do stupid stuff before, so I am sure they designed this as well.

for manufacturing cost savings reasons, this is why... --- \/

Originally Posted by Dan Burkhart (Post 21664253)
Those are a real time sucker.


cpach 08-29-20 10:06 PM

For what it's worth Specialized definitely does pretty much all the design and mockup of their frames. They are like 49% owned by their manufacturer, Merida, who also by all accounts make pretty good quality frames.

TiHabanero 08-30-20 12:11 AM

Quality of frame is not in dispute, although this frame is replacing a defective one. but internal routing of brake line is. I am sure there is a better way to do it and they know it, but as someone mentioned before, cost savings dictates reality.
Makes me wonder if the brake line is routed after the paint is applied, but before the BB sleeve is glued in place as I cannot see a manufacturer feeding the brake line over the BB sleeve and into the down tube starting from the chainstay the same way due to the time it took. Add to that the other internal routings, it makes sense to glue the sleeve into the frame last. Of course I don't know nuthin' 'bout it so just blowing wind at this point!

vespasianus 08-30-20 07:57 AM

One thing that works for me is to get a small metal insert for the brake hose and insert it into the hose end. Route is through and use a strong magnet to help "guide" it to the hole.

TiHabanero 08-30-20 03:22 PM

Vespasianus, there is no way to route the line through the frame without the method you described, the issue is getting the rubber hose over the brake line and routing it over the BB sleeve. Hard to explain it, but it is a serious time consumer. Folding the brake line over on itself had me concerned it would kink the line, but it didn't and after that with the help of another person it was smooth sailing.
The brake line is pushed/pulledhe caliper end of chain stay to the BB and routed over it then out the access hole. This is a pain in the butt, but is the only way to get to the next step. Once the line is pulled as far through as possible, then the foam tube, with the help of some lube, is slid over the line as far as possible, then the line with the tube on it is folded over and shoved back through the access hole forward of the sleeve. The helper is pulling on the Park hose tool that is connected to the brake line while I pushed the line with tube into the access hole. It is bullcrap to do it this way, but it is the only way I could come up with. Very happy the brake line did not kink, but resumed it straight form.
Specialized does not reimburse labor for warranty claims. Any profit on the bike when sold new is now gone. Profit = net zero.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:20 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.