Yep, given those changes, Giant wins in my book too ----- I really like 9 spd , as more gears are better, and 9 spd is still inexpensive to maintain,,,, how do you feel about it's looks? You get better componentry for the money.
Giant makes nice bikes, and you almost always seem to get more bike for your buck. Hydraulic brakes are the icing on the cake. I really like the looks of the Giant, and it too will hold resale.
You might be able to dicker price, using the cost of the Specialized; but, you are still getting more for your money, with Giant.
Last edited by Wanderer; 04-14-14 at 01:08 PM.