I think the worry-warts have gotten the better of the BMI ratings and what constitutes "obese". I outrun 20-year-olds in basketball (at age 41) who would blow me off the scale in terms of BMI.
I wish there was a fitness scale, like a weight scale and BMI calculator, that instantly calculates one's "fitness".
In the interim, I'm going to ignore the BMI, measure my body fat by the old pinch method, and continue on the path to between 205-210 in weight.