Dissenting Unpopular Opinion warning,
I am afflicted with big foot disorder, along with weird foot shape. This along with my non-competitive attitude means I don't do toe clips, clip-ins, or any sort of gizmo to attach my feet to the pedals. I wear athletic shoes that fit my feet and will not waste my time on bike shoes that don't fit.
I've already confessed these crimes against road biking in the "Spanish Inquisition" thread a few years back, so I don't mind mentioning it here.
Plain quill pedals hold my feet in place just fine and I don't mind losing the upstroke advantage.
You won't find me lying on the side of the road with road rash, bike securely clipped between my legs.