And I am really sorry, Stuart, but despite your extended arguments on all these threads, nothing you have said is convincing me to change my chain lube strategies.
I really doubt they are changing anyone else's, either (based on the fact that I have not seen a single post which says "I followed cyccommute's advice and wow! He's right! I am never going back to an oil based lube ever again").
I have, however, read quite a few posts where White Lightning and its ilk haven't done an adequate job.