Originally Posted by
bampilot06
consensus on tiagra? Would you guys settle for tiagra if you were buying a new bike? Comparing the 4 that i’m interested in, seems there all priced around the same between 2200 to 2800 for 105, but if I settled for tiagra, I could get the bike for 1450 to 1800.
Is there a huge difference between 105 and tiagra?
Is it something I would have to replace earlier on down the road where the 105 would last longer?
Realistically with me being back at work my average monthly miles will probably drop to 250 or less. And I would like something that will last atleast a year before I even have to utter the word bike shop or parts.
Whether you're talking hydro disc or rim, Tiagra is definitely good and performs well. To me, the main reason to go to 105 would be 11-speed, which opens you up to compatibility/better selection with the Ultegra and DA parts out there, whether you're talking consumables (chains, cassettes) or if something breaks and needs replacing down the line (RD, shift lever). You also get the additional cog, which is nice, but that alone is not worth the price premium, IMO.