Got either one available for her to test ride, in person ?
Generically women have proportionately longer legs and shorter arms and torso , so companies like Trek have Frames with a women's specific design WSD.
seat tube C-T, center to top, C-C center to tube center , or center to the top height of the seat tube, where it ends at the band clamp?
and what is the top tube length ?
Is She OK With Toe overlap with the front wheel? it's a common problem with small frames combined with big 700c wheels..
...