Originally Posted by
rubiksoval
No. I'm not one for fads and solutions to problems I don't have.
You're right in that you may not have the stopping problem. I wish I had the budget (read spousal approval) to purchase the frame, disc brakes, and wheels for a "modern" touring bicycle. Loaded touring bikes coming through the Appalachians in the rain made me want more stopping power. As to discs being a fad, I'm not sure. We follow the technology and trends of motorcycles and cars to some extent - of course not all is applicable. I'll not go back to drum brakes given the choice, but you're right I'm not planning my next used truck purchase based on disc vs drum brakes.
Being a fan of British bikes, I've always wanted to compare the stopping power of those old tourers with three speeds (maybe), and what looks-like push-rod brakes. To those vintage riders, the center-pull rim brakes would be the fad.
Thanks,
bicyforev