Originally Posted by
laura*
You're *****ed. At this point, offer the buyer a full and complete refund and tell him you will come and pick up the bike in person.
NEVER accept PayPal for local pickup items! The buyer simply has to claim non-receipt to get their money back. Because you didn't mail anything, you have no proof of shipping/delivery! That means you will lose.
Although since the guy has emailed complaining that the item was "not as described" and proposing very specific solutions it clearly shows that he has the item in his possession.