No padding saddles take a while to get used to. If you've got a 30 day return window, and your saddle is not comfortable, people will return the saddle. The saddle company makes no money.
A saddle that has too much padding may feel fine for 10 to 20 miles, but it will ultimately cause pain. I prefer firm padding and no flex with curves. I am currently riding the Specialized Romin Evo Pro. It has a
#2 padding; however, it is firm, and fits my bum.