Years ago I got a bar of Grandpa's Pine Tar soap with a purchase from Rivendell and have been using it ever since. I never have to use deodorant when I wash with it. My wife got me a 1 pound bar of Dick Cannon soap for Xmas. It, too, seems to work really well with my body chemistry and I don't need to use deodorant. I like both equally well. The Pine Tar soap has a strong odor, one that I find pleasing. Dick Cannon soap has a light scent to it when using, but it does not stay at all and rinses away.