Well...I picked up the XL Bruised Ego Purple Surly Krampus last week and so far it's been awesome! Took her out for some trail rides over the weekend, and am cruising around the neighborhood with my family.
The bike fits me so much better than my previous L Giant Rainier from 2006...much more comfortable and I am really liking the SRAM components. Riding is fun again!
Thanks to everyone for their advice and input. I'll post a picture once I get a few more posts under my belt!