Thanks everyone for the input.
I've heard from several different people (friends, family, parents, etc.) that I should start eating more vegetables and cut back on fats/sugars. It's common sense. The only issue is how can I start intaking more vegetables and fruits when I don't like any of them, even if I pair them with something I do like or add things to enhance the flavor. Part of the reason I'm not a huge lover of veggies and fruits isn't just the taste, but the texture.
As I mentioned, I cut back on my soda last fall (went from six or more a day to maybe one or two a day.) That, along with riding my bike daily, made a significant impact and I started losing some weight. Unfortunately, it didn't stick and I am back to square 1.
I'll take a look at the MFP. I have a somewhat slow Android phone that's almost out of memory, so I'm not sure if I'll be able to run it. I don't have a smart watch like a Fitbit or anything fancy like that. I don't even have a computer for my bike or a pedometer.