Originally Posted by
garethzbarker
Personally, I'm going to walk down to the sports store and grab a tin of baseball glove oil tomorrow.
I would caution that might not be a good idea. In my limited experience with a brooks saddle... mine got less comfortable as it got fully broken in and that stuff is supposed to soften leather.
I personally wouldn't buy another Brooks saddle since I didn't find it comfortable enough when new to justify the extra weight and not comfortable at all when fully broken in. But if I did buy another, I would stick with treatments that didn't soften the leather. I'd probably use Sno-Seal if I didn't want to use Proofide.