From one Newbie to another... for what it's worth I recently went through the same bike research exercise as you. I had the opportunity to closely compare the Trek DS, Giant Roam and Specialized Crosstrail. Dollar for dollar I think there is better value (components) in both the Roam & Crosstrail over the DS. In the final analysis I decided on the Crosstrail and ordered the Comp Disc yesterday. It was a toss up between the Sport Disc & the Comp Disc and only chose the latter to get to the slightly lighter frame and forks and the 2-ring compact crank. Good luck with your choice.
Last edited by Ronecol; 04-29-15 at 06:55 AM.