Originally Posted by Scrodzilla

The first couple of versions sucked. The fabric was very rough and it seems like they hadn't quite figured out what to do along the edges, which would fray really quickly and fall apart.

The updated "All Weather" models use a different fabric top and have a much slicker feel. The edges are also very smooth. My wife has been using one for a little over a year and it's holding up really well. It's still dark black and hasn't gotten ratty looking at all.