This is sort of consistent with the geo chart weirdness I've seen. Our T1/T2 frame is from 2017-a warranty replacement for what I am pretty sure was a 2015. Though I cant be sure exactly when the warranty frame was made it's the exact frame size wise. The above chart is from our original owners manual. It lists captain top tube for our L/S at 58.5 where it is actually about 56.5 or 57 at most. In fact, the chart you posted seems to match our bike. Our chart also has 71 degree ht angle for all the sizes and a 66 trail. That agrees with your number from bike geocalc but not your c-dale chart. Not sure what ours is. Your chart numbers are smaller all around, and seem to be more reasonable. 54.5 is about right for a size M, rather than the 57.1 listed above