It sounds too high, it is too high. You can throw a rock in Chicago CL and find a step-through, mixte, or small-framed road bike that's more reasonably priced. The Miyata would be my pick, but you should definitely talk to your girlfriend to narrow down the search criteria from the too-broad "casual, vintage bike."
[h=2]
Miyata Two Ten Road Touring Bike 50cm - $100 (Oak Park)[/h]
Miyata Two Ten Road Touring Bike 50cm
[h=2]
Red Nishiki Bicycle for sale. Great shape, ready to ride! - $85[/h]
Red Nishiki Bicycle for sale. Great shape, ready to ride!
[h=2]
Schwinn Le Tour womens road bike - $130[/h]
Schwinn Le Tour womens road bike
[h=2]
Vintage Raleigh Sports Bike-Women's - $115 (Bartlett)[/h]
Vintage Raleigh Sports Bike-Women's
[h=2]
Women's Schwinn Traveler 10 Speed Bicycle - $50 (Cary)[/h]
Women's Schwinn Traveler 10 Speed Bicycle