Originally Posted by
NeoY2k
Though the fundamental and pretty much theoretical question is: how can a frameset make that much of a difference in comfort when its geo is pretty much what you were expecting and that almost similar bikes did not show signs of harshness.
The Sutra was also sold with 32mm tires. Didn't felt the same - though only riding them round the block.
It is not just the tires, The frame is the basis for everything. The wheels and tires come next, but can't overcome a harsh frame. Wheels also make a difference single gauge vs double, etc and then of course the tires
Ride is a sum of the whole
if for your weight the frame and fork is too robust (like a 52 cm frame made from SLX not SL) it will be harsh. Fork design and flex is huge, straight legs may not be be as compliant as needed
frame material can make a difference alloy vs carbon vs steel
not a lot of help I know but some input for your theoretical quesstion