New Schwinn peloton or classic version?
Are the wheels 27" or 700c?
I generally use Michelin Pro4 Service course (which has been replaced by Michelin Power something or other). I tried Continental for a while because everybody and their dog swears by them around here, but I had tons of sidewall cuts.
I also generally order them 4 at a time from the UK (ribble, probikekit, merlin cycles, whatever has a good price on what I'm shopping for.
This is also a screaming deal:
https://planetcyclery.com/components...endurance-tire
krylion appears to be the name for teh former Pro4 Endurance tire, which I like.
Shop around - they're consumables! You won't be stuck with any particular tire for too long, they wear out.