Originally Posted by
The 585
Looking for a versatile bike, preferably drop-bar with steel frame, for a 12 mile each way commute. I also want to cruise around the paved trails for 20-30 mile exercise rides, and occasionally pick up some groceries. It would need eyelets for a rack, and room for fenders. Would you get a touring bike or cyclocross bike? Thanks!
Well, CX vs Touring is rather opposite ends of the spectrum. I like a CX bike because it is very nimble and can corner hard for nimble handling in urban situations.
A touring bike will have a lower center of gravity, a longer wheelbase, and tend to be more stable (and have more room for fenders). For most people, the touring bike would be best (unless you want light fast and nimble).
Of course the newer breed of gravel bike would work great too (allows a broad range of tire sizes - up to 40-45mm.