Originally Posted by
MikeyMK
I just don't see how they can be comfortable. They look like a saddle with all the padding torn off. I can push my entire thumb into my saddle. Are they any good for sitting upright?
Shape determines function. B-67 saddles are for upright riding, and have a suspension. B17 saddles are for more aggressive positions, and the Swifts and Swallows are considered racing style.
If the leather was glued to a shell throughout, it likely wouldn't be as comfortable. The leather is stretched on the frame, with no other support in between. The leather itself is stiff, but under your weight conforms and cradles your pelvis. It feels like firm padding on a conventional saddle.