If This Rear Deraillier Gets Bent, Can It Be Replaced
#1
If This Rear Deraillier Gets Bent, Can It Be Replaced
I just got this 2008 road bike. Looking at the rear deraillier hanger, it seems ok .
The problem i am wondering about is that
I don't see any way to replace it if it gets damaged. Is it really unfixable if damaged?
The problem i am wondering about is that
I don't see any way to replace it if it gets damaged. Is it really unfixable if damaged?
#2
SE Wis
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Milwaukee, WI
Posts: 10,811
Bikes: '68 Raleigh Sprite, '02 Raleigh C500, '84 Raleigh Gran Prix, '91 Trek 400, 2013 Novara Randonee, 1990 Trek 970
Liked 3,655 Times
in
2,201 Posts
Anything is fixable The question is cost effectively
Likes For dedhed:
#3
Full Member
Join Date: Oct 2023
Posts: 426
Bikes: '00 LS Vortex/Chorus 12/Campag Zondas, '98 LS Classic/Chorus 10/Rolf Vector Pros
Liked 365 Times
in
208 Posts
is it aluminum? Then I guess you might get one -two “bend backs” out of it. If it’s steel, then it’ll be fine - this was once how all dropouts looked. In any case, in the unlikely event that you do bend it, most things are repairable in the hands of a decent frame builder. Are you expecting to bend it? I’ve gone ~35 years since I last damaged an RD hanger - it’s a relatively rare occurrence if you look after your bike. Perceived repairability/nonrepairability wouldn’t be a factor if I was looking to buy a frame
Likes For 13ollocks:
Likes For mixteup:
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: New Rochelle, NY
Posts: 39,639
Bikes: too many bikes from 1967 10s (5x2)Frejus to a Sumitomo Ti/Chorus aluminum 10s (10x2), plus one non-susp mtn bike I use as my commuter
Liked 3,480 Times
in
1,911 Posts
As pointed out, it is repairable but won't be cheap or simple.
If the frame is still in production, a replacement a replacement dropout can be had and bonded in place, making a good as new repair.
Or, if there's enough left, it can be modified to accept a bolt on hanger.
Or, you could fabricate a hanger and a skilled welder could attach it.
Best bet is to try real.hard not to crack it.
Note, heating it will improve the chances of straightening without cracking. But aluminum is extremely conductive, so the question is whether the bonding adhesive can take the necessary heat.
If the frame is still in production, a replacement a replacement dropout can be had and bonded in place, making a good as new repair.
Or, if there's enough left, it can be modified to accept a bolt on hanger.
Or, you could fabricate a hanger and a skilled welder could attach it.
Best bet is to try real.hard not to crack it.
Note, heating it will improve the chances of straightening without cracking. But aluminum is extremely conductive, so the question is whether the bonding adhesive can take the necessary heat.
Last edited by FBinNY; 11-10-23 at 06:28 AM.
#6
Senior Member
I may be wrong, but it looks like forged steel to me. Highly unlikely to bend, and any crash that does bend it is probably going to crack the stays (or at least the joint) anyway.
Likes For Jeff Neese:
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: New Rochelle, NY
Posts: 39,639
Bikes: too many bikes from 1967 10s (5x2)Frejus to a Sumitomo Ti/Chorus aluminum 10s (10x2), plus one non-susp mtn bike I use as my commuter
Liked 3,480 Times
in
1,911 Posts
Both the color and fabrication scream aluminum. Though it's easy enough to check with a magnet or file.
Likes For FBinNY:
#8
Senior Member
Anything's possible, but I don't think Trek ever used steel dropouts/fork ends in their carbon or aluminum frames. The pictured dropouts are thicker than steel would be, or so it looks to me, and the finish is the uniform dullness of aluminum. FBinNY and several other experienced posters seem to have taken for granted that the dropouts are aluminum, as did I. If the OP wonders, a magnet test would answer the question immediately.
Likes For Trakhak:
#9
No one is going to be welding an inch away from an epoxy bond.
The world was absolutely full of non-replaceable aluminum derailleur hangers at one time, and it really wasn't a big issue. Dropouts like that are much tougher than the soft stuff replaceable hangers are made from, and can take quite a bit more impact before bending. I hate replaceable hanger - they might as well be made of lead.
It isn't worth worrying about.
The world was absolutely full of non-replaceable aluminum derailleur hangers at one time, and it really wasn't a big issue. Dropouts like that are much tougher than the soft stuff replaceable hangers are made from, and can take quite a bit more impact before bending. I hate replaceable hanger - they might as well be made of lead.
It isn't worth worrying about.
Likes For Kontact:
#10
Old fart
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Appleton WI
Posts: 25,043
Bikes: Several, mostly not name brands.
Liked 3,675 Times
in
2,077 Posts
Looks like a Trek bonded aluminum frame and dropout to me. If the dropout breaks, the whole dropout would need to be replaced. It could be difficult sourcing a replacement, and also difficult cleanly removing the damaged dropout and bonding the replacement. If only the hanger breaks, a functional replacement could be cobbled up from claw-type hangers or a generic replacement hanger.
Likes For JohnDThompson:
#11
If just the hanger or rear part of the dropout broke it could be TIG welded back together, being very careful to prevent heat build-up in the bonded areas (needs to be kept below about 60°C, which might be difficult when the weld is about 700°C and aluminium is a good conductor of heat). That's assuming that the aluminium is weldable at all, which depends on which specific alloy it is - 7075 is great for forging but will microcrack if you try to weld it. If it wasn't possible to weld in place you could remove the end by careful application of heat to the bonded areas; then weld repair the original, or find or make another end that fits, to glue in. Makes you glad to have replaceable hangers.
Likes For grumpus:
#12
If just the hanger or rear part of the dropout broke it could be TIG welded back together, being very careful to prevent heat build-up in the bonded areas (needs to be kept below about 60°C, which might be difficult when the weld is about 700°C and aluminium is a good conductor of heat). That's assuming that the aluminium is weldable at all, which depends on which specific alloy it is - 7075 is great for forging but will microcrack if you try to weld it. If it wasn't possible to weld in place you could remove the end by careful application of heat to the bonded areas; then weld repair the original, or find or make another end that fits, to glue in. Makes you glad to have replaceable hangers.
Likes For Kontact:
#13
It would be interesting, but you can cool with dry ice or liquid nitrogen, or those pipe freezers that plumbers use on water pipes - the challenge would be to maintain a steady heat gradient while welding, as you can't chill the weld pool. But I suspect it's not a weldable alloy anyway.
Indeed - whether steel or aluminium, good forged ends are remarkably tough. OTOH early bonded frames tended to be rather flexy and make worrying noises.
Indeed - whether steel or aluminium, good forged ends are remarkably tough. OTOH early bonded frames tended to be rather flexy and make worrying noises.
Likes For grumpus:
#14
It would be interesting, but you can cool with dry ice or liquid nitrogen, or those pipe freezers that plumbers use on water pipes - the challenge would be to maintain a steady heat gradient while welding, as you can't chill the weld pool. But I suspect it's not a weldable alloy anyway.
Indeed - whether steel or aluminium, good forged ends are remarkably tough. OTOH early bonded frames tended to be rather flexy and make worrying noises.
Indeed - whether steel or aluminium, good forged ends are remarkably tough. OTOH early bonded frames tended to be rather flexy and make worrying noises.
Likes For Kontact:
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Boulder County, CO
Posts: 4,556
Bikes: '80 Masi Gran Criterium, '12 Trek Madone, early '60s Frejus track
Liked 509 Times
in
384 Posts
Looks like a Trek bonded aluminum frame and dropout to me. If the dropout breaks, the whole dropout would need to be replaced. It could be difficult sourcing a replacement, and also difficult cleanly removing the damaged dropout and bonding the replacement. If only the hanger breaks, a functional replacement could be cobbled up from claw-type hangers or a generic replacement hanger.
Likes For oldbobcat:
#16
Senior Member
Honestly, I wouldn't worry about it until you have a damaged hanger. As mentioned, minor bends can be re-aligned usually more than once. Just retired a 25-year-old alu frame that had its non-replaceable hanger re-aligned at least 5 times in its lifetime before the headtube developed cracks. Ride and enjoy until you actually need a replacement. It has already survived 15 years without damage.
Last edited by Crankycrank; 11-11-23 at 07:29 AM.
#17
I thought the idea behind the hanger is it gives us a part that is relatively easy to replace, so we do not have to junk a frame due to a small flaw in the point where wheels attach.
#18
Senior Member
They can be straightened a few times if the hanger isn't bent badly but more than a few times and there's a good chance of it snapping. The issue of breaking leading to replacement hangers was largely around MTbs that are more prone to crashing through rough terrain and bending the hanger. Most of the issues I've had with bent hangers revolved around the kids knocking them over while leaning against the car waiting to be put on the rack. With anything that sees dirt or child use, replaceable is a good idea, otherwise I don't see it as a concern. If it did snap I'd go to the local shop and find a hanger that matched up enough that I could use a dremel and make it fit.
Likes For Russ Roth:
#19
Full Member
Join Date: Oct 2023
Posts: 426
Bikes: '00 LS Vortex/Chorus 12/Campag Zondas, '98 LS Classic/Chorus 10/Rolf Vector Pros
Liked 365 Times
in
208 Posts
I believe the "RD hanger as a sacrificial component" concept came about with the advent of Al and CF frames. Prior to this, steel frames had fixed hangers that could be bent straight multiple times without breaking, and/or were built sufficiently stout that it would take a significant impact to incur any damage*. Al is less amenable to multiple rebends, and CF not at all - hence the replaceable hanger. However, hanger damage isn't "all or nothing" - most RD impacts aren't hanger-destroying events - an Al hanger could sustain sufficient bend to throw off the shifting and still be almost invisibly out of alignment. Such small bends are likely multiply straightenable without fatally compromising the hanger strength, and are also largely avoidable - absent crashes - by simply watching how you treat your bike - ensuring that it doesn't fall over, keeping the RD safe, and if you have to lie it down, placing it non-drive-side downward.
*the fixed hanger on my bike is 5/16" titanium plate - I suspect that the RD would be completely destroyed before the hanger or frame took any damage
*the fixed hanger on my bike is 5/16" titanium plate - I suspect that the RD would be completely destroyed before the hanger or frame took any damage
Likes For 13ollocks:
#20
I believe the "RD hanger as a sacrificial component" concept came about with the advent of Al and CF frames. Prior to this, steel frames had fixed hangers that could be bent straight multiple times without breaking, and/or were built sufficiently stout that it would take a significant impact to incur any damage*. Al is less amenable to multiple rebends, and CF not at all - hence the replaceable hanger. However, hanger damage isn't "all or nothing" - most RD impacts aren't hanger-destroying events - an Al hanger could sustain sufficient bend to throw off the shifting and still be almost invisibly out of alignment. Such small bends are likely multiply straightenable without fatally compromising the hanger strength, and are also largely avoidable - absent crashes - by simply watching how you treat your bike - ensuring that it doesn't fall over, keeping the RD safe, and if you have to lie it down, placing it non-drive-side downward.
*the fixed hanger on my bike is 5/16" titanium plate - I suspect that the RD would be completely destroyed before the hanger or frame took any damage
*the fixed hanger on my bike is 5/16" titanium plate - I suspect that the RD would be completely destroyed before the hanger or frame took any damage
A few years ago,someone on this site posted his opinion that minor bends to deraillier hanger is so common that having a spare on hand is important. I have never replaced one or thought one might be damaged. I just thought it is important to be able to replace one.
I thought the idea behind the hanger is it gives us a part that is relatively easy to replace, so we do not have to junk a frame due to a small flaw in the point where wheels attach.
I thought the idea behind the hanger is it gives us a part that is relatively easy to replace, so we do not have to junk a frame due to a small flaw in the point where wheels attach.
It's a compromise - you can have a stiff, reliable hanger; or a replaceable one.
What's hilarious is that early on, Wheels Manufacturing offered steel hangers for those who were tired of flexible aluminum ones. Which is ironic because a steel hanger bolted to an aluminum dropout would definitely destroy the frame in the event of a crash. They discontinued those pretty quick.
Likes For Kontact:
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Northern NY...Brownville
Posts: 2,657
Bikes: Specialized Aethos, Specialized Diverge Comp E5
Liked 512 Times
in
308 Posts
It can be 'realigned' if it is out of alignment. It is a one piece aluminum dropout/hanger. Unlikely to find a replacement due to age of frame.
If the hanger needs aligning take your time and use a proper alignment tool. If you just crank on it it is possible it will snap and then you are SOL.
If realigned many without a problem by taking my time and making small adjustments. I've never had to use heat. I have watched a coworker snap one because he just cranked on it...dead bike on a scrap pile.
That dropout is one of the reasons why replaceable hangers were invented...
Good luck and keep us informed.
If the hanger needs aligning take your time and use a proper alignment tool. If you just crank on it it is possible it will snap and then you are SOL.
If realigned many without a problem by taking my time and making small adjustments. I've never had to use heat. I have watched a coworker snap one because he just cranked on it...dead bike on a scrap pile.
That dropout is one of the reasons why replaceable hangers were invented...
Good luck and keep us informed.
Likes For Kai Winters:
#22
Likes For grumpus:
#23
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 16,142
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Liked 5,404 Times
in
3,729 Posts
What Trek bike is that. Some seem to think it's a CF bike. But I was thinking it's a aluminum bike.
Didn't Trek make a aluminum bike with bonded aluminum tubes back in the previous Century?
Just curious. So no real help for your question other than I agree it'll come down to exactly how it gets ruined which will dictate how it needs to be fixed. Cost may well be more than it's worth to you.
Didn't Trek make a aluminum bike with bonded aluminum tubes back in the previous Century?
Just curious. So no real help for your question other than I agree it'll come down to exactly how it gets ruined which will dictate how it needs to be fixed. Cost may well be more than it's worth to you.
Likes For Iride01:
#24
So I don't know what you are talking about.
Likes For Kontact:
#25
That's OK, it was long enough ago that I don't remember the details, could have been Vitus or Alan or some other, not a clue as to model or year (some time mid-1980s?) and I don't need to convince anyone of anything.
Likes For grumpus: