Swede1

Hi all, Moved to AZ and have many trails just around the corner, and not loving the options for road biking so I figured I would add a "mountain" bike to the stable.

Adding the " " since I haven't paid attention to the field in 20 years, and apparently now there are many versions of these bikes. So the first question, what type of bike would fit someone that wants to ride simpler trails, no interest in downhill etc?

Second, the dreaded, any recommendations on a make/model question...perhaps looking to spend $2-2.5K. There are plenty of local bikeshops, but some solely carry models that I have never heard of (e.g. rage cycles in Scottsdale) and some carry the Treks, etc.

Third, I got fitted for my road bike (turns out I have a short upper body so definitely needed modifications)--how important is this for a MTB? it seems as though you are not as static when you are on a trail, so perhaps not as important?

Any input would be helpful/

2cam16

For simple trails, I'd go with an XC type of bike. Full suspension if you can afford it although hardtail will work.One with a dropper post too again if it fits within your budget. As to make and model, there are just too many out there nowadays. Most modern mtb's have gone in the 1x direction. A lot of them are good too. Some of the Youtube channels I subscribe to do some bike reviews. Try searching on YT. That may help.

carlosponti

where in AZ are you? arizona has some gnarly trails in some parts. 2500 can get you a nice trail bike. for gnarly trails id get a full suspension with a trail bike configuration.

Darth Lefty 

Ordinarily I'd say pick a bike shop and do some test rides. But you picked a hell of a week.

I'd go for a trail bike, they are just the most fun. As for what you want to get, if you want to keep your local bike shop afloat, ask them what they recommend. It's really unlikely you'll get a turd. Spring sales are going on now.

Your budget is kind of in-between, it's higher than most hardtail bikes, you could get a nice one. It's about the bottom for full suspension, which are yes a little more complicated, but also not available with cheaper and lighter-duty components.

colombo357

The price of MTBs have gone way up in the last 10 or so years, significantly outpacing inflation, so you might be in for some sticker shock.

How firm is your budget?

What kind of road bike(s) are you currently riding, and what are the component specs? Just trying to get a feel of what your expectations are.

Swede1

North Phoenix, so plenty of trails right outside.

Swede1

I guess I could go a little higher, just want to make sure I am happy and no second guessing a week after i buy it

Specialized Roubaix Elite with stock components. Love it!

colombo357

With your road background, I might suggest an XC hardtail with fast rolling tires and 29" wheels.

https://www.specialized.com/us/en/ep...ext=91319-3102

https://www.canyon.com/en-us/mountai...-7.0/2427.html

The component spec on both these bikes would be roughly equivalent to a "base" Ultegra spec'd road bike, meaning Ultegra drivetrain mixed with lower level brakes and wheels.

Swede1

Thank you Colombo....now, yesterday I do what I seemingly always do....I jump right in and do something impulsive (simply want to get out riding since there is not much else to do in the evenings). Went to a local store that actually was open...looking at their specialized models. The first couple of bikes that I liked, unfortunately where out of stock once we realized I would be better off with an XL. They offered me a rental, but quite frankly it did not seem like a great deal (30% off when new bikes where also 30% off). Finally we came to an agreement to the next bike up---also on sale:Stumpjumper ST Comp Carbon 29. The sales person was very convincing that I would be happy.....I hope I will. I really did like the feel of dual suspension.

Clearly the budget was stretched, now my problem is how this message will be delivered to my wife.

colombo357

Nice choice. You won't be disappointed.

I know you said "no interest in downhill" in your original post, but with a capable trail bike like the StumpJumper, your opinion may change in time.

CodyDog

You chose a great MTB. Congrats!

qclabrat

Pics please and of your local trails. All State and county parks are closed so parks are limited

Wileyrat

I just spent some time riding trails in a Pima County park that is absolutely open, as is the Az state park a few miles from my home.

Suguaro NP is another story.

2old

There should be some excellent choices in your price range, even for full suspension considering the current "climate", and the fact that shops are hemorrhaging. Shops in my area are closed, but you can make an appointment for a "hands off" test ride and they'll even deliver a purchase. If you purchase from a major brand, (Trek, Specialized, Giant) you almost can't go wrong (IMO). I agree with the XC recommendation too, best overall for mild trail riding.

Chad991

In that price range, all around fantastic bike if you want a hardtail, look at the Santa Cruz Chameleon 27.5 or 29er, good sram drive trains, boost frames ...nice bikes

Swede1

Well, one week into the new bike, and wow has this been a reality check.

Regularly riding 40 miles on the roadbike I thought this should be a no-brainer. First ride out, figured I would take it easy and do the 14 mile loop, After 45 minutes I looked at the map and realized it would never happen--I was 3 miles out. Heart rate was never below 180!

Second ride, tried a trail by my house....quickly turned into a hike-with-a-bike---should definitely read the ratings.

Anyway, it is a blast....a few things I have learned:

Mountain bikes simply do not do what you want them to
Cacti really hurts...and they are a lot harder than they seem
Rocks are scary
A 2L Camelback is definitely not big enough

Darth Lefty 

Yeah, it’s a lot more... acute.

Stay away from the teddy bear cholla, I remember those from my childhood

tar wheels 

She's a beaut, Clark!