Thoughts on the Felt Broam (vs Breed, etc.)?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thoughts on the Felt Broam (vs Breed, etc.)?
Looks like Felt has a new gravel bike – The Broam. The top end version (Broam 30) is aluminum with a carbon fork, a 105 groupset with hydraulic brakes, and 700x40 tires for $1800.
https://feltbicycles.com/collections...ture-road-bike
Gearing is decent – 48/32 and 11-34. Stack/Reach ratio is a bit high at 1.57. Bottom bracket drop is 72mm. And the wheelbase is pretty long (106.6 @ size 56). The one oddity is that the front brake rotor is 160mm while the rear is 140.
In many ways it's similar but different than the Felt Breed – the Breed comes with 650x47 tires, has a lower stack/reach (1.52), a taller top tube, a 160mm rear rotor, a shorter wheelbase, and costs $100 more for some reason I'm not seeing at first glance.
Neither the Broam nor the Breed really talk about max tire clearance.
Any thoughts on the Broam vs some of the other new gravel bikes like the Checkpoint, the Topstone, the Revolt, etc.?
https://feltbicycles.com/collections...ture-road-bike
Gearing is decent – 48/32 and 11-34. Stack/Reach ratio is a bit high at 1.57. Bottom bracket drop is 72mm. And the wheelbase is pretty long (106.6 @ size 56). The one oddity is that the front brake rotor is 160mm while the rear is 140.
In many ways it's similar but different than the Felt Breed – the Breed comes with 650x47 tires, has a lower stack/reach (1.52), a taller top tube, a 160mm rear rotor, a shorter wheelbase, and costs $100 more for some reason I'm not seeing at first glance.
Neither the Broam nor the Breed really talk about max tire clearance.
Any thoughts on the Broam vs some of the other new gravel bikes like the Checkpoint, the Topstone, the Revolt, etc.?
Last edited by JayNYC; 09-10-18 at 08:05 AM.
#2
Sunshine
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Des Moines, IA
Posts: 16,610
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
Mentioned: 123 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 10954 Post(s)
Liked 7,483 Times
in
4,185 Posts
Looks like Felt has a new gravel bike – The Broam. The top end version (Broam 30) is aluminum with a carbon fork, a 105 groupset with hydraulic brakes, and 700x40 tires for $1800.
Gearing is decent – 48/32 and 11-34. Stack/Reach ratio is a bit high at 1.57.
In many ways it's similar but different than the Felt Breed – the Breed comes with 650x47 tires, has a lower stack/reach (1.52),
Gearing is decent – 48/32 and 11-34. Stack/Reach ratio is a bit high at 1.57.
In many ways it's similar but different than the Felt Breed – the Breed comes with 650x47 tires, has a lower stack/reach (1.52),
Curious why the stack and reach has been put into a ratio. What does that accomplish? Stack and reach vary from bike to bike and there is no good or bad setup since everyone is different. There is no ideal ratio.
Or am I misunderstanding your comments?
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Last edited by JayNYC; 09-10-18 at 08:52 AM.
#4
Sunshine
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Des Moines, IA
Posts: 16,610
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
Mentioned: 123 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 10954 Post(s)
Liked 7,483 Times
in
4,185 Posts
Stack/reach ratio is a thing (google it). The lower the number the more stretched out you are, the higher the number the more upright you are. It's a general overview number. Yes, when you get more particular you'll want to drill down to actual stack and reach numbers, but at first glance the ratio is useful.
Just a curious observation since there is no ideal ratio.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
For sure its a thing, but i moreso am asking why its being mentioned at all in terms of a review of a bike as if its a good or bad thing. You mentioned the 1.57 ratio being 'a bit high', but it isnt a bit high if it fits someone with longer legs and a shorter torso/arms. To that person, the other ratio of 1.52 may be a bit low.
Just a curious observation since there is no ideal ratio.
Just a curious observation since there is no ideal ratio.
#6
Sunshine
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Des Moines, IA
Posts: 16,610
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
Mentioned: 123 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 10954 Post(s)
Liked 7,483 Times
in
4,185 Posts
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I asked Felt about max tire clearance. They gave me a lecture about ISO standards, then said 700C x 45 for the Broam and 650b x 2.1 (53) for the Breed. I had asked max for 700C and 650b for both, so still waiting to hear 650b for Broam and 700C for Breed.
Ah yes, they seem to have a new "adventure" category on their site. Both were in the gravel section a few days ago. But other than marketing terms, what's the substantive difference between those two categories? Or, put another way, why can't the Broam be a gravel bike or the Breed an "adventure" / touring / bikepacking bike?
For the hell of it, since we're talking about the Breed just as much as the Broam, here's the pic of the Breed 30…
For the hell of it, since we're talking about the Breed just as much as the Broam, here's the pic of the Breed 30…
#9
Reno/Seattle/NYC
I asked Felt about max tire clearance. They gave me a lecture about ISO standards, then said 700C x 45 for the Broam and 650b x 2.1 (53) for the Breed. I had asked max for 700C and 650b for both, so still waiting to hear 650b for Broam and 700C for Breed.
Ah yes, they seem to have a new "adventure" category on their site. Both were in the gravel section a few days ago. But other than marketing terms, what's the substantive difference between those two categories? Or, put another way, why can't the Broam be a gravel bike or the Breed an "adventure" / touring / bikepacking bike?
Ah yes, they seem to have a new "adventure" category on their site. Both were in the gravel section a few days ago. But other than marketing terms, what's the substantive difference between those two categories? Or, put another way, why can't the Broam be a gravel bike or the Breed an "adventure" / touring / bikepacking bike?
I have an F75 from 2007 that has always been a bit big for me, and am looking at gravel/adventure/light touring bikes for its eventual replacement. In 2007 Felt was pretty much second to none in terms of value for components, and while the Breed and Broam seem to be a little bit cheaper than some other brands, I wish it they were more competitive with the Topstone.
#10
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Broam…
Frame: Felt Adventure Road Disc Superlite custom butted aluminum, smooth welded construction, BSA threaded 68mm bottom bracket shell, 12 x 142mm with Syntace style thru axle, flat mount disc brake standard, replaceable rear derailleur hanger, internal mechanical cable routing Shock:
Fork: Felt Adventure Gravel UHC Advanced carbon fiber monocoque construction, ControlTaper 1.125" - 1.5" aluminum steerer tube, flat mount disc standard, 12 x 100mm thru axle with mid-mount rack and fender mounts
Breed…
Frame: Felt Gravel Race Disc Superlite custom butted aluminum, hydroform smooth welded construction, T47 86 bottom bracket shell, 12 x 142mm with Syntace style thru axle, flat mount disc brake standard, replaceable rear derailleur hanger, internal mechanical cable routing Shock:
Fork: Felt Adventure Gravel UHC Advanced carbon fiber monocoque construction, ControlTaper 1.125" - 1.5" aluminum steerer tube, flat mount disc standard, 12 x 100mm thru axle
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I have an F75 from 2007 that has always been a bit big for me, and am looking at gravel/adventure/light touring bikes for its eventual replacement. In 2007 Felt was pretty much second to none in terms of value for components, and while the Breed and Broam seem to be a little bit cheaper than some other brands, I wish it they were more competitive with the Topstone.
#12
Reno/Seattle/NYC
You can get an Ultegra CAADX for $2050… $50 more than many/most of the 105-equipped gravel bikes…
I am intrigued by the extra rack/fender mounts on Broam and Topstone.
I notice there's slightly different gearing between the Broam and Breed as well. 46/30 vs 48/32, but hardly that big of a difference.
#13
Banned
Your LBS, sells Felt bikes? mine, nearby does but it does not stock Many $2K bikes ,
more MTB than gravel racing.
go on a test ride ..
more MTB than gravel racing.
go on a test ride ..
#14
Senior Member
Thread Starter
And having heard several of you bemoan that your LBS will only let you do circles in the parking lot – that's another advantage of NYC – since our bike shops don't have parking lots, you leave ID and a credit card with the bike shop and can take off for 30 min to an hour if needed. Go to Central Park or wherever you need to go to test the bike.
#15
Reno/Seattle/NYC
I live in Manhattan, there are probably 20 reputable LBSs near me. Pretty much everything is sold here. There are a bunch of bikes I'd like to test ride, and I figure it will help to do the test rides close in time to each other, so I'm waiting for all the new bikes to be announced, for dealers to get them in stock, and then I'll set up a weekend where I ride from bike shop to bike shop and do test rides.
And having heard several of you bemoan that your LBS will only let you do circles in the parking lot – that's another advantage of NYC – since our bike shops don't have parking lots, you leave ID and a credit card with the bike shop and can take off for 30 min to an hour if needed. Go to Central Park or wherever you need to go to test the bike.
And having heard several of you bemoan that your LBS will only let you do circles in the parking lot – that's another advantage of NYC – since our bike shops don't have parking lots, you leave ID and a credit card with the bike shop and can take off for 30 min to an hour if needed. Go to Central Park or wherever you need to go to test the bike.
Living in Washington Heights is sort of the impetus for shopping for a gravel/adventure bike too. Commuting by fixed-gear up and down the hill every day is getting tough on the knees, and 23mm tires are getting hard to handle on the streets, especially when commuting in the winter.
#16
Full Member
In many ways it's similar but different than the Felt Breed – the Breed comes with 650x47 tires, has a lower stack/reach (1.52), a taller top tube, a 160mm rear rotor, a shorter wheelbase, and costs $100 more for some reason I'm not seeing at first glance.
It also has different cockpit pieces (most notably the carbon seatpost) and what I assume is a nicer crankset. These things probably make up the $100 difference.
Ah yes, they seem to have a new "adventure" category on their site. Both were in the gravel section a few days ago. But other than marketing terms, what's the substantive difference between those two categories? Or, put another way, why can't the Broam be a gravel bike or the Breed an "adventure" / touring / bikepacking bike?
That being said, the Breed seems to have a bit more of 'race' slant towards it, but why couldn't you also bikepack the hell out of it?
#17
Full Member
The Breed also has three bottle mounts inside the triangle, which I think is a super cool feature.
I think I really like this bike!
I think I really like this bike!
#18
Senior Member
Thread Starter
The person answering questions for Felt on Facebook didn't really understand my question about tire size, but s/he went and asked a production manager who did understand. Bottom line, both the Breed and Broam have the same tire size limitations. The max sizes are 700C x 45mm or 650b x 2.1" (53mm). It's just the Breed comes with 650b wheels and the Broam with 700C wheels.
That's actually pretty sweet. It gives a lot of workable options. Everything pretty much works – from 700x25 road tires on up to 650x53.
And one correction from what I stated in my original post (they changed the specs on the website) – both the Breed and the Broam have 160mm brake rotors on the front and 140mm on the back.
That's actually pretty sweet. It gives a lot of workable options. Everything pretty much works – from 700x25 road tires on up to 650x53.
And one correction from what I stated in my original post (they changed the specs on the website) – both the Breed and the Broam have 160mm brake rotors on the front and 140mm on the back.
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Cascadia
Posts: 1,206
Bikes: Jamis Quest Comp
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 169 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times
in
3 Posts
You can get an Ultegra CAADX for $2050… $50 more than many/most of the 105-equipped gravel bikes…
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Cannondale hasn't gotten back to me on my max tire width question so no official answer, but based on comments I've seen in reviews, etc. the max is 700x37 or 650x47. The 105 version ships with 37s, so maybe it can go a bit higher than that – 38 or 40.
In terms of geometry BB drop on the CAADX is 68 vs 72 on the Breed & Broam. Which means the BB height is pretty close with max tire sizes, but the Breed & Broam get 4mm lower when you put skinny road tires on (260 vs 264). Both are in the range of "normal" BB heights.
And the stack/reach ratio for the CAADX is the same as it is for the Breed. At the size that probably fits me best, the stack for the CAADX is between the values for the Breed & Broam. Reach is just slightly more than the Breed. The seat tube angle is a 1/2 degree more on the CAADX. Wheelbase is between the Breed & the Broam.
So CAADX is pretty close to the Breed & the Broam. It just has smaller max tire sizes.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Ohio
Posts: 2,857
Bikes: Road bike, Hybrid, Gravel, Drop bar SS, hard tail MTB
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1218 Post(s)
Liked 298 Times
in
214 Posts
the Breed is more attractive to me than the Broam. As for the Broam, I'd pick the Cannondale Topstone first. Cannondale SAVE tech on an AL frame will be miles more comfortable than any other AL frame on the market. My opinion. and It is only $1,650 leaving you with enough $ to go buy the tires of your choice.
I have been looking at the 2019 Revolt.
I have been looking at the 2019 Revolt.
#22
Reno/Seattle/NYC
the Breed is more attractive to me than the Broam. As for the Broam, I'd pick the Cannondale Topstone first. Cannondale SAVE tech on an AL frame will be miles more comfortable than any other AL frame on the market. My opinion. and It is only $1,650 leaving you with enough $ to go buy the tires of your choice.
I have been looking at the 2019 Revolt.
I have been looking at the 2019 Revolt.
Off the top of my head, of the big bikes in this category, I think only the Diverge and Haanjo have higher stack/reach ratios than the Broam.
#24
padawan
Did you get the Breed? My LBS just got a Breed 30 in my size and I'll probably buy it. I love the huge tire clearance and 650b. I wish it was carbon but then it'd be a different price. $1900 for a bike I won't actually ride that often seems about right.
#25
Reno/Seattle/NYC
Let us know what you think of it if you test ride it! The Broam/Breed are high in the running for me right now too, but I haven't found one to test yet.