Best Puncture Resistant Tires?
#26
Senior Member
Thread Starter
The Gatorskin folding tire rides better than the hardshell IMO. I ride 28 mm so I really do not notice a harsh ride. I do not understand why there are so many complaints re: Gatorskins. I cannot see spending $50+ for a tire when I can get Gatorskins for around $35 and they will last 5K miles. I am a recreational-touristy type cyclist so watts and speed really do not apply to me.
#27
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Michelin Protek Cross Max. The toughest tire I've ever ridden. Never a puncture flat. I've picked out broken glass, small nails and tacks, bits of steel wire from radial tires, but nothing ever penetrated the puncture shield. The thick tread has been slashed down to where the yellow Aramid fiber puncture shield is visible, but nothing penetrated through to nick the tube. Possibly the perfect tire for bombed out roads and folks who are forced to ride the debris-strewn shoulders and gutters.
It's heavy but I use it only on one hybrid that I use for errands and casual rides. The tires don't feel sluggish on that bike, probably because I don't expect it to feel fast.
My other lighter, sportier hybrid wears Continental SpeedRides, a great all purpose tire with a minimal 1 mm thick puncture shield. It's had a few puncture flats, but not enough to worry about.
On my road bikes, I'd rather deal with an occasional flat than ride the lead filled garden hose known as Gatorskins. My only concession to practicality is I use Conti Ultra Sport II tires for everyday use. They're remarkably grippy, tough, durable, smooth rolling and resistant to punctures and cuts despite lacking any puncture shield. And at around $15 each, I don't even care if one gets cut to pieces. So far I'll wear them out from ordinary riding before they get enough nicks to do any damage. The last puncture flat I got was nearly two years ago.
I have a few somewhat better clincher tires: Schwalbe One V-Guards, Conti Grand Prix Classic, Vredestein Fortezza Tricomp. Occasionally I'll mount those when I feel like chasing a KOM or PR. But they're a bit more fragile. One of the first Schwalbe Ones I got was cut to pieces long before the tread was close to being worn out.
If I wanted a puncture resistant tire for a road bike, I'd probably try a Michelin Protek Urban, or one of their tougher road bike tires like the Pro 4 Grip Service Course. Based on my experience with the Protek Cross Max, the Aramid fiber shield seems to ride better than just slapping on extra thick rubber for puncture resistance -- which is pretty much what Schwalbe and Continental do for some tires.
It's heavy but I use it only on one hybrid that I use for errands and casual rides. The tires don't feel sluggish on that bike, probably because I don't expect it to feel fast.
My other lighter, sportier hybrid wears Continental SpeedRides, a great all purpose tire with a minimal 1 mm thick puncture shield. It's had a few puncture flats, but not enough to worry about.
On my road bikes, I'd rather deal with an occasional flat than ride the lead filled garden hose known as Gatorskins. My only concession to practicality is I use Conti Ultra Sport II tires for everyday use. They're remarkably grippy, tough, durable, smooth rolling and resistant to punctures and cuts despite lacking any puncture shield. And at around $15 each, I don't even care if one gets cut to pieces. So far I'll wear them out from ordinary riding before they get enough nicks to do any damage. The last puncture flat I got was nearly two years ago.
I have a few somewhat better clincher tires: Schwalbe One V-Guards, Conti Grand Prix Classic, Vredestein Fortezza Tricomp. Occasionally I'll mount those when I feel like chasing a KOM or PR. But they're a bit more fragile. One of the first Schwalbe Ones I got was cut to pieces long before the tread was close to being worn out.
If I wanted a puncture resistant tire for a road bike, I'd probably try a Michelin Protek Urban, or one of their tougher road bike tires like the Pro 4 Grip Service Course. Based on my experience with the Protek Cross Max, the Aramid fiber shield seems to ride better than just slapping on extra thick rubber for puncture resistance -- which is pretty much what Schwalbe and Continental do for some tires.
Those Michelin Protek Cross Max Tires sound good.This is the first I have heard of them. It sounds like you believe they give just as much protection as the hard shell Gator Skins but with a much better ride and handling. The Gator Skins ride that bad? After reading what you said I realize there are many different levels of balancing flat protection and performance and that is up to the tastes of each particular rider and what he is looking for. I never realized that, there is not one size fits all, it is a personal thing. Like you said, when you are out for a performance ride, not running errands, you are willing to give up some flat protection reliability for the tire's road performance. For me flat protection reliability is always paramount without the tire rolling like a brick. Rolling resistance and shaving a few ounces would be lost on me. These Michelin Proteks really sound good.
#28
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Hacienda Hgts
Posts: 2,101
Bikes: 1999 Schwinn Peloton Ultegra 10, Kestrel RT-1000 Ultegra, Trek Marlin 6 Deore 29'er
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 822 Post(s)
Liked 1,955 Times
in
941 Posts
The Gatorskin folding are 395 gms according to the Continental website while the hardshells are 460 gm. The hardshells offer the three ply protective layer to the entire tire while the folding is only where the tire meets the contact zone. Thus, the weight difference and perhaps a harsher ride due to a stronger sidewall.
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Montreal, Quebec
Posts: 5,921
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1815 Post(s)
Liked 1,693 Times
in
974 Posts
Once I am done with my present tires I would also like to try going tubeless with the Gator Skins, Schwalbe Marathon Plus or like Canklecat said Michelin Protek Cross Max to eliminate all possibility of pinch flats and my nemeses valves splitting from tubes and valve failure. Can you find out if this is feasible or is it too messy.
c
c
Last edited by alcjphil; 02-26-20 at 08:37 AM.
Likes For alcjphil:
#30
Senior Member
Thread Starter
The Gatorskin folding are 395 gms according to the Continental website while the hardshells are 460 gm. The hardshells offer the three ply protective layer to the entire tire while the folding is only where the tire meets the contact zone. Thus, the weight difference and perhaps a harsher ride due to a stronger sidewall.
#31
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Edit: I reread your post and now realize you were saying none of those tire models come in tubeless, I did not know that.Well, I will have to try them as tubed tires if I can not get adequate performance from my present tires.
Last edited by mjac; 02-26-20 at 08:55 AM.
#32
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Hacienda Hgts
Posts: 2,101
Bikes: 1999 Schwinn Peloton Ultegra 10, Kestrel RT-1000 Ultegra, Trek Marlin 6 Deore 29'er
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 822 Post(s)
Liked 1,955 Times
in
941 Posts
^^^^^ I ride my Gatorskin folding (28 mm) at 100 psi F/B (my weight 210 lbs) on urban streets and do not consider them harsh. The hardshells are rougher riding but that is expected. I am not familiar with the Michelin Protek Cross Max but the tread looks like an all terrain tire and I question whether that tread would not be ideal for smooth tarmac? They are almost twice as heavy 32 mm (750 mg) as the Gatorskin 28 mm folding and are a thick tread but on sale for $30 here:
https://www.biketiresdirect.com/prod...-max-700c-tire
I cannot fit the smallest width 32 mm on my road bikes if that is a concern for you?
https://www.biketiresdirect.com/prod...-max-700c-tire
I cannot fit the smallest width 32 mm on my road bikes if that is a concern for you?
Last edited by CAT7RDR; 02-26-20 at 09:00 AM.
Likes For ups:
#34
Senior Member
Thread Starter
^^^^^ I ride my Gatorskin folding (28 mm) at 100 psi F/B (my weight 210 lbs) on urban streets and do not consider them harsh. The hardshells are rougher riding but that is expected. I am not familiar with the Michelin Protek Cross Max but the tread looks like an all terrain tire and I question whether that tread would not be ideal for smooth tarmac? They are almost twice as heavy 32 mm (750 mg) as the Gatorskin 28 mm folding and are a thick tread but on sale for $30 here:
https://www.biketiresdirect.com/prod...-max-700c-tire
I cannot fit the smallest width 32 mm on my road bikes if that is a concern for you?
https://www.biketiresdirect.com/prod...-max-700c-tire
I cannot fit the smallest width 32 mm on my road bikes if that is a concern for you?
#36
Senior Member
Thread Starter
An experienced rider can tell the rolling resistance difference between two tires while on the bike? I just want to stop flats. A flat tire has more rolling resistance then anything.
#38
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I saw that. That should be interesting in comparing the puncture resistant tires I am looking at. I have to take a look at it. I did not think the chart would be that useful to me because I am not too critical on rolling resistance but then I saw the columns on puncture resistance, tire weight and tire thickness. Thanks,mjac
Likes For mjac:
#39
Senior Member
Thread Starter
In a previous thread I asked what was the best self sealing 700 X 25 tube there is and was shot down on all fronts. The factory self sealing tubes don't work. Injecting tubeless mountain bike sealant into your tube doesn't work with narrow high pressure tires and the puncture resistant strips not only don't work and but can actually cause flats.
So I am going to try a different tack since I want to avoid flats at all costs. Without any regard to weight, what is the best puncture resistant tire on the market? I have heard of Continental's Gator Skins...Thanks,mjac
So I am going to try a different tack since I want to avoid flats at all costs. Without any regard to weight, what is the best puncture resistant tire on the market? I have heard of Continental's Gator Skins...Thanks,mjac
#40
Me duelen las nalgas
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: Texas
Posts: 13,513
Bikes: Centurion Ironman, Trek 5900, Univega Via Carisma, Globe Carmel
Mentioned: 199 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4559 Post(s)
Liked 2,802 Times
in
1,800 Posts
After Canklecat recommended Przewalski Bike Shorts to me, which turned out to be the greatest shorts and absolutely the greatest value on the planet, I have to listen to what he says. Anybody who has not tried these shorts really ought to.
Those Michelin Protek Cross Max Tires sound good.This is the first I have heard of them. It sounds like you believe they give just as much protection as the hard shell Gator Skins but with a much better ride and handling. The Gator Skins ride that bad? After reading what you said I realize there are many different levels of balancing flat protection and performance and that is up to the tastes of each particular rider and what he is looking for. I never realized that, there is not one size fits all, it is a personal thing. Like you said, when you are out for a performance ride, not running errands, you are willing to give up some flat protection reliability for the tire's road performance. For me flat protection reliability is always paramount without the tire rolling like a brick. Rolling resistance and shaving a few ounces would be lost on me. These Michelin Proteks really sound good.
Those Michelin Protek Cross Max Tires sound good.This is the first I have heard of them. It sounds like you believe they give just as much protection as the hard shell Gator Skins but with a much better ride and handling. The Gator Skins ride that bad? After reading what you said I realize there are many different levels of balancing flat protection and performance and that is up to the tastes of each particular rider and what he is looking for. I never realized that, there is not one size fits all, it is a personal thing. Like you said, when you are out for a performance ride, not running errands, you are willing to give up some flat protection reliability for the tire's road performance. For me flat protection reliability is always paramount without the tire rolling like a brick. Rolling resistance and shaving a few ounces would be lost on me. These Michelin Proteks really sound good.
I haven't checked Michelin's current catalog, but here's a breakdown of their Protek lineup as of a year or so ago:
- Most of the lineup uses a variation of the familiar chevron tread pattern.
- Protek: Designates their standard Aramid puncture shield, 1mm, I think.
- Cross: Thicker chevron tread, not quite mountain bike knobbies, but excellent traction for most conditions other than mud or really loose crumbly soil. Thicker rubber tread adds weight and rolling resistance.
- Max: Adds their thickest 5mm Aramid puncture shield. The thicker shield adds some weight and rolling resistance, but less than a separate liner like the Tuffy, because the puncture shield is incorporated into the tire and resists squirming around wasting energy.
For most road bikes and sporty commuter hybrids, the 700x28 Protek Urban would be a good compromise. For bikes like mine limited to 700x25 or skinnier, I'd go for something like the Michelin Pro 4 or Power All Season. But for now I'm satisfied with the Continental Ultra Sport II (slicks) and Grand Prix Classic (which adds a bit of tread pattern) on my road bikes.
Between the Aramid fiber ("Kevlar") type puncture shields and thicker rubber shields, subjectively I'd say the Aramid fiber shields feel less sluggish. I have a couple of Continental Sport Contact II tires in 700x32 that I hoped would be a suitable replacement for the 700x42 SpeedRides I'd been using, but which were too wide for my old SKS Bluemel fenders. The two tires weighed about the same and the skinnier Sport Contact II had less aggressive tread so I figured it would roll a bit nicer. Nope. The thicker tread and rubber puncture shield felt really sluggish. After a couple of months I took off the Sport Contact II, fenders and went back to the SpeedRides.
But the Rolling Resistance site tests indicate the Conti Sport Contact II and Schwalbe Marathon Green Guard perform similarly, so I'd just buy whichever is less expensive. I got the Conti Sport Contact II pair for about $20 from Nashbar when it was closing shop a couple of years ago, so they were a very good value. I'll still find a use for them some day.
#41
Sunshine
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Des Moines, IA
Posts: 16,604
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
Mentioned: 123 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 10947 Post(s)
Liked 7,473 Times
in
4,181 Posts
A guy i ride with uses tannus tires- they are airless and solid core. he swears they ride just as well as pneumatic tires, but he also used to use gatorskins, so the usefulness of his opinion on ride quality is questionable at best. Tannus tires have a few different types of tire to account for the PSI people ride with. It helps, in theory, to mimic comfort due to rider weight variability.
Anyways- the only tire that wont flat is one that doesnt have air.
#42
Senior Member
Lot of good suggestions here. IMHO the Conti Gators are one of the better/faster rolling heavy duty tires. In contrast to the Schwalbe Marathons. I have to pump my Schwalbes up to maximum +5% pressure to get them to roll fast. Some of the narrower Michelin Pro Tek are nice rolling tires. And, I like the rolling resistance of black wall Panaracer Paselas. One very tough heavy duty tire I haven't seen mentioned here yet is the Bontrager branded items. But, some of the Bontragers can be heavier and slower than even the Marathons. YMMV.
#43
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I dont think anyone would want to get flats that are avoidable. I honestly cant imagine someone saying 'yes, i want to have flats that are avoidable'.
A guy i ride with uses tannus tires- they are airless and solid core. he swears they ride just as well as pneumatic tires, but he also used to use gatorskins, so the usefulness of his opinion on ride quality is questionable at best. Tannus tires have a few different types of tire to account for the PSI people ride with. It helps, in theory, to mimic comfort due to rider weight variability.
Anyways- the only tire that wont flat is one that doesnt have air.
A guy i ride with uses tannus tires- they are airless and solid core. he swears they ride just as well as pneumatic tires, but he also used to use gatorskins, so the usefulness of his opinion on ride quality is questionable at best. Tannus tires have a few different types of tire to account for the PSI people ride with. It helps, in theory, to mimic comfort due to rider weight variability.
Anyways- the only tire that wont flat is one that doesnt have air.
#44
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Lot of good suggestions here. IMHO the Conti Gators are one of the better/faster rolling heavy duty tires. In contrast to the Schwalbe Marathons. I have to pump my Schwalbes up to maximum +5% pressure to get them to roll fast. Some of the narrower Michelin Pro Tek are nice rolling tires. And, I like the rolling resistance of black wall Panaracer Paselas. One very tough heavy duty tire I haven't seen mentioned here yet is the Bontrager branded items. But, some of the Bontragers can be heavier and slower than even the Marathons. YMMV.
#45
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Michelin Protek Cross Max tires are massively heavy, and not even available in skinny road bike sizes. This particular tire is best suited to errand bikes, some commuter bikes, and most-terrain riding -- pavement, gravel, some dry conditions off road. The 700x40 (nominal size, actually measures closer to 700x45) Protek Cross Max on my errand bike weighs about 1,200 gm each. Road bike tires usually weigh less than 400 gm, even the Gatorskins.
I haven't checked Michelin's current catalog, but here's a breakdown of their Protek lineup as of a year or so ago:
For most road bikes and sporty commuter hybrids, the 700x28 Protek Urban would be a good compromise. For bikes like mine limited to 700x25 or skinnier, I'd go for something like the Michelin Pro 4 or Power All Season. But for now I'm satisfied with the Continental Ultra Sport II (slicks) and Grand Prix Classic (which adds a bit of tread pattern) on my road bikes.
Between the Aramid fiber ("Kevlar") type puncture shields and thicker rubber shields, subjectively I'd say the Aramid fiber shields feel less slxuggish. I have a couple of Continental Sport Contact II tires in 700x32 that I hoped would be a suitable replacement for the 700x42 SpeedRides I'd been using, but which were too wide for my old SKS Bluemel fenders. The two tires weighed about the same and the skinnier Sport Contact II had less aggressive tread so I figured it would roll a bit nicer. Nope. The thicker tread and rubber puncture shield felt really sluggish. After a couple of months I took off the Sport Contact II, fenders and went back to the SpeedRides.
But the Rolling Resistance site tests indicate the Conti Sport Contact II and Schwalbe Marathon Green Guard perform similarly, so I'd just buy whichever is less expensive. I got the Conti Sport Contact II pair for about $20 from Nashbar when it was closing shop a couple of years ago, so they were a very good value. I'll still find a use for them some day.
I haven't checked Michelin's current catalog, but here's a breakdown of their Protek lineup as of a year or so ago:
- Most of the lineup uses a variation of the familiar chevron tread pattern.
- Protek: Designates their standard Aramid puncture shield, 1mm, I think.
- Cross: Thicker chevron tread, not quite mountain bike knobbies, but excellent traction for most conditions other than mud or really loose crumbly soil. Thicker rubber tread adds weight and rolling resistance.
- Max: Adds their thickest 5mm Aramid puncture shield. The thicker shield adds some weight and rolling resistance, but less than a separate liner like the Tuffy, because the puncture shield is incorporated into the tire and resists squirming around wasting energy.
For most road bikes and sporty commuter hybrids, the 700x28 Protek Urban would be a good compromise. For bikes like mine limited to 700x25 or skinnier, I'd go for something like the Michelin Pro 4 or Power All Season. But for now I'm satisfied with the Continental Ultra Sport II (slicks) and Grand Prix Classic (which adds a bit of tread pattern) on my road bikes.
Between the Aramid fiber ("Kevlar") type puncture shields and thicker rubber shields, subjectively I'd say the Aramid fiber shields feel less slxuggish. I have a couple of Continental Sport Contact II tires in 700x32 that I hoped would be a suitable replacement for the 700x42 SpeedRides I'd been using, but which were too wide for my old SKS Bluemel fenders. The two tires weighed about the same and the skinnier Sport Contact II had less aggressive tread so I figured it would roll a bit nicer. Nope. The thicker tread and rubber puncture shield felt really sluggish. After a couple of months I took off the Sport Contact II, fenders and went back to the SpeedRides.
But the Rolling Resistance site tests indicate the Conti Sport Contact II and Schwalbe Marathon Green Guard perform similarly, so I'd just buy whichever is less expensive. I got the Conti Sport Contact II pair for about $20 from Nashbar when it was closing shop a couple of years ago, so they were a very good value. I'll still find a use for them some day.
#46
Me duelen las nalgas
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: Texas
Posts: 13,513
Bikes: Centurion Ironman, Trek 5900, Univega Via Carisma, Globe Carmel
Mentioned: 199 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4559 Post(s)
Liked 2,802 Times
in
1,800 Posts
Yeah, I found that out when I looked into them. The way you described them, using the Aramid band to keep them slim, I thought they were road tires but they start at 32mm and a 32mm Cross Max weighs twice as much as a 28mm Gator. I have two Bontregers from the COOP, a 23mm with "triple flat protection" and the other one a 28mm with an Aramid Band, any good?
My set of Schwalbe One V-Guards were about as close to racing tires as you'll find in a clincher, and included a remarkably tough and effective paper thin puncture shield. By the 1,000-1,500 mile mark the tread was slashed to pieces by ordinary road debris, but even with the tube threatening to bulge through the avulsions the thin fiber shield kept everything intact. I had relatively few puncture flats with those tires. But because it was a race quality tread for weekend warriors and local crit racers, in a handy clincher style, the tread was designed to be fast, smooth rolling and not for longevity. When first introduced around 2014 the Schwalbe One V-Guard was tested at around 12 watts rolling resistance at maximum recommended pressure, which was considered really low for the time. I'd buy 'em again at a reasonable price and save 'em for rides when I'm feeling frisky and want to tackle a PR or KOM (not that I'll ever snag the latter, but a feller can try).
Now there are some race-ish clinchers rated as low as 10 watts, but those are mostly set up for tubeless.
Speaking of which, I'm seriously considering one of Mavic's entry level wheelsets that include a pair of tires designed for those wheels. The YouTube demos look good, much less hassle than some tubeless setups a few years ago. I though tubes with sealant -- at least Slime brand -- were more trouble than they were worth. But demos of tubeless setups with deliberate punctures to show how quickly the sealant works look pretty good.
#47
Senior Member
I'm using Michelin Pro Teks on my upright hybrid bicycle. They have a nice simple chevron tread pattern and a distinctive reflective sidewall. I guess they're around 32mm. (I'll have to go out & look). They roll nice & smooth at 80psi. I like them a lot. They perform very well compared to other similar sized tires. As good or better than the Schwalbe Marathon IMHO. But, I don't think they're going to fit most racing style bicycles. They're not that wide but, do have a tall profile. Would probably have trouble clearing the brake bridge on some bikes.
#48
Member
I think some good questions to ask are: What type of roads are you riding on? How often are you getting flat tires? Do you use tire levers to put the tubes and tires back on the rims? What psi do you ride on?
#50
Senior Member
I really like my Michelin power endurance tires. They ride much better than gator skins. I keep a close eye on the road in an effort to avoid broken glass. I've logged 6000 miles without a flat.