Can't find creak origin
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Can't find creak origin
My 5y/o road bike has started to creak sometimes. It seems more prone to do it when riding at night, so I suppose temperarture is a factor.
The creaking coincides with the crank movement and it also does it when standing up (so it's not a saddle issue). It creaks more when on the big chainring.
So far I've disassembled the cranks (Rival) and removed and reinstalled the bottom bracket. Bottom bracket is pressfit but has never creaked in 5 years. I regreased everything when I assembled it. I also disassembled the chainrings and greased the bolts. I have not removed the pedals (Shimano M520), but it creaks when pedalling using only one foot, either right or left, so they don't seem to be the cause either.
I have also greased the rear through axle and even the space between the RD hanger and the frame.
Finally, I've tightened the cassette and checked the freehub and everything seems alright. I have also checked the frame for cracks and found nothing. I also checked the wheels (Vision Team 35 disc) and they don't have cracks (I replaced the wheels the past summer because the old Mavic's had cracks on the spoke holes, which also caused creaks).
Any ideas? Am I missing something?
The creaking coincides with the crank movement and it also does it when standing up (so it's not a saddle issue). It creaks more when on the big chainring.
So far I've disassembled the cranks (Rival) and removed and reinstalled the bottom bracket. Bottom bracket is pressfit but has never creaked in 5 years. I regreased everything when I assembled it. I also disassembled the chainrings and greased the bolts. I have not removed the pedals (Shimano M520), but it creaks when pedalling using only one foot, either right or left, so they don't seem to be the cause either.
I have also greased the rear through axle and even the space between the RD hanger and the frame.
Finally, I've tightened the cassette and checked the freehub and everything seems alright. I have also checked the frame for cracks and found nothing. I also checked the wheels (Vision Team 35 disc) and they don't have cracks (I replaced the wheels the past summer because the old Mavic's had cracks on the spoke holes, which also caused creaks).
Any ideas? Am I missing something?
Last edited by Amt0571; 12-15-23 at 04:27 AM.
Likes For Amt0571:
#2
mechanically sound
Long shot, but I discovered creaking from my skewers. Switched to closed cam for a slight weight penalty and no more creaks.
__________________
Likes For frankenmike:
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Golden, CO and Tucson, AZ
Posts: 2,837
Bikes: 2012 Specialized Elite Disc, 1983 Trek 520
Mentioned: 13 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 676 Post(s)
Liked 741 Times
in
430 Posts
Try recreating the noise on the stand. Align a crank with the seat tube, wrap both hands around the crank and seat tube, and squeeze. Then pull them apart. This will usually point out any motion in the BB.
Likes For andrewclaus:
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2015
Location: Dublin, Ireland
Posts: 1,268
Bikes: Bianchi Ti Megatube; Colnago Competition; Planet-X EC-130E; Klein Pulse; Amp Research B4; Litespeed Catalyst; Trek Y11
Mentioned: 8 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 605 Post(s)
Liked 480 Times
in
260 Posts
I recall a thread years ago about someone with this problem, and after dismantling the entire bike, it ended up being the zip on their cycling jacket, which they only wore on cold days.
The point: could be lots of things, so don't discount anyone's input.
Have you tried different shoes? Maybe one of the cleat bolts is loose?
Do you have a spare / different wheelset around to try?
Recreating it on a stand or turbo trainer is a good start.
The point: could be lots of things, so don't discount anyone's input.
Have you tried different shoes? Maybe one of the cleat bolts is loose?
Do you have a spare / different wheelset around to try?
Recreating it on a stand or turbo trainer is a good start.
Likes For ridelikeaturtle:
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Northern NY...Brownville
Posts: 2,575
Bikes: Specialized Aethos, Specialized Diverge Comp E5
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 242 Post(s)
Liked 456 Times
in
267 Posts
Perhaps the handlebar/stem interface...happened to me once this year...it was a tiny bit loose after a position adjustment and I failed to tighten it to torque spec.
Headset...
Headset...
Likes For Kai Winters:
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I recall a thread years ago about someone with this problem, and after dismantling the entire bike, it ended up being the zip on their cycling jacket, which they only wore on cold days.
The point: could be lots of things, so don't discount anyone's input.
Have you tried different shoes? Maybe one of the cleat bolts is loose?
Do you have a spare / different wheelset around to try?
Recreating it on a stand or turbo trainer is a good start.
The point: could be lots of things, so don't discount anyone's input.
Have you tried different shoes? Maybe one of the cleat bolts is loose?
Do you have a spare / different wheelset around to try?
Recreating it on a stand or turbo trainer is a good start.
It happens when riding hands free, so I assume it's not the bars. You remind me that it could be a good idea to remove the steerer and grease the bearing / frame interface though. I don't think it's the cause, but I can't really rule it out. Maybe I could try to ride in a wheelie, but I'm unable to ride a wheelie without holding the bars, so that wouldn't fully rule it out.
Last edited by Amt0571; 12-15-23 at 08:27 AM.
Likes For Amt0571:
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: San Diego, CA
Posts: 3,677
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 839 Post(s)
Liked 1,064 Times
in
747 Posts
Sometimes old cable housings start to creak against the ferrules when the metal housing strands get corroded or start to protrude further from the plastic housing and every little movement from the bars can cause a creak. Even though you say it happens hands free the bars are still moving a little so try moving the bars back and forth when the bike is stationary to see if you can create the noise.
Likes For Crankycrank:
#9
don't try this at home.
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: N. KY
Posts: 5,940
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 974 Post(s)
Liked 512 Times
in
352 Posts
Locating the noise:
I found my rear quick release creak after checking a bunch of other things: Indoors, I stood next to the bike and pressed down on the pedal that was at 6 oclock, to torque the frame. The noise is coming from the back of the bike!
quick release noise
A couple times a year, I remove the quick release and wipe off the cam surface and add a light film of grease. Fixed!
I found my rear quick release creak after checking a bunch of other things: Indoors, I stood next to the bike and pressed down on the pedal that was at 6 oclock, to torque the frame. The noise is coming from the back of the bike!
quick release noise
A couple times a year, I remove the quick release and wipe off the cam surface and add a light film of grease. Fixed!
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 982
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 506 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 639 Times
in
357 Posts
My 5y/o road bike has started to creak sometimes. It seems more prone to do it when riding at night, so I suppose temperarture is a factor.
The creaking coincides with the crank movement and it also does it when standing up (so it's not a saddle issue). It creaks more when on the big chainring.
So far I've disassembled the cranks (Rival) and removed and reinstalled the bottom bracket. Bottom bracket is pressfit but has never creaked in 5 years. I regreased everything when I assembled it. I also disassembled the chainrings and greased the bolts. I have not removed the pedals (Shimano M520), but it creaks when pedalling using only one foot, either right or left, so they don't seem to be the cause either.
I have also greased the rear through axle and even the space between the RD hanger and the frame.
Finally, I've tightened the cassette and checked the freehub and everything seems alright. I have also checked the frame for cracks and found nothing. I also checked the wheels (Vision Team 35 disc) and they don't have cracks (I replaced the wheels the past summer because the old Mavic's had cracks on the spoke holes, which also caused creaks).
Any ideas? Am I missing something?
The creaking coincides with the crank movement and it also does it when standing up (so it's not a saddle issue). It creaks more when on the big chainring.
So far I've disassembled the cranks (Rival) and removed and reinstalled the bottom bracket. Bottom bracket is pressfit but has never creaked in 5 years. I regreased everything when I assembled it. I also disassembled the chainrings and greased the bolts. I have not removed the pedals (Shimano M520), but it creaks when pedalling using only one foot, either right or left, so they don't seem to be the cause either.
I have also greased the rear through axle and even the space between the RD hanger and the frame.
Finally, I've tightened the cassette and checked the freehub and everything seems alright. I have also checked the frame for cracks and found nothing. I also checked the wheels (Vision Team 35 disc) and they don't have cracks (I replaced the wheels the past summer because the old Mavic's had cracks on the spoke holes, which also caused creaks).
Any ideas? Am I missing something?
- BB (grease all threads in contact with the frame and BB, all metal to metal contact surfaces, and torque to the recommended settings, which can be quite high), the faces of tapered BB axles if they have a little corrosion
- bolt holding the BB cable guide onto the frame (grease threads and make sure the bolt is not touching the BB shell inside the frame)
- BB cable guide (grease threads and tighten)
- crank bolts (grease threads and washers)
- chain ring bolts (take them all out and grease the threads, the faces where they contact the CRs, and the CRs where they contact the crank spider arms)
- a dirty chain, inadequately lubed chain, stiff link in a chain or a burr on one of the "break off" special links used to assemble the chain
- front derailleur clamp (clean and put a light film of grease on the inside of the clamp where it touches the seat tube)
- front derailleur cage hitting crank arm
- the pedals (grease the threads and the shoulders of the axle where it butts against the crank arm, get some wax, silicone etc. on the cleats, check for play in the bearings, squirt some lube into the guts of the pedal machinery if possible)
- shoes/cleats - loose cleat nut rattling around in the shoe sole, shoe/cleat interface, cleat bolts, cleats touching pedals (wax lube, silicone, or furniture polish)
- seat post and saddle (grease the post, seat post clamp, seat post bolts, saddle rails, and add some oil to where the rails go into the saddle body)
- bars and stem (grease the stem where it clamps to steerer or goes into the steerer if quill type, top cap, stem bolts at both ends, h'bar bolt if quill stem, and h'bar where it goes through the stem)
- grease/tighten QRs and where the hub axle contacts the frame
- tighten cassette lock ring, grease cassette hub body and cassette spacers
- grease steerer tube spacers (if threadless)
- replaceable derailleur hangers (remove, clean, grease all parts and threads, reassemble)
- any other bolt (bottle cages, derailleur clamps, derailleur bolts, shift cable casing stops, etc.)
- cables hitting the frame (cable donuts), or shifting in their end ferrules (lube contact points).
Wheels can make noises when pedaling or coasting (check for spoke tension, particularly on the rear non drive side, put a drop of lube where each pair of spokes cross and where each spoke enters the rim and the hub flange, check for loose metal bits or spoke nipples in the body of the rim and cracks in the rim at spoke holes.).
Clicks that happen when you coast can come from:
- computer wheel magnet hitting the pickup (computer pickup reed switch noise cannot be fixed)
- nuts on threaded Presta valve stems (throw the nut away)
- valve stems hitting/moving against the rim
- wheel reflectors wobbling.
- pinned rim joint flexing
- bits of loose metal inside the rim left over from manufacturing
Likes For KerryIrons:
#11
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 15,002
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Mentioned: 51 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6199 Post(s)
Liked 4,816 Times
in
3,323 Posts
And when you disassembled and reassembled the crank you also checked the chain ring bolts?
The creak may also be the spokes on your wheels. Take a strong piece of cloth soaked with soapy water and wedge it between the places where the spokes cross each other and clean them good. Or you can just lube the crosses with paraffin or your favorite oil or other lube.
The creak may also be the spokes on your wheels. Take a strong piece of cloth soaked with soapy water and wedge it between the places where the spokes cross each other and clean them good. Or you can just lube the crosses with paraffin or your favorite oil or other lube.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: SW Ohio
Posts: 3,682
Bikes: Puch Marco Polo, Saint Tropez, Masi Gran Criterium
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1163 Post(s)
Liked 442 Times
in
315 Posts
You say you re-greased the press fit bottom bracket. Does that mean that you physically removed the cups from the bottom bracket shell and re-intstalled them?
#13
Junior Member
Two possibilities not mentioned are;
1. Cracked BB shell, this happened on a mountain bike of mine. Clean it all real good and inspect thoroughly for any crack, this will probably be on the bottom and not easy to see.
2. The BB cups of a cartridge type system. We had alot of problems with that issue and always just automatically installed them with the copper antisieze on the inside and outside of the cups. Easy fix.
1. Cracked BB shell, this happened on a mountain bike of mine. Clean it all real good and inspect thoroughly for any crack, this will probably be on the bottom and not easy to see.
2. The BB cups of a cartridge type system. We had alot of problems with that issue and always just automatically installed them with the copper antisieze on the inside and outside of the cups. Easy fix.
#14
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Finally got around to removing the pedals and reinstalling them with grease. No creaking.... for 5km. It then started again. The same happened when I disassembled the whole BB.
Sometimes I can make it creak when stationary by pushing hard on the pedal while holding the rear brake. I'm thinking it's either the crankset/chainrings or the freehub. It seems to me the sound comes from the crankset, but in my experience the creak sounds can be misleading.
I noticed I missed something when I disassembled the chainrings tough... it seems that my Rival cranks have a removable spider. I still have to check that one. I've had bolts come loose and cause creaks more than once, and those cranks have more 25.000km at the moment.
Thank you all for your ideas and suggestions!
Sometimes I can make it creak when stationary by pushing hard on the pedal while holding the rear brake. I'm thinking it's either the crankset/chainrings or the freehub. It seems to me the sound comes from the crankset, but in my experience the creak sounds can be misleading.
I noticed I missed something when I disassembled the chainrings tough... it seems that my Rival cranks have a removable spider. I still have to check that one. I've had bolts come loose and cause creaks more than once, and those cranks have more 25.000km at the moment.
Thank you all for your ideas and suggestions!
Likes For Amt0571:
#15
Industry guy
Is it possible a seal on the bb stiffens in the colder temps?
That would explain a number of the symptoms.
rusty
That would explain a number of the symptoms.
rusty
#16
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#17
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2023
Location: Eastern Shore MD
Posts: 884
Bikes: Lemond Zurich/Trek ALR/Giant TCX/Sette CX1
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 570 Post(s)
Liked 773 Times
in
404 Posts
Clicks tied to your pedaling can come from
- BB (grease all threads in contact with the frame and BB, all metal to metal contact surfaces, and torque to the recommended settings, which can be quite high), the faces of tapered BB axles if they have a little corrosion
- bolt holding the BB cable guide onto the frame (grease threads and make sure the bolt is not touching the BB shell inside the frame)
- BB cable guide (grease threads and tighten)
- crank bolts (grease threads and washers)
- chain ring bolts (take them all out and grease the threads, the faces where they contact the CRs, and the CRs where they contact the crank spider arms)
- a dirty chain, inadequately lubed chain, stiff link in a chain or a burr on one of the "break off" special links used to assemble the chain
- front derailleur clamp (clean and put a light film of grease on the inside of the clamp where it touches the seat tube)
- front derailleur cage hitting crank arm
- the pedals (grease the threads and the shoulders of the axle where it butts against the crank arm, get some wax, silicone etc. on the cleats, check for play in the bearings, squirt some lube into the guts of the pedal machinery if possible)
- shoes/cleats - loose cleat nut rattling around in the shoe sole, shoe/cleat interface, cleat bolts, cleats touching pedals (wax lube, silicone, or furniture polish)
- seat post and saddle (grease the post, seat post clamp, seat post bolts, saddle rails, and add some oil to where the rails go into the saddle body)
- bars and stem (grease the stem where it clamps to steerer or goes into the steerer if quill type, top cap, stem bolts at both ends, h'bar bolt if quill stem, and h'bar where it goes through the stem)
- grease/tighten QRs and where the hub axle contacts the frame
- tighten cassette lock ring, grease cassette hub body and cassette spacers
- grease steerer tube spacers (if threadless)
- replaceable derailleur hangers (remove, clean, grease all parts and threads, reassemble)
- any other bolt (bottle cages, derailleur clamps, derailleur bolts, shift cable casing stops, etc.)
- cables hitting the frame (cable donuts), or shifting in their end ferrules (lube contact points).
Wheels can make noises when pedaling or coasting (check for spoke tension, particularly on the rear non drive side, put a drop of lube where each pair of spokes cross and where each spoke enters the rim and the hub flange, check for loose metal bits or spoke nipples in the body of the rim and cracks in the rim at spoke holes.).
Clicks that happen when you coast can come from:
- computer wheel magnet hitting the pickup (computer pickup reed switch noise cannot be fixed)
- nuts on threaded Presta valve stems (throw the nut away)
- valve stems hitting/moving against the rim
- wheel reflectors wobbling.
- pinned rim joint flexing
- bits of loose metal inside the rim left over from manufacturing
- BB (grease all threads in contact with the frame and BB, all metal to metal contact surfaces, and torque to the recommended settings, which can be quite high), the faces of tapered BB axles if they have a little corrosion
- bolt holding the BB cable guide onto the frame (grease threads and make sure the bolt is not touching the BB shell inside the frame)
- BB cable guide (grease threads and tighten)
- crank bolts (grease threads and washers)
- chain ring bolts (take them all out and grease the threads, the faces where they contact the CRs, and the CRs where they contact the crank spider arms)
- a dirty chain, inadequately lubed chain, stiff link in a chain or a burr on one of the "break off" special links used to assemble the chain
- front derailleur clamp (clean and put a light film of grease on the inside of the clamp where it touches the seat tube)
- front derailleur cage hitting crank arm
- the pedals (grease the threads and the shoulders of the axle where it butts against the crank arm, get some wax, silicone etc. on the cleats, check for play in the bearings, squirt some lube into the guts of the pedal machinery if possible)
- shoes/cleats - loose cleat nut rattling around in the shoe sole, shoe/cleat interface, cleat bolts, cleats touching pedals (wax lube, silicone, or furniture polish)
- seat post and saddle (grease the post, seat post clamp, seat post bolts, saddle rails, and add some oil to where the rails go into the saddle body)
- bars and stem (grease the stem where it clamps to steerer or goes into the steerer if quill type, top cap, stem bolts at both ends, h'bar bolt if quill stem, and h'bar where it goes through the stem)
- grease/tighten QRs and where the hub axle contacts the frame
- tighten cassette lock ring, grease cassette hub body and cassette spacers
- grease steerer tube spacers (if threadless)
- replaceable derailleur hangers (remove, clean, grease all parts and threads, reassemble)
- any other bolt (bottle cages, derailleur clamps, derailleur bolts, shift cable casing stops, etc.)
- cables hitting the frame (cable donuts), or shifting in their end ferrules (lube contact points).
Wheels can make noises when pedaling or coasting (check for spoke tension, particularly on the rear non drive side, put a drop of lube where each pair of spokes cross and where each spoke enters the rim and the hub flange, check for loose metal bits or spoke nipples in the body of the rim and cracks in the rim at spoke holes.).
Clicks that happen when you coast can come from:
- computer wheel magnet hitting the pickup (computer pickup reed switch noise cannot be fixed)
- nuts on threaded Presta valve stems (throw the nut away)
- valve stems hitting/moving against the rim
- wheel reflectors wobbling.
- pinned rim joint flexing
- bits of loose metal inside the rim left over from manufacturing
Triple front chain ring. Zero noise in the two smaller rings. I get a clicking noise when in the large ring.
The noise happens regardless of power output. It happens at all cadence levels. And it is steady - it doesn't increase or decrease frequency with changes in cadence.
I've torqued all the chainring bolts, but not greased them.
#18
Senior Member
#19
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
UPDATE: yesterday I disassembled the crankset spider. It was held by 3 bolts that felt more than properly torqued. I greased the spider/crankset contact surfaces and the bolts themselves. Today I did my 30km commute between -1ºC and 5ºC and the bike was silent. The spider had never been disassembled since I bough the bike.
I'm waiting to see what happens when I return home in the afternoon. I'm hoping for the best.
I'm waiting to see what happens when I return home in the afternoon. I'm hoping for the best.
Likes For Amt0571:
Likes For Jughed:
#23
Senior Member
I had a noise like that a few years ago. After trying everything I could imagine that might cause it, I took the bike to my LBS. He took apart, cleaned and lubed the headset. I was skeptical, but that was literally the only thing I hadn’t done. Sure enough, that fixed it. Frames act like speakers for these noises making it hard to pin down the source.
Likes For BTinNYC:
#25
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2023
Location: Eastern Shore MD
Posts: 884
Bikes: Lemond Zurich/Trek ALR/Giant TCX/Sette CX1
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 570 Post(s)
Liked 773 Times
in
404 Posts
During a long charity ride the bike started making a racket loud enough for everyone else to comment... "Your BB is screwed"... "damm son, whats wrong with that thing"...
A bearing on the inner hub was starting to go, just a slight tick when you spun it using your finger - the frame amped it up and you couldn't tell where it was coming from.
Likes For Jughed: