loimpact

Trying to find a new saddle...(yes, ugh).....

SADDLE #1 -----------------> have run the good ole' PB Forte Pro saddle on 2 bikes for a few yaers that have served well. Now trying to reduce perineum numbness (prostate mercy)...LOL...

SADDLE #2 -----------------> Tried Toseek with large cutout and one thin layer of cush. (Very hard....I can do it, but not something I'd want to live with long term)

SADDLE #3 -----------------> So.....Selle Italia Superflow (I got the TM version since cheapest) and seems like a good blend of the 2 above.......my left sit bone gets a little sore from the firmness vs the ole' forte....Maybe my sit bones are uneven?.....BUT....perineum numbness definitely gone. (nice)

QUESTION #1 -------> Does anybody know if the "TM" version's "Extra Padding" has more than the others...(i.e. regular Superflow, TI Superflow, Carbonio Superflow, etc.) Selle's webiste leaves A LOT to be desired!

QUESTION #2 -------> Anybody been in a similar boat to mine & have advice?? Maybe other saddles to try????

TIA very much!!!

Iride01 

Seems like you went from a small cutout to a really large and a humongous cutout. For me, I'd want something between the saddle on the left and the selle italia in the middle.

Fore/aft and tilt can make a big difference on how saddle feels with your perineum. If you haven't been trying various positions of those adjustments then do so. Don't think you have to do what others do.

Sy Reene

fwiw, i've been liking the Selle Italia Superflow SP-01.. the cutout at the rear allows both halves to independently flex a tiny bit (supposedly can help with minor differential leg lengths too).. I don't think padding changes really between the various lines (TM, Ti, Carbonio, etc.). Chain Reaction has some decent pricing on them at the moment FYI.

loimpact

Iride01 ------- Thanks for the feedback! Ya, the cutout differential is actually not so huge in reality. (Or at least not to me). I'm 6'2" (188cm) and 200lbs right now (like to be closer to 190) but the Forte's cutout is almost negligible to me. I feel like I needed as much cutout as the Selle or Toseek just to *feel* the significance. I'm also gonna try & 'test' a Romin by Specialized as that's about the only thing that really seems in between without moving to some type of "short" saddle which I don't think would work for me. (I'm tall and move around quite a bit as I ride all kinds of roads)

Sy -------- Ya know.....I actually keep eyeing that saddle. (I'm abusing Amazon at the moment so I've got easy returns to "test" with...har har). But I like the idea of an 'independent' flex on a saddle like that. I may just try that one too.

philbob57

I recommend looking into the Selle SMP, especially the TRK if you like padding. It's the best I've found for preventing perineal numbness, though I found the SMO before I got to Selle Italia's offerings.

Oso Polar

Well, for me this is a very reliable hint that seat height is significantly higher than it should be - this causes asymmetrical seating position as body is forced to choose which side of the body will suffer (it'll try to protect the dominant side of the body). Cobb San Remo worked great for me for perineal pressure - no pressure at all. But this pressure depends a lot on the saddle angle - as with any other seat. Try changing seat angle from completely flat to, say, 3 degrees nose up - in 0.5 degree increments at a time, or even less. Difference is usually striking, at least for me it is. E.g. with San Remo for me in my current riding position 0.7 to 1 degree work best, less or more are both worse - which is why adjusting seat angle by sight only is IMHO completely useless.

loimpact

philbob57 ----- Thanks for the suggestion! Those look quite fluffy. I'd done a week long demo on the standard SMP Selle but just found it too "one position" for me. Though that was a few years ago & maybe I'd feel different now. (Gonna exhaust more traditional saddles first)

Oso ------- I've been professionally fitted so I'm definitely in the proper position on both of my bikes. Again....I truly just think it's a physical anomaly for me. On the Forte saddle, there's enough cushion (and flex, I should say too, especially at its age) that I just don't think it comes to light. Perhaps over time, that tissue will toughen. (I forget about it mid-ride but then feel it right away on a fresh ride after a day off) Truth told, however....I've only been testing for several ride days so far however.

I just picked up the Spesh Romin so gonna ride that tomorrow. (Did a spin around the block in baggy shorts & feels similar to the Selle Superflow so not sure if I'll feel it's any better but we'll see)

pattrick

Try going to vendors like Bike Tires Direct and read the reviews of the saddles you are interested in. Most will give you a clue of the padding or lack of ,and some of the nuances that may not seem obvious. If your looking for a little padding in an Italia design with a cut out check the Selle Italia Max SLR Gel Super flow. I have one after checking numerous cut out type reviews,while not perfect for myself three to four hour rides are not bad. Good luck in your search.

Iride01 

Let us know how the Specialize Romin does. I've had a couple Specialized long ago in the past that were fairly comfortable, but I didn't like the rise in the rear. I tend to like a flat profile from nose to the back like many Selle Italia's have.

My new bike came with a Specialized Power Comp. It feels funny, but is actually quite comfortable for short rides. However toward mile 50, It becomes uncomfortable. So it'll have to go soon.

Why don't you try that S-Works Power with Mirror and let us know if it's worth it for long rides? <grin>

https://www.specialized.com/us/en/s-...irror/p/184353

Carbonfiberboy 

I have Selle Italia SLR Boost Endurance Superflow saddles on my bikes now. Excellent. I regularly do several-hour rides, no discomfort. I ordered them from Deporvillage

loimpact

SLR gel superlow looks good too! Since I'm coming *from* cushy I don't want to push too far. I want to keep my sit bones sitting on top vs sinking in (thus pressing on soft bits) but since the SuperFlow series all have the large cutout that give me the opportunity for a little extra cushioning while still allowing perineum relief!!

No kidding....I'd love to try that saddle! I gotta hand it to Specialized. They go 100% on everything. The "Phenom" actually has my eye if the Romin doesn't work out. Only concern with it is that while it has a cutout....it's almost useless, imho. (it's so small) LOTS of saddles to choose from. (facepalm)

That looks good too, although again.....I don't do well on the short saddles, but the SLR Gel Superflow mentioned by pattrick fits the bill!!

loimpact

Had a good 30 mile ride in the Romin today. I can definitely say it's a good saddle. My only problem at the moment is....I think my left sit-bone soreness is coming from that razor thin carbon saddle I rode last weekend. (I probably shouldn't have done a 40 mile hammerfest in that thing). Soooo.....the good news is that I can still sit comfortably on the Romin even with that soreness (it takes about 5 minutes of riding and my butt settles in fine) But at about mile #30 I could tell my left sit bone was asking me to ease up.

I think it would be fair to say it'll be between the Romin and the Selle Superflow. I'll try & alternate between them both regularly before my return window closes on them & see if I have a favorite. Hmmmmmm

one4smoke

Man, I've tried a bunch of different saddles but the Selle Anatomica is the only one I've found that works for me. Especially on long rides up to 100 miles. I had the H series for several years, but currently trying the X series.

upthywazzoo 

Of the snub-nosed saddles, I've tried the SP-01, Superflow SLR, PRO Stealth, Vento Argo, and Dash Strike. Currently demoing an Aeolus Elite. I'm still looking for that magical saddle that happens to be comfortable outdoors AND on the trainer.

Paul Barnard

Like so many of you I have played saddle roulette for most of my riding days. I have tried some of all shapes sized and levels of firmness and cushion. Some have been unbearable. The best I had been able to find were the ISM recreational models. Even those had me squirming on longer rides. Cobb recently changed names and sold their old name stuff off pretty cheaply. I bought several of their Randee saddles and like them quite a bit. I haven't logged more than 40 miles on one yet, but at that mark they are appreciably more comfortable than the ISMs. There are still some good deals out there.

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...andee&_sacat=0

Sojodave

To the original poster, is that a Romin Evo or a Romin? The photo looks like a Romin Evo. The difference between the two is that the Romin Evo has a narrower nose. I am currently riding the Romin Evo pro and bike fitters and Specialized tells you to level the middle of the saddle. For me, this had it nose down 3.5%. I actually have had the best success having it nose down at 5%. This allows me to sit in the back and push on the tail, sit in the middle, and push on the nose on hills and bigger efforts. It's also a difficult saddle to get the fore/aft correct. I usually put saddles all the way back since I'm 6'4", however, I have the Romin Evo at 3.5 instead of 5.

PoorInRichfield

I'm absolutely not buying another new saddle until the whole "printed saddle thing" either proves to be the next miracle drug or flops and goes away. If this new technology proves to be a good idea, you can bet by next year we'll see printed saddles falling out of the sky from nearly every manufacturer.

So far, all the reviews I've read on the S-Works Power saddle have been very positive... which I hate because it's a $500 saddle and now I want one. The Fizik version is a little cheaper but only comes in a nuclear green color and I don't really care for it's super open design. I can only imagine the Fizik saddle will look nasty over time when it gets full of dirt.

Bah Humbug

I loved my old Superflow and now really want to try that SP-01 above. Next saddle will be that.

Iride01 

So with new tech coming on the market, you won't buy anything till it's determined to be a good idea. Hmmm.... you must have a lot of dated things. Hard to find any expanding market that doesn't have new concepts being introduced that may or may not fly with the consumer.

Smile.......... I have trouble wanting to pay more than a $80 dollars on a saddle. I have some good saddles though that I nabbed at a great price just by being patient.

PoorInRichfield

Maybe TMI (too much information), but if you're experiencing prostate irritation in life in general (not just on the bike), might I suggest taking either saw palmetto or stinging nettle root supplements. I've taken both and either one works well for pretty much eliminating that "I always feel like I have to pee" feeling. If that isn't an issue for you, then disregard this post entirely

noodle soup

Might want to talk to @amashndash

Frank72

I use the Selle SMP Extra. It just works for me. I have it on both my bikes. I try to ride further back on it to relive pressure that happens when I slide forward a little.

Hope you find one that works for you! I don't even think about my saddle while riding.

PoorInRichfield

How long do think it's going to take to determine if a printed saddle is a good idea? I'm not talking about decades... I'm talking about months. After-all, this is a printed saddle. If Specialized determines this saddle to be a cash-cow and the reviews are all good, the time it'll take them to design similar saddles and get them to market will be shorter than we've ever experienced.

Remember bad saddle ideas like the SaddleCo saddle? I had one and within about a season no one was buying them because they didn't live up to their promise.

Sy Reene

fyi, The "boost" is the snubnosed (ie. now fashionable) shaped version. Pictured above was the standard length model.
It is pretty firm padding.. for me it somehow works better than other saddles I have that have more padding.

smashndash

If you're interested in the SP-01 boost, PM me. I have no use for mine.

Yeah I sorta found out the hard way that, especially on the trainer, I need a lot more padding than I realized. My hips rock a little and without padding under my ischial tuberosities (chair sit bones), it feels like they're slicing my flesh. The shape itself seemed more agreeable to me than the Power, though. The Power seems to punish me for riding even slightly upright due to the "scoop".