Specialized Sirrus vs Giant Roam 3 vs Giant Escape 3
11-24-17, 04:31 PM
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2017
Posts: 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Specialized Sirrus vs Giant Roam 3 vs Giant Escape 3
Hey. This is a great forum and community. I would like your recommedations.
I am a MBA student and live near the university area in Texas. I use a bike to goto school and nearby areas to run errands. Bought a walmart Schwinn for $250 and was great for the first month but by 3 months,after rain and lots of usage, it started to badly need a tuneup. Before I could do so,it got stolen. It also had a horrible stock seat.
Now I am looking at 3 sales deals and unable to decide.
1. Specialized Sirrus 2017. $370 with 1 free tuneup within 6 months.Many in stock.
2. Giant Roam 3 2017. $355 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
3. Giant Escape 3 2017. $295 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
I am a rough handler of bikes. Though I use the bike 90percent on pavement or road, sometimes there is a trail path that I take it to. I pedal hard,ride fast and brake hard.I change gears frequently too.
I will also probably put a small carrier in front or back for putting my bag on it. My average miles per day of riding is 3.I also dont mind riding in light to medium rain. I also prefer a seat which is comfortable.
Which among the above would be most suitable? The Roam 3 looks strong with good tyres but I have read because of the shockers and disc brakes it would require much more maintenance. The Escape3 looks too light and simple, with thin tyres while the Sirrus looks stronger(not as much as the Roam3).
I would appreciate early feedback.
I am a MBA student and live near the university area in Texas. I use a bike to goto school and nearby areas to run errands. Bought a walmart Schwinn for $250 and was great for the first month but by 3 months,after rain and lots of usage, it started to badly need a tuneup. Before I could do so,it got stolen. It also had a horrible stock seat.
Now I am looking at 3 sales deals and unable to decide.
1. Specialized Sirrus 2017. $370 with 1 free tuneup within 6 months.Many in stock.
2. Giant Roam 3 2017. $355 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
3. Giant Escape 3 2017. $295 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
I am a rough handler of bikes. Though I use the bike 90percent on pavement or road, sometimes there is a trail path that I take it to. I pedal hard,ride fast and brake hard.I change gears frequently too.
I will also probably put a small carrier in front or back for putting my bag on it. My average miles per day of riding is 3.I also dont mind riding in light to medium rain. I also prefer a seat which is comfortable.
Which among the above would be most suitable? The Roam 3 looks strong with good tyres but I have read because of the shockers and disc brakes it would require much more maintenance. The Escape3 looks too light and simple, with thin tyres while the Sirrus looks stronger(not as much as the Roam3).
I would appreciate early feedback.
11-24-17, 11:01 PM
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 154
Bikes: 2015 Giant Escape 2,
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 52 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
Hey. This is a great forum and community. I would like your recommedations.
I am a MBA student and live near the university area in Texas. I use a bike to goto school and nearby areas to run errands. Bought a walmart Schwinn for $250 and was great for the first month but by 3 months,after rain and lots of usage, it started to badly need a tuneup. Before I could do so,it got stolen. It also had a horrible stock seat.
Now I am looking at 3 sales deals and unable to decide.
1. Specialized Sirrus 2017. $370 with 1 free tuneup within 6 months.Many in stock.
2. Giant Roam 3 2017. $355 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
3. Giant Escape 3 2017. $295 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
I am a rough handler of bikes. Though I use the bike 90percent on pavement or road, sometimes there is a trail path that I take it to. I pedal hard,ride fast and brake hard.I change gears frequently too.
I will also probably put a small carrier in front or back for putting my bag on it. My average miles per day of riding is 3.I also dont mind riding in light to medium rain. I also prefer a seat which is comfortable.
Which among the above would be most suitable? The Roam 3 looks strong with good tyres but I have read because of the shockers and disc brakes it would require much more maintenance. The Escape3 looks too light and simple, with thin tyres while the Sirrus looks stronger(not as much as the Roam3).
I would appreciate early feedback.
I am a MBA student and live near the university area in Texas. I use a bike to goto school and nearby areas to run errands. Bought a walmart Schwinn for $250 and was great for the first month but by 3 months,after rain and lots of usage, it started to badly need a tuneup. Before I could do so,it got stolen. It also had a horrible stock seat.
Now I am looking at 3 sales deals and unable to decide.
1. Specialized Sirrus 2017. $370 with 1 free tuneup within 6 months.Many in stock.
2. Giant Roam 3 2017. $355 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
3. Giant Escape 3 2017. $295 with free 2 tuneups/yearly.Last unit.
I am a rough handler of bikes. Though I use the bike 90percent on pavement or road, sometimes there is a trail path that I take it to. I pedal hard,ride fast and brake hard.I change gears frequently too.
I will also probably put a small carrier in front or back for putting my bag on it. My average miles per day of riding is 3.I also dont mind riding in light to medium rain. I also prefer a seat which is comfortable.
Which among the above would be most suitable? The Roam 3 looks strong with good tyres but I have read because of the shockers and disc brakes it would require much more maintenance. The Escape3 looks too light and simple, with thin tyres while the Sirrus looks stronger(not as much as the Roam3).
I would appreciate early feedback.
Last edited by coney462; 11-24-17 at 11:04 PM. Reason: new thoughts
11-25-17, 01:31 AM
#3
Senior Member
Definitely The Roam 3... I rode that Bike.. its solid and will suit your needs well.. If I didn't buy the Toughroad SLR 2 I was going to buy the Roam.. it really is a great smooth riding bike.. and though the suspension isn't for real offroading.. it does help on gravel etc..
Though I recommend you ride them and see how they feel to you. That is what is most important.
Though I recommend you ride them and see how they feel to you. That is what is most important.
11-25-17, 08:04 AM
#4
aka Phil Jungels
I'm gonna be the odd man out - that Sirrus is a really great bike, and the seat ain't bad either!
11-25-17, 11:38 AM
#5
Senior Member
11-25-17, 11:50 AM
#6
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2017
Posts: 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Thanks everyone for the advice. After reading the replies, I did try out the bikes.
The Sirrus felt little stiff but had a solid grip.Speed was ok.Medium of the three.
The Escape 3 was light and fast. However, it was very stiff on even slight uneven surfaces on the road.
The Roam 3 was solid, strong feel and managed road and gravel very well with its front forks. It was slowest of the 3.
I am going ahead with the Roam 3 because of the way it managed handling and strong build. I have the option of returning it in 7 days(provided its in almost the same condition as I bought). Hopefully it turns out fine.
The Sirrus felt little stiff but had a solid grip.Speed was ok.Medium of the three.
The Escape 3 was light and fast. However, it was very stiff on even slight uneven surfaces on the road.
The Roam 3 was solid, strong feel and managed road and gravel very well with its front forks. It was slowest of the 3.
I am going ahead with the Roam 3 because of the way it managed handling and strong build. I have the option of returning it in 7 days(provided its in almost the same condition as I bought). Hopefully it turns out fine.
11-25-17, 12:00 PM
#7
Senior Member
Thanks everyone for the advice. After reading the replies, I did try out the bikes.
The Sirrus felt little stiff but had a solid grip.Speed was ok.Medium of the three.
The Escape 3 was light and fast. However, it was very stiff on even slight uneven surfaces on the road.
The Roam 3 was solid, strong feel and managed road and gravel very well with its front forks. It was slowest of the 3.
I am going ahead with the Roam 3 because of the way it managed handling and strong build. I have the option of returning it in 7 days(provided its in almost the same condition as I bought). Hopefully it turns out fine.
The Sirrus felt little stiff but had a solid grip.Speed was ok.Medium of the three.
The Escape 3 was light and fast. However, it was very stiff on even slight uneven surfaces on the road.
The Roam 3 was solid, strong feel and managed road and gravel very well with its front forks. It was slowest of the 3.
I am going ahead with the Roam 3 because of the way it managed handling and strong build. I have the option of returning it in 7 days(provided its in almost the same condition as I bought). Hopefully it turns out fine.
When I tried it out, It really did feel good to ride... and no it won't be the fastest on the road.. But it is a comfortable ride. I Was going to get that one.. I opted to get the Toughroad SLR2 instead because with my current Weight.. I was hoping the larger tires would help compensate for that and handle my weight better long term..
But I was Really close to buying the Roam.. I even have a thread on here somewhere where I was strongly considering it.. Another choice was going to be the Talon 2 or 3 which were also not bad choices.. Though, ultimately.. I am happy with my choice.
The Roam in my opinion just has that little bit extra over the escape.
Post Pictures when you can.
11-26-17, 01:49 PM
#9
aka Phil Jungels
I've said it before, and I will say it again, as an owner of a Sirrus Comp, and a Crosstrail Sport. I love the Sirrus, but the Crosstrail is the bike I would keep if I had to remove one. It's just so much better as a do it all bicycle. Your Roam is a very close cousin to my Crosstrail.
You will love it!
You will love it!
11-26-17, 07:35 PM
#10
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2017
Posts: 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Thank you guys. So far loving the Roam3. Need to get a kick stand for it. Any recommendations?
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
Last edited by Bk19xsa; 11-26-17 at 07:39 PM.
11-27-17, 05:15 AM
#11
Senior Member
Thank you guys. So far loving the Roam3. Need to get a kick stand for it. Any recommendations?
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
11-27-17, 08:32 AM
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 6,319
Bikes: 2012 Salsa Casseroll, 2009 Kona Blast
Mentioned: 13 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1031 Post(s)
Liked 208 Times
in
146 Posts
Thank you guys. So far loving the Roam3. Need to get a kick stand for it. Any recommendations?
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
Got a front black basket from Target for keeping my one strap laptop bag and other items for when I run grocery errands.
However, it takes away from the look of the bike and makes it look a little feminine. Thinking about getting a back rack with a pannier side bag to go along with it. Any recommendations or should I get a basket (rear or side rear) to attach to the back rack. I wouldnt like the pannier bag to get stolen or affected during rain as I will rarely detach it.
Will post photos once I get the kickstand.
11-27-17, 04:30 PM
#13
Newbie
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: Central Coast, California
Posts: 3
Bikes: Giant Roam
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Contact a Giant dealer. They should be available around 1/2018. I got mine on ebay for $4.99.
12-04-17, 04:56 PM
#14
Senior Member
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mighty_mouf89
Hybrid Bicycles
7
04-12-17 10:13 AM
kakari
Hybrid Bicycles
3
02-21-17 09:58 PM
