Spokes breaking repetitively
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Spokes breaking repetitively
I have always done my own bike mechanics, but I have taken my bike to a guy a couple of times the last 2-3 years or so, really like him, but his shop closed up recently and I don't know of another bike mechanic in my town. Well, there are MANY, but I don't know who I'd go to in a pinch. I'd go to Yelp and hope...
In 2010 I went into local bike shop and they sold me a new rear wheel for my now 20+ year old Miyata triple-butted road bike with 27" wheels. I didn't want a quick release but the guy told me I couldn't get a new rear wheel for the bike otherwise. I took his word for it. I kinda think it's not such a great wheel. A couple years ago the axle broke and I had it replaced (by that guy who just evidently went out of business). The last year or so the spokes have been breaking. Must be around 5 broken. I doubt they're stainless, seriously! I replaced them with what I have lying around, trued the wheel, but the wheel won't stay true and I figure I have to do something, if for no other reason than it's a PITA to keep replacing broken spokes on a rear wheel! I have a couple wheels in my Amazon "cart" but looking, I see I have a used 27" rear wheel (WITHOUT quick-release) with what I think are good looking stainless spokes. It's fitted with a Suntour 6 sprocket freewheel. My current wheel has a Shimano 6 sprocket freewheel. I think both freewheels are 14-28 teeth. The Suntour freewheel on that set-aside wheel looks good to me, but I'm no expert.
So, I'm thinking why not swap out the problem wheel for the wheel with the Suntour freewheel, true it and see how it goes. I'm wondering if this is a good idea. Or, I figure I could put the Shimano freewheel I've been using on that set-aside wheel with the stainless spokes and use that. If I use the Suntour freewheel instead, should I get a new chain? The old chain has a number of years on it. I haven't ridden that chain a lot, maybe 400 miles/year, but have started to ride more, maybe 1000 miles/year (i.e. 20 miles/week).
In 2010 I went into local bike shop and they sold me a new rear wheel for my now 20+ year old Miyata triple-butted road bike with 27" wheels. I didn't want a quick release but the guy told me I couldn't get a new rear wheel for the bike otherwise. I took his word for it. I kinda think it's not such a great wheel. A couple years ago the axle broke and I had it replaced (by that guy who just evidently went out of business). The last year or so the spokes have been breaking. Must be around 5 broken. I doubt they're stainless, seriously! I replaced them with what I have lying around, trued the wheel, but the wheel won't stay true and I figure I have to do something, if for no other reason than it's a PITA to keep replacing broken spokes on a rear wheel! I have a couple wheels in my Amazon "cart" but looking, I see I have a used 27" rear wheel (WITHOUT quick-release) with what I think are good looking stainless spokes. It's fitted with a Suntour 6 sprocket freewheel. My current wheel has a Shimano 6 sprocket freewheel. I think both freewheels are 14-28 teeth. The Suntour freewheel on that set-aside wheel looks good to me, but I'm no expert.
So, I'm thinking why not swap out the problem wheel for the wheel with the Suntour freewheel, true it and see how it goes. I'm wondering if this is a good idea. Or, I figure I could put the Shimano freewheel I've been using on that set-aside wheel with the stainless spokes and use that. If I use the Suntour freewheel instead, should I get a new chain? The old chain has a number of years on it. I haven't ridden that chain a lot, maybe 400 miles/year, but have started to ride more, maybe 1000 miles/year (i.e. 20 miles/week).
Last edited by dmusicant; 09-24-19 at 03:34 PM.
#2
Steel is real
Maybe the Suntour cogs has similar wear as the chain, I'd go with it see how she rides
#3
Steel is real
If you haven't got a chain wear gauge {i haven't}, i just grab some links and see if there's any play
This has minimal play, the freewheel i had on it was a 6spd shimano ..didn't realize a tooth was missing untill i took it for a test ride, changed it over to a Suntour..good looking teeth, rides nice, just need to stick bar tape on
This has minimal play, the freewheel i had on it was a 6spd shimano ..didn't realize a tooth was missing untill i took it for a test ride, changed it over to a Suntour..good looking teeth, rides nice, just need to stick bar tape on
#4
The dropped
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 2,144
Bikes: Pake C'Mute Touring/Commuter Build, 1989 Kona Cinder Cone, 1995 Trek 5200, 1973 Raleigh Super Course FG, 1960/61 Montgomery Ward Hawthorne "thrift" 3 speed, by Hercules (sold) : 1966 Schwinn Deluxe Racer (sold)
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1739 Post(s)
Liked 1,014 Times
in
696 Posts
What you describe doesn't give me hesitation in stating that you can rebuild your current wheel with some careful measurements. Spokes break; it happens. When lots of spokes break, generally they've had all the loading they can take. Jobst Brandt thought it was due to loose spokes, and that tighter spokes gave better service. Unless your rim is pretty dinged up and no longer sufficiently round and the hub cups are pitted or worn out, or just plain cheap, rebuilding a wheel is one way to understand how your wheels work and how to patch them up. If you're intimidated and want a bike shop to do it, you might be better off buying a new wheel.
Or just swap the freewheels, no other thought needed.
Wheelbuilding isn't hard if you have the tools and the patience.
Or just swap the freewheels, no other thought needed.
Wheelbuilding isn't hard if you have the tools and the patience.
#5
Señor Member
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 5,066
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 649 Post(s)
Liked 292 Times
in
215 Posts
The wheels purchased from bike shops often have a flaw in their assembly - the spokes are not 'stress relieved' before being sold, and this results in the spoke tension dropping after the first few hundred km, which will eventually lead to broken spokes. You can tighten the spokes up after riding, or do the 'stress relieving' befoere riding and this will generally give you the best shot at having a long-lasting wheel.
However, if you have been putting high mileage or heavy use on the bike, 9 years is a pretty good life span for a machine built wheel.
As above, wheel building is not rocket surgery, so replacing the spokes with new ones is totally doable.
Some other points:
QR axles are actually not significantly weaker than solid axles - the centre few mm missing is made up for with the QR skewer. 6sp bikes with QR axles were standard equipment from the mid to late 80s and they were ok for durability. When 7 speed became a thing, the unsupported length of axle under the freewheel got longer and bent and broken axles became much more common. Most high quality bikes from the late 80s onward have a 'freehub' design which puts the driveside bearing further outboard and makes for a much stronger assembly. It is possible that your replacement wheel was spaced for a 7sp hub and that made it weaker, not the QR axle.
Non-stainless spokes ('Nickle plated') are generally strong enough, but, 9 years of regular use with possibly insufficient tension is a lot to ask of any spokes.
It may be possible to mount 700c - the modern road standard size - wheels on your bike. If you can adjust your brake pads 4mm down from where they meet the 27" rims then 700C will probably fit without major modifications. THis is often easier with caliper brakes than with cantilever brakes. This modification gives you a couple benefits: esp. much wider choice of tires and rims, and a few mm of extra clearance if you want to run slightly wider tires (many bikes that came with 27x1-1/4 tires can be fitter with 700 X 35 or even 38mm wide tires.
You don't need a chain wear gage - you only need a 12" ruler. Measure from the centre of one pin on the bottom run of chain to the centre of the pin closest to 12" along. If the chain is more than ~1/16" 'stretched' over 12" then it is likely worn to the point that a new chain will not mesh properly with your old cogs.
However, if you have been putting high mileage or heavy use on the bike, 9 years is a pretty good life span for a machine built wheel.
As above, wheel building is not rocket surgery, so replacing the spokes with new ones is totally doable.
Some other points:
QR axles are actually not significantly weaker than solid axles - the centre few mm missing is made up for with the QR skewer. 6sp bikes with QR axles were standard equipment from the mid to late 80s and they were ok for durability. When 7 speed became a thing, the unsupported length of axle under the freewheel got longer and bent and broken axles became much more common. Most high quality bikes from the late 80s onward have a 'freehub' design which puts the driveside bearing further outboard and makes for a much stronger assembly. It is possible that your replacement wheel was spaced for a 7sp hub and that made it weaker, not the QR axle.
Non-stainless spokes ('Nickle plated') are generally strong enough, but, 9 years of regular use with possibly insufficient tension is a lot to ask of any spokes.
It may be possible to mount 700c - the modern road standard size - wheels on your bike. If you can adjust your brake pads 4mm down from where they meet the 27" rims then 700C will probably fit without major modifications. THis is often easier with caliper brakes than with cantilever brakes. This modification gives you a couple benefits: esp. much wider choice of tires and rims, and a few mm of extra clearance if you want to run slightly wider tires (many bikes that came with 27x1-1/4 tires can be fitter with 700 X 35 or even 38mm wide tires.
You don't need a chain wear gage - you only need a 12" ruler. Measure from the centre of one pin on the bottom run of chain to the centre of the pin closest to 12" along. If the chain is more than ~1/16" 'stretched' over 12" then it is likely worn to the point that a new chain will not mesh properly with your old cogs.
Likes For Wilfred Laurier:
#6
Member
Thread Starter
Edit 1: Um, I made mistakes in the OP, I'm not riding 7500mi/year now, just maybe 1000. Was riding maybe 400 before this year but my gym closed so, ride more to get to new one.
Edit 2: I DO have a chain guage. Haven't used it, bought it a few months ago from Asia. Cheap, but I figure it probably works. Didn't come with instructions, I figure I can figure out how to use it somehow. The chain I'm using has a quick-link, I don't have to use a chain removal tool to get it off to clean it. I've cleaned my chains for years once in a while with paint thinner swishing in a big pan.
Last edited by dmusicant; 09-24-19 at 03:41 PM.
#7
Member
Thread Starter
What you describe doesn't give me hesitation in stating that you can rebuild your current wheel with some careful measurements. Spokes break; it happens. When lots of spokes break, generally they've had all the loading they can take. Jobst Brandt thought it was due to loose spokes, and that tighter spokes gave better service. Unless your rim is pretty dinged up and no longer sufficiently round and the hub cups are pitted or worn out, or just plain cheap, rebuilding a wheel is one way to understand how your wheels work and how to patch them up. If you're intimidated and want a bike shop to do it, you might be better off buying a new wheel.
Or just swap the freewheels, no other thought needed.
Wheelbuilding isn't hard if you have the tools and the patience.
Or just swap the freewheels, no other thought needed.
Wheelbuilding isn't hard if you have the tools and the patience.
Why not use the spare wheel? At least its spokes look good, clean, unrusted and they don't respond to a magnet, which convinces me they are SS.
#8
Member
Thread Starter
I'm surprised to read in this thread that insufficient spoke tension leads to broken spokes. I suspected (intuitively) that broken spokes happened because some spokes were too tight.
I have no way of knowing if my spokes are too tight or too loose other than what Cuthbertson said in his Anybody's Bike Book (which I've had for decades) saying to go around your rim and get a sense of the median spoke tension and just try to get your spokes all in the neighborhood of that tension (while having the rim reasonably true). That's been my M.O. ever since. I haven't bothered checking the tensions or even much checking trueness of the rims unless I detect problems (e.g. rim rubbing on brake pads). But the last week or so I've been checking the spoke tensions and trueness of the rim almost daily. That rim isn't keeping true. Several spokes were obviously too loose yesterday. I'm hoping that other wheel would be better.
I have no way of knowing if my spokes are too tight or too loose other than what Cuthbertson said in his Anybody's Bike Book (which I've had for decades) saying to go around your rim and get a sense of the median spoke tension and just try to get your spokes all in the neighborhood of that tension (while having the rim reasonably true). That's been my M.O. ever since. I haven't bothered checking the tensions or even much checking trueness of the rims unless I detect problems (e.g. rim rubbing on brake pads). But the last week or so I've been checking the spoke tensions and trueness of the rim almost daily. That rim isn't keeping true. Several spokes were obviously too loose yesterday. I'm hoping that other wheel would be better.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1324 Post(s)
Liked 927 Times
in
640 Posts
When you say rebuild the wheel, do you mean also replacing the spokes? That sounds intimidating. The only tools I have for that are spoke wrenches.
Why not use the spare wheel? At least its spokes look good, clean, unrusted and they don't respond to a magnet, which convinces me they are SS.
Why not use the spare wheel? At least its spokes look good, clean, unrusted and they don't respond to a magnet, which convinces me they are SS.
Cheers
Likes For Miele Man:
#10
The dropped
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 2,144
Bikes: Pake C'Mute Touring/Commuter Build, 1989 Kona Cinder Cone, 1995 Trek 5200, 1973 Raleigh Super Course FG, 1960/61 Montgomery Ward Hawthorne "thrift" 3 speed, by Hercules (sold) : 1966 Schwinn Deluxe Racer (sold)
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1739 Post(s)
Liked 1,014 Times
in
696 Posts
Rebuilding the wheel would be more an issue if you had a suntour accushift cassette and freehub. There's no current replacement for that. But you don't, just unscrew your current freehub and swap to the new wheel. Or don't. If you're using friction shifters, freehub spacing doesn't matter.
#11
Steel is real
You don't need a chain wear gage - you only need a 12" ruler. Measure from the centre of one pin on the bottom run of chain to the centre of the pin closest to 12" along. If the chain is more than ~1/16" 'stretched' over 12" then it is likely worn to the point that a new chain will not mesh properly with your old cogs.
#12
Steel is real
#13
Senior Member
If the rim and hub of your current wheel are satisfactory, the best option is to have it rebuilt by a good wheelbuilder/mechanic, or if you want you can pick up the tools and do it yourself. Spokes break mostly due to uneven or insufficient tension which is common on factory wheels, especially on what is mostly a budget segment of the market these days--27". Basically, when a load is applied to a wheel the spokes near the ground loose tension--if tension is inadequate they slacken and fatigue where they bend repetitively.
If the current rim/hub are crummy, old hubs are relatively easy to buy on eBay, or many shops will even have some in a parts drawer somewhere. The nicest easily available/inexpensive freewheel hub that most bike shops can order is probably https://velo-orange.com/collections/...heel-hub-126mm. If a bike shop has a JBI account, they can order some really cheap but serviceable wheelmaster hubs. If you really want to not have a QR lever you can get tooled skewers. Hollow axles are minimally less strong than solid ones by nature, and are usually higher quality and thus actually stronger. Companies like Velocity still make very high quality rims in 27" (the Dyad, in this example).
If the current rim/hub are crummy, old hubs are relatively easy to buy on eBay, or many shops will even have some in a parts drawer somewhere. The nicest easily available/inexpensive freewheel hub that most bike shops can order is probably https://velo-orange.com/collections/...heel-hub-126mm. If a bike shop has a JBI account, they can order some really cheap but serviceable wheelmaster hubs. If you really want to not have a QR lever you can get tooled skewers. Hollow axles are minimally less strong than solid ones by nature, and are usually higher quality and thus actually stronger. Companies like Velocity still make very high quality rims in 27" (the Dyad, in this example).
#14
Señor Member
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 5,066
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 649 Post(s)
Liked 292 Times
in
215 Posts
Respoking a wheel only requires one tool - a spoke wrench that properly fits your nipples.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
#15
The dropped
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 2,144
Bikes: Pake C'Mute Touring/Commuter Build, 1989 Kona Cinder Cone, 1995 Trek 5200, 1973 Raleigh Super Course FG, 1960/61 Montgomery Ward Hawthorne "thrift" 3 speed, by Hercules (sold) : 1966 Schwinn Deluxe Racer (sold)
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1739 Post(s)
Liked 1,014 Times
in
696 Posts
I agree that rebuilding his current wheel is a possibility, but if he has a readily available wheel with a freewheel and the right OLN width, why bother? The only reason I'm bothering building/rebuilding wheels is because I'm being stubborn in keeping the Accushift stuff that came with the bike, and I need a Suntour freehub to do it.
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1324 Post(s)
Liked 927 Times
in
640 Posts
Respoking a wheel only requires one tool - a spoke wrench that properly fits your nipples.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
Cheers
#17
Member
Thread Starter
I'd try the spare wheel. If you get chain skip you could then either change the freewheels or get a new chain. I'd be inclined to change the freewheels if the chain skipped since you know the one freewheel works well with the chain you have on the bike. Changing the chain might not work if the spare wheel freewheel is also worn.
Cheers
Cheers
Actually, I think I'll just swap wheels and at the same time swap freewheels. Presumably the old chain shouldn't give obvious problems with the freewheel I've been using. Otherwise, if I get chain skipping with the Suntour freewheel, I have to dismount the tire again. I hate messing with rear wheels, so much more work than front wheels... including getting the chain back onto the derailleur. I don't do it often enough to feel comfortable doing it. Plus, I have a thorn resistant tube in that back wheel, plus a urethane tire liner! It makes for very few flats, but messing with the wheel is a chore.
#18
Member
Thread Starter
Respoking a wheel only requires one tool - a spoke wrench that properly fits your nipples.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
It can be made much easier and faster with second tool called a 'nipple driver' - basically a slot screwdriver with a tip profile that keeps the tip centred in the nipple head.
Here's a link to the Park Tool version: https://www.mec.ca/en/product/5048-7...-Nipple-Driver - you can spin the nipples a bit faster with this tool than with a straight screwdriver and this is a nice feature if you regularly build wheels. For doing one or two wheels over your lifetime you can improvise with a plain screwdriver, or modify a screwdriver with a file if you wish. You use your nipple driver to get the spokes and nipples installed, then do final tightening, tensioning and truing with the spoke wrench.
It is easier if you have a wheel truing stand, but you can also just use your brake pads (or a zip tie) as a gauge and tension and true the wheel while it is mounted in your frame.
Generally speaking, you should start by bringing the spokes up to nice high and even feeling tension, then work on removing the 'out-of-roundness' (or 'up-and-down') by working around the rim and tightening or loosening adjacent spokes to move that section of the rim closer or further from the hub, then work on side-to-side truing. Then remove the wheel and flip it around and install it into the frame or fork backwards and see if the rim is in the same place respective of your brake pads... this is checking the 'dish' - the centeredness of the rim between the dropouts. If the rim is closer to one side than the other, you tighten all the spokes on one side and loosen all the spokes on the other side to pull the rim toward where it will be centred, then flip the wheel over to check the dish again, and repeat until the rim is centred and the location between the brake pads doesn't change when the wheel is flipped.
The spoke nipple driver. Can I use a cordless screwdriver instead?
Now, the process of re-spoking a wheel, do you do this one spoke at a time, i.e. remove one old spoke and replace with a new one, and continue until you get them all (36?)?
I don't have a wheel truing stand. What I do have is what I think is an old weight lifting bench which many years ago I converted to a bike repair stand. I can suspend the bike on it, at least the rear wheel, so it spins freely. This is good for truing the back wheel. I've been eyeballing the clearance of the brake pads. What I haven't done (maybe ever) is pay attention to the up/down movement, just side to side! I guess that's a mistake.
Now flipping the wheel around to correct for dish... This has me confused. I read the other day (and once before) that rear wheels (at least on 12 speed bikes like mine) have dished rear wheels. So, wouldn't that make it hard or impossible to correct for incorrect dish by turning a rear wheel over and re-truing?
#19
Member
Thread Starter
Rebuilding the wheel would be more an issue if you had a suntour accushift cassette and freehub. There's no current replacement for that. But you don't, just unscrew your current freehub and swap to the new wheel. Or don't. If you're using friction shifters, freehub spacing doesn't matter.
#20
Member
Thread Starter
I went to a dollar store and bought a few cheap screwdrivers that I then filed down until the thing tip fitted into the hole in a spoke nipple. One screwdriver/nipple driver was filed so that it released after four turns of the spoke. I got that idea from Jobst Brand's THE BICYCLE WHEEL book years ago. I have a couple of other screwdriver/nipple drivers that release after a different number of turns. It makes tightening the spokes to a certain point really easy.
Cheers
Cheers
Edit: Oh, thinking about it, I suppose if the screwdriver tip angles in, eventually the edges will catch on the holes in the rim and make it impossible to drive the nipple down on the spoke end any further. Is that the concept?
Last edited by dmusicant; 09-26-19 at 08:54 PM.
#21
The dropped
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 2,144
Bikes: Pake C'Mute Touring/Commuter Build, 1989 Kona Cinder Cone, 1995 Trek 5200, 1973 Raleigh Super Course FG, 1960/61 Montgomery Ward Hawthorne "thrift" 3 speed, by Hercules (sold) : 1966 Schwinn Deluxe Racer (sold)
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1739 Post(s)
Liked 1,014 Times
in
696 Posts
A few questions:
The spoke nipple driver. Can I use a cordless screwdriver instead?
Now, the process of re-spoking a wheel, do you do this one spoke at a time, i.e. remove one old spoke and replace with a new one, and continue until you get them all (36?)?
I don't have a wheel truing stand. What I do have is what I think is an old weight lifting bench which many years ago I converted to a bike repair stand. I can suspend the bike on it, at least the rear wheel, so it spins freely. This is good for truing the back wheel. I've been eyeballing the clearance of the brake pads. What I haven't done (maybe ever) is pay attention to the up/down movement, just side to side! I guess that's a mistake.
Now flipping the wheel around to correct for dish... This has me confused. I read the other day (and once before) that rear wheels (at least on 12 speed bikes like mine) have dished rear wheels. So, wouldn't that make it hard or impossible to correct for incorrect dish by turning a rear wheel over and re-truing?
The spoke nipple driver. Can I use a cordless screwdriver instead?
Now, the process of re-spoking a wheel, do you do this one spoke at a time, i.e. remove one old spoke and replace with a new one, and continue until you get them all (36?)?
I don't have a wheel truing stand. What I do have is what I think is an old weight lifting bench which many years ago I converted to a bike repair stand. I can suspend the bike on it, at least the rear wheel, so it spins freely. This is good for truing the back wheel. I've been eyeballing the clearance of the brake pads. What I haven't done (maybe ever) is pay attention to the up/down movement, just side to side! I guess that's a mistake.
Now flipping the wheel around to correct for dish... This has me confused. I read the other day (and once before) that rear wheels (at least on 12 speed bikes like mine) have dished rear wheels. So, wouldn't that make it hard or impossible to correct for incorrect dish by turning a rear wheel over and re-truing?
It's true that rear wheels are dished. The angles from the flanges to the rim are greater on the freewheel side, because the flange is closer to the center. You can flip the wheel in the drop outs to verify dish because the rim should be over the center of the hub body and the lock nuts, not centered between the flanges.
#22
The dropped
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 2,144
Bikes: Pake C'Mute Touring/Commuter Build, 1989 Kona Cinder Cone, 1995 Trek 5200, 1973 Raleigh Super Course FG, 1960/61 Montgomery Ward Hawthorne "thrift" 3 speed, by Hercules (sold) : 1966 Schwinn Deluxe Racer (sold)
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1739 Post(s)
Liked 1,014 Times
in
696 Posts
To rebuild, you would reduce tension all the way around the wheel first. I'd remove all the spokes first, because you'll eventually need to lace them, and it's easier if you have all your "heads out" spokes in first. Sheldon Brown's page on wheelbuilding is a wonderful resource here.
Again, spokes aren't cheap and will likely get more expensive as tariffs take effect. You're better served swapping wheels for now.
Rebuilding is significantly easier with a dedicated stand, and I'd recommend a tension meter so you can have confidence in your build. Lowest price on that is around $80, $120-130 if you buy Park Tools tension meter and cheap straight gauge spokes.
This means that buying machine-built wheels is cheaper the first time. You'll get a whole wheelset starting at $150.
Again, spokes aren't cheap and will likely get more expensive as tariffs take effect. You're better served swapping wheels for now.
Rebuilding is significantly easier with a dedicated stand, and I'd recommend a tension meter so you can have confidence in your build. Lowest price on that is around $80, $120-130 if you buy Park Tools tension meter and cheap straight gauge spokes.
This means that buying machine-built wheels is cheaper the first time. You'll get a whole wheelset starting at $150.
Last edited by Unca_Sam; 09-26-19 at 07:13 PM.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1324 Post(s)
Liked 927 Times
in
640 Posts
Yup, this is my thinking. Thank you... it's on my short list of projects! By this time next week, it should be done.
Actually, I think I'll just swap wheels and at the same time swap freewheels. Presumably the old chain shouldn't give obvious problems with the freewheel I've been using. Otherwise, if I get chain skipping with the Suntour freewheel, I have to dismount the tire again. I hate messing with rear wheels, so much more work than front wheels... including getting the chain back onto the derailleur. I don't do it often enough to feel comfortable doing it. Plus, I have a thorn resistant tube in that back wheel, plus a urethane tire liner! It makes for very few flats, but messing with the wheel is a chore.
Actually, I think I'll just swap wheels and at the same time swap freewheels. Presumably the old chain shouldn't give obvious problems with the freewheel I've been using. Otherwise, if I get chain skipping with the Suntour freewheel, I have to dismount the tire again. I hate messing with rear wheels, so much more work than front wheels... including getting the chain back onto the derailleur. I don't do it often enough to feel comfortable doing it. Plus, I have a thorn resistant tube in that back wheel, plus a urethane tire liner! It makes for very few flats, but messing with the wheel is a chore.
Cheers
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1324 Post(s)
Liked 927 Times
in
640 Posts
Cheers
#25
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1324 Post(s)
Liked 927 Times
in
640 Posts
I don't understand this. How would a screwdriver release after N turns of a spoke (nipple)?
Edit: Oh, thinking about it, I suppose if the screwdriver tip angles in, eventually the edges will catch on the holes in the rim and make it impossible to drive the nipple down on the spoke end any further. Is that the concept?
Edit: Oh, thinking about it, I suppose if the screwdriver tip angles in, eventually the edges will catch on the holes in the rim and make it impossible to drive the nipple down on the spoke end any further. Is that the concept?
Here it is with a spoke nipple and a spoke
Here it is with the spoke nipple on it.
Here it is with the spoke nipple getting screwed onto the spoke. I did it off the wheel for clarity.
Here it is with the spoke nipple screwed partway onto the spoke and you can see how the spoke has pushed the driver away from the spoke nipple.
By adjusting the length of that narrow center section when making the tool you can control how far onto the spoke each spoke nipple goes.
Cheers
Likes For Miele Man: