BATES B.A.R. 1954 build advice
#26
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thanks for the input 63rickert!
I wanted to get a 48 or 46 chainring, but couldn't find a suitable match. This crank and bb is just to get this project rolling so I can enjoy the Bates as a built bike while I search down the right parts. I had the stronglight crank and french thread pedals sitting in a bin from a french build that never happened. Chater Lea or Williams single chainring cottered is what I want for the final solution. In addition, I think my cheap chrome english threaded headset, with a nice low 30mm stack height is going to at least solve that problem for now. I would like to get a TDC or some other period correct headset in the future. Last will probably be the wheels.
@ big block when I see a listing like that I usually think the seller isn't motivated to sell very much. I stumbled across an interesting thread on another forum, https://www.lfgss.com/conversations/229926/?offset=450 in which you and others discussed a lot of problems in acquiring period correct parts. It made for a very informative read! I'm not patient enough to wait until I have everything in hand but I feel like I made some good progress with the brakes, stem, handle bars and seatpost.
I wanted to get a 48 or 46 chainring, but couldn't find a suitable match. This crank and bb is just to get this project rolling so I can enjoy the Bates as a built bike while I search down the right parts. I had the stronglight crank and french thread pedals sitting in a bin from a french build that never happened. Chater Lea or Williams single chainring cottered is what I want for the final solution. In addition, I think my cheap chrome english threaded headset, with a nice low 30mm stack height is going to at least solve that problem for now. I would like to get a TDC or some other period correct headset in the future. Last will probably be the wheels.
@ big block when I see a listing like that I usually think the seller isn't motivated to sell very much. I stumbled across an interesting thread on another forum, https://www.lfgss.com/conversations/229926/?offset=450 in which you and others discussed a lot of problems in acquiring period correct parts. It made for a very informative read! I'm not patient enough to wait until I have everything in hand but I feel like I made some good progress with the brakes, stem, handle bars and seatpost.
#27
Senior Member
@ big block when I see a listing like that I usually think the seller isn't motivated to sell very much. I stumbled across an interesting thread on another forum, https://www.lfgss.com/conversations/229926/?offset=450 in which you and others discussed a lot of problems in acquiring period correct parts. It made for a very informative read! I'm not patient enough to wait until I have everything in hand but I feel like I made some good progress with the brakes, stem, handle bars and seatpost.
Three and a half years after getting the frame, it is nearing completion. Just waiting on some tyres to be shipped (yes on a boat because there are no flights) from Japan, and parts to convert a Sturmey Archer 4 speed trigger to an ACS trigger. These are from the USA.
And I have an alternative saddle frame to recover and will probable go onto this bike. And to consider the options with that Lytaloy crankset.
I enjoy the researching, and the problem solving. And I get to ride the other bikes in the meantime.
Philip
#28
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Together again
Well, today my cheap headset came in the mail and I was able to reunite the Bates fork and frame. The headset fit perfectly with no need for spacers. 35 mm stack height. In addition I installed the head tube grease nipple which was a pita.
I checked the fork dropouts which were in perfect alignment, which is cool because this fork is super stiff. The rosette on the fork blades is wrong, it should be diadrant not cantiflex, but I can live with this faux pas. Still waiting for brakes and handlebar & stem from UK.
I checked the fork dropouts which were in perfect alignment, which is cool because this fork is super stiff. The rosette on the fork blades is wrong, it should be diadrant not cantiflex, but I can live with this faux pas. Still waiting for brakes and handlebar & stem from UK.
Last edited by JJScaliger; 07-21-20 at 04:18 PM.
#29
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Some pieces to the puzzle have arrived. GB spear point stem and Reynolds aluminum Bailey track bars.
My intended seatpost came but was a 27.2 not 27.0 mm, which my frame requires. This domed reynolds seatpost was so perfect but not to be. I'll save it for another project. It feels super light.
.
Waiting for brakes, levers and bottom brackets from UK.
My intended seatpost came but was a 27.2 not 27.0 mm, which my frame requires. This domed reynolds seatpost was so perfect but not to be. I'll save it for another project. It feels super light.
.
Waiting for brakes, levers and bottom brackets from UK.
#30
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Just for the record if anyone needs this in the future, I measured this Reynolds R5 aluminum domed seatpost at approx. 27.2 with a caliper.
#31
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Almost alive. Still waiting for brake levers and bottom bracket from UK.
GB standard (HIDUMINIUM)
suntour sprint
GB spearpoint and Reynolds Bailey track bars
grease nip painstakingly installed
I bought a cheap Kalloy pillar seatpost until I can find a more appropriate solution.
The bars have 50 4 stamped on them. I'm not sure if this is a date or not.
The GB standards have plenty of reach. There is plenty more if I needed it. 26" wheels, I don't know. I was concerned about the reach because I ran into a similar problem when I converted my Dawes from 27" to 700c. My Weinmann Vainqueur 999 only reach the rims when completely bottomed out.
I have a TA 46 chainring on the way for my Stronglight 49D.
The levers are new old stock GB Arret coureur with white housing and cables included. I'm thinking black cotton bar tape.
GB standard (HIDUMINIUM)
suntour sprint
GB spearpoint and Reynolds Bailey track bars
grease nip painstakingly installed
I bought a cheap Kalloy pillar seatpost until I can find a more appropriate solution.
The bars have 50 4 stamped on them. I'm not sure if this is a date or not.
The GB standards have plenty of reach. There is plenty more if I needed it. 26" wheels, I don't know. I was concerned about the reach because I ran into a similar problem when I converted my Dawes from 27" to 700c. My Weinmann Vainqueur 999 only reach the rims when completely bottomed out.
I have a TA 46 chainring on the way for my Stronglight 49D.
The levers are new old stock GB Arret coureur with white housing and cables included. I'm thinking black cotton bar tape.
Last edited by JJScaliger; 07-31-20 at 01:51 PM. Reason: added stuff
#32
Senior Member
27.2 seatpost is correct. All Bates were built with 21/24 gauge butted tubing. Only way Reynolds made the Cantiflex tubes. In metric that is 0.81/0.56. With an OD for the seat tube of 1-1/8 or 28.6. Do the arithmetic. Heat distortion takes 0.2, any frame.
It is extremely common for seat lugs to get mashed somewhere in a long history. About 999 times out of 1000 it is easy to bend them back to where they belong. This one is a little bit of a surprise as the Bates seatlug is massive. But only a little. Since this is such a special frame, find a frame builder or old school steel bike mechanic who can show you the ropes. You could ride it a little while with a 27.0, some risk if done long term.
One way to damage any steel frame is to ride it without a vent. Domed top to seatpost is pretty, and then condensation stays inside. Even on a stored display piece tubes will rust from inside. Either an open top seatpost or drill a vent in bottom of BB shell. On a rider it is entirely kosher to drill the most antique shell. Or the most antique seatpost.
It is extremely common for seat lugs to get mashed somewhere in a long history. About 999 times out of 1000 it is easy to bend them back to where they belong. This one is a little bit of a surprise as the Bates seatlug is massive. But only a little. Since this is such a special frame, find a frame builder or old school steel bike mechanic who can show you the ropes. You could ride it a little while with a 27.0, some risk if done long term.
One way to damage any steel frame is to ride it without a vent. Domed top to seatpost is pretty, and then condensation stays inside. Even on a stored display piece tubes will rust from inside. Either an open top seatpost or drill a vent in bottom of BB shell. On a rider it is entirely kosher to drill the most antique shell. Or the most antique seatpost.
#34
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thanks for the info 63rickert! The 27.2 almost fits at the top but after about 3/4" in it feels too tight. I used a drill hone to try and clean out any burrs or oxidation, but it still felt too tight. I had heard that some Reynolds tubes took 27.0 so that seemed like it might have been the case. The Reynolds seatpost does have a tiny hole on the top of the dome. My bb shell does have a small hole drilled in the center. I think whoever repainted this frame added the shifter braze on and drilled a hole to install a fixture to route the cable on the bottom. I think the frame has recently been drilled for brakes as well. It had a burr inside the fork crown that looked pretty fresh.
Could you post a picture of your Bates? I would love to see it!
Could you post a picture of your Bates? I would love to see it!
#35
2 wheeled enthusiast
That is one sexy beast! Hard to not stop and stare at a Bates B.A.R. when you notice those forks.
#36
Senior Member
Thread Starter
That is one sexy beast! Hard to not stop and stare at a Bates B.A.R. when you notice those forks.
In the winter I bought a scruffy Raleigh Sports three speed with drop bars to use as a commuter. I basically tuned it up swapped the front wheel and tires and it was ready to roll. I've been having a blast riding it to work. It has that magic 48 x 18 direct drive which is perfect for my mostly flat commute. I started to think what would a 3 speed be like with a lighter frame, Reynolds right? So I began to hunt for a Bates or a Claud Butler with bi-laminate lugs. I saw a lot of beat down frames on ebay.uk that either had bad amateur repaints or were rusted and dinged up. Then I saw this frame with that flamboyant bottle green for a reasonable price.
The original idea was for this bike to be a 3 speed with SA AM rear IGH. I'm starting to like the flip flop idea more and more as a permanent set up.
#37
multimodal commuter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: NJ, NYC, LI
Posts: 19,808
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
Mentioned: 584 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1908 Post(s)
Liked 574 Times
in
339 Posts
Thanks! I always thought these frames looked cool and I wanted to work on a project where the respray had already been done. Most of the bikes I've restored in the past have been more modern and scruffier. My Dawes is a good example; it has decent original paint, pretty lugs, a nice metal head badge and shiny chrome. I definitely made it more contemporary by replacing the bb and crank with a stronglight 93 cotterless and suntour derailleurs and shifters.
In the winter I bought a scruffy Raleigh Sports three speed with drop bars to use as a commuter. I basically tuned it up swapped the front wheel and tires and it was ready to roll. I've been having a blast riding it to work. It has that magic 48 x 18 direct drive which is perfect for my mostly flat commute. I started to think what would a 3 speed be like with a lighter frame, Reynolds right? So I began to hunt for a Bates or a Claud Butler with bi-laminate lugs. I saw a lot of beat down frames on ebay.uk that either had bad amateur repaints or were rusted and dinged up. Then I saw this frame with that flamboyant bottle green for a reasonable price.
The original idea was for this bike to be a 3 speed with SA AM rear IGH. I'm starting to like the flip flop idea more and more as a permanent set up.
In the winter I bought a scruffy Raleigh Sports three speed with drop bars to use as a commuter. I basically tuned it up swapped the front wheel and tires and it was ready to roll. I've been having a blast riding it to work. It has that magic 48 x 18 direct drive which is perfect for my mostly flat commute. I started to think what would a 3 speed be like with a lighter frame, Reynolds right? So I began to hunt for a Bates or a Claud Butler with bi-laminate lugs. I saw a lot of beat down frames on ebay.uk that either had bad amateur repaints or were rusted and dinged up. Then I saw this frame with that flamboyant bottle green for a reasonable price.
The original idea was for this bike to be a 3 speed with SA AM rear IGH. I'm starting to like the flip flop idea more and more as a permanent set up.
I have used a few different four speed hubs, and they are great too, even better than three speed hubs, when they behave themselves. But sadly they are all 50 or more years old, and they do not always behave themselves. Which really ruins the experience.
If you have any hills, I don't think you can beat the good old AW hub. It's just so simple... and reliable....
__________________
www.rhmsaddles.com.
www.rhmsaddles.com.
#38
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Three speed hubs are a lot of fun if they behave themselves!
I have used a few different four speed hubs, and they are great too, even better than three speed hubs, when they behave themselves. But sadly they are all 50 or more years old, and they do not always behave themselves. Which really ruins the experience. If you have any hills, I don't think you can beat the good old AW hub. It's just so simple... and reliable...
I have used a few different four speed hubs, and they are great too, even better than three speed hubs, when they behave themselves. But sadly they are all 50 or more years old, and they do not always behave themselves. Which really ruins the experience. If you have any hills, I don't think you can beat the good old AW hub. It's just so simple... and reliable...
The Bates was bought with the intention of making it a tubular IGH 3 speed. The flip flop idea is fun, the 4 speed Campy GS idea is fun. I'll probably do all 3 setups eventually.
The flip flop Suntour sprint wheelset will probably end up on a frame I have in storage when I want a change and build up the 3 speed wheelset. Gitane Interclub? I don't know. Stronglight 49 to that when I get the proper cottered crankset for the Bates. An ancillary project made up of left over parts.
#39
Senior Member
Thanks for the info 63rickert! The 27.2 almost fits at the top but after about 3/4" in it feels too tight. I used a drill hone to try and clean out any burrs or oxidation, but it still felt too tight. I had heard that some Reynolds tubes took 27.0 so that seemed like it might have been the case. The Reynolds seatpost does have a tiny hole on the top of the dome. My bb shell does have a small hole drilled in the center. I think whoever repainted this frame added the shifter braze on and drilled a hole to install a fixture to route the cable on the bottom. I think the frame has recently been drilled for brakes as well. It had a burr inside the fork crown that looked pretty fresh.
Could you post a picture of your Bates? I would love to see it!
Could you post a picture of your Bates? I would love to see it!
Somewhere in the archives of this site there exist photos of the bike. Photos someone else took. Posted in an smontanaro thread from last summer. Summer before?
You want an accurate seat tube bore and a seatpost that fits. Things that are supposed to remain static but don’t are the worst problems to have. Yes, Reynolds made all sorts of tubes and 27.0 is a common post for English bikes. Your bike takes 27.2. I cannot tell you why your bore has a taper. I can promise you that if the bore is bigger at top the seatpost will rock. Then the seatlug cracks. Been there, done that.
#40
multimodal commuter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: NJ, NYC, LI
Posts: 19,808
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
Mentioned: 584 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1908 Post(s)
Liked 574 Times
in
339 Posts
That said, it is not that the climbing gear ("B") slips, but that the trigger slips from B to L. For the higher gears, the trigger shifter pulls against a rather mild spring, which is fine, but from L to B it's pulling against a much firmer spring. This puts a lot of pressure on the part of the trigger that holds it in B, and (consequently) it wears out... and then it fails.
For what is worth, any FW hub can be converted to a five speed hub, with a second shifter. This solves the problem of the slipping gear.
And, of course, you can put the guts of any AW, FW or 5S hub into the shell of any of those. Completely interchangable. The alloy shell hubs of the early 50's are especially nice, and can be found with 36 holes.
__________________
www.rhmsaddles.com.
www.rhmsaddles.com.
#41
Senior Member
Thread Starter
This week a couple of parts were delivered for this build. A Bayliss Wiley Continental front hub and a TA 46 chainring, both nib.
The front hub will be on the back burner until I find the right rim to build it up.. The wingnuts I bought separately. I'll pair this front hub with the sturmey archer aw rear.
I'm still waiting patiently for the brake levers and bottom bracket from UK. Also crank bolts and cloth tape. I have two Huret chrome top tube clips for the brake cable in the bin. So close...
The front hub will be on the back burner until I find the right rim to build it up.. The wingnuts I bought separately. I'll pair this front hub with the sturmey archer aw rear.
I'm still waiting patiently for the brake levers and bottom bracket from UK. Also crank bolts and cloth tape. I have two Huret chrome top tube clips for the brake cable in the bin. So close...
Likes For JJScaliger:
#42
Senior Member
Thread Starter
In my relentless search for all things Bates (diadrant), I lucked onto this today:
posted on an English bike forum about 5 years ago. From a 1950-54 catalogue (Bates London).
Interesting to research oem specs. The other catalogue I found a couple of months ago was much earlier, 1937 on this cool website.
Catalogues & Manuals - Three Speed Hub
I saw the 1937 catalogue on ebay.uk recently for north of £100
posted on an English bike forum about 5 years ago. From a 1950-54 catalogue (Bates London).
Interesting to research oem specs. The other catalogue I found a couple of months ago was much earlier, 1937 on this cool website.
Catalogues & Manuals - Three Speed Hub
I saw the 1937 catalogue on ebay.uk recently for north of £100
Likes For JJScaliger:
#43
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2020
Posts: 331
Bikes: '68 Masi Special road, Grail bike
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 108 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 70 Times
in
58 Posts
the spacing combined with the shifter braze on makes me think the stock setup was
a Sturmey setup with two cogs (remove the cog spacers and a 2nd cog will fit with their "backs"
together) and a Cyclo derailleur for 1/8 inch chain
a Sturmey setup with two cogs (remove the cog spacers and a 2nd cog will fit with their "backs"
together) and a Cyclo derailleur for 1/8 inch chain
#44
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Bottom bracket Monday
My bottom brackets from UK came today. A stronglight 118 and TDC with spindle #4 . I intend to use the stronglight cotterless for now with my 49D. I purchased the TDC bottom bracket for when that perfect crankset comes along; maybe a Williams 1200 or a Chater Lea. The bbs came from the same seller, so 2 birds with one stone. I think the included #4 looks too long so I preemptively ordered a TDC #6 for a single chainring. That nos spindle cost more than either of the bbs! 63rickert shamed me into the purchase. Deep down I knew it was the right thing to do.
TDC with #4 & #6
Stronglight 118
I had to order a couple of wrenchs for the stronglight bb. I did find a nice used Var for the adjustable cup. This build is teaching me to be more patient.
TDC with #4 & #6
Stronglight 118
I had to order a couple of wrenchs for the stronglight bb. I did find a nice used Var for the adjustable cup. This build is teaching me to be more patient.
Last edited by JJScaliger; 08-10-20 at 02:37 PM. Reason: phone typing
#45
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Progress
I was able to install the bottom bracket today. My 38mm wrench came in the mail.
Here's the Bates with a complete drive train.
The GB brake levers came today.
Unfortunately I did not have time to install them. Something to look forward to tomorrow...
Here's the Bates with a complete drive train.
The GB brake levers came today.
Unfortunately I did not have time to install them. Something to look forward to tomorrow...
#47
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Such an interesting bike. Loving this thread.
Asking for help was a good idea. Everyone's advise and suggestions pushed this project forward at a much faster rate than I could have done by myself. Thanks to all!
#48
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Ridgefield, CT
Posts: 83
Bikes: 1988 Chas Roberts, 1988 Paramount, 1999 Bates BAR, 1973 Charles Roberts, 1976 Glen Erickson, 1986 Bill Davidson, 1986 John Hollands, 1992 Land Shark, 1992 Della Santa, 1969 Legnano Gran Premio, 1997 mark Nobilette
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 9 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times
in
4 Posts
Bates B.A.R
My Bates made by Ron Cooper in the 1990's. Len Phipps made the lugs.
Likes For jeff44:
#49
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Gorgeous bike, I love the paint! Those super record levers look great! I was tempted to get a pair for my Bates. I have a soft spot for drillium. Did you have center pull brakes in the past? The lugs look like Nervex professionals with cutouts. Cool! I wasn't familiar with Len Phipps, I just looked him up at Classic Lightweights. I think yours are tasteful; In my opinion some English lugs are a little too ornate. Thanks for posting!
#50
Senior Member
Thread Starter
On the road
This morning I installed the brakes which was pretty straight forward. In the afternoon all the planets came into alignment and my missing bits arrived.
Var spanner for the adjustable cup. I was able to use an adjustable wrench yesterday to get a basic adjustment but after I installed the left crank arm I couldn't get in again without pulling the crank. It still felt a smidge loose.I don't like to take these old cranks on and off again too many times. I knew the var wrench was going to be delivered today so I waited. The big surprise was the bartape. It wasn't scheduled to arrive until Thursday.
I was able to go for a short 12 mile test ride in the late afternoon. Rode to Roger Williams Park and rode three laps. Nothing off road. On the way to the park I rode past a basketball court and a 15 year old kid watched me ride by and said, "Damn!" I swear to god.
It rides very nice indeed! Similiar to a modern road bike with straight fork blades. The two bikes I ride the most are a Raleigh sports and a 1960s Dawes, both of which have very slack geometry. 63rickert was right about the fork; it dampens bumps better than the rear triangle. The brakes worked great.
I haven't decided if I'm going to shellac the bars. I probably will. I like the gearing 46 x 18 = 69 inches. I didn't hit any big hills but was able to power over everything I encountered.
A more substantial ride is on the agenda for tomorrow!
Var spanner for the adjustable cup. I was able to use an adjustable wrench yesterday to get a basic adjustment but after I installed the left crank arm I couldn't get in again without pulling the crank. It still felt a smidge loose.I don't like to take these old cranks on and off again too many times. I knew the var wrench was going to be delivered today so I waited. The big surprise was the bartape. It wasn't scheduled to arrive until Thursday.
I was able to go for a short 12 mile test ride in the late afternoon. Rode to Roger Williams Park and rode three laps. Nothing off road. On the way to the park I rode past a basketball court and a 15 year old kid watched me ride by and said, "Damn!" I swear to god.
It rides very nice indeed! Similiar to a modern road bike with straight fork blades. The two bikes I ride the most are a Raleigh sports and a 1960s Dawes, both of which have very slack geometry. 63rickert was right about the fork; it dampens bumps better than the rear triangle. The brakes worked great.
I haven't decided if I'm going to shellac the bars. I probably will. I like the gearing 46 x 18 = 69 inches. I didn't hit any big hills but was able to power over everything I encountered.
A more substantial ride is on the agenda for tomorrow!
Last edited by JJScaliger; 08-15-20 at 05:07 PM. Reason: added stuff