Tire for various urban terrain; 2 questions
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Tire for various urban terrain; 2 questions
I am a newbie and need some schooling in tires. Have had a Trek FX4 Carbon Sport for about two weeks and love the way it feels. Riding mostly on urban paths, with asphalt or concrete surface and the stock Bontrager R2 Hard-Case Lite Road Tire is fast.
On Saturday I came upon a short interconnect with hard packed soil and sand in some areas, and I fell, because I lost traction and control. I am sure a more skilled rider would have handled it, but that made me think about getting a tire that can handle a broader terrain. I realize there is no ideal tire, but would like to understand the trade-offs in tire choice and get some example recommendations. I looked for tires with smooth crown (is that the word?) and knobs on the side. For example:
The second question is about width. My stock tires are 32 mm wide, and while I do NOT intend to go full MTB/beach cruiser, can I put wider tires and on the rims? The front fork has a 46 mm clearance, so I was wondering if 35mm width adds some options.
All I want is a bit more confident grip on the occasional sandy or loose gravel patch. Puncture resistance is a must in Arizona. Light weight is the third criterion.
Any suggestion is gratefully appreciated.
On Saturday I came upon a short interconnect with hard packed soil and sand in some areas, and I fell, because I lost traction and control. I am sure a more skilled rider would have handled it, but that made me think about getting a tire that can handle a broader terrain. I realize there is no ideal tire, but would like to understand the trade-offs in tire choice and get some example recommendations. I looked for tires with smooth crown (is that the word?) and knobs on the side. For example:
- Bontrager H5 Hard-Case Ultimate Reflective Hybrid Tire
- WTB Byway Road Plus
- Schwalbe Marathon Plus
The second question is about width. My stock tires are 32 mm wide, and while I do NOT intend to go full MTB/beach cruiser, can I put wider tires and on the rims? The front fork has a 46 mm clearance, so I was wondering if 35mm width adds some options.
All I want is a bit more confident grip on the occasional sandy or loose gravel patch. Puncture resistance is a must in Arizona. Light weight is the third criterion.
Any suggestion is gratefully appreciated.
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 6,319
Bikes: 2012 Salsa Casseroll, 2009 Kona Blast
Mentioned: 13 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1031 Post(s)
Liked 208 Times
in
146 Posts
The tread on the Schwalbe won't be any better than a smooth tire. The appeal of Schwalbe is, they are extremely durable, and puncture resistant.
The others look like they would offer better performance on dirt or gravel, but worse performance on pavement. Also, part of the problem you may have had with your Hard Case Lites is the tire pressure. Not much you can do, but you would want to run your tires at a lower pressure on dirt or gravel than you would on pavement. That doesn't much help you if you do a ride on mixed surfaces, but I can say that in general, when 99% of my riding is on pavement and only 1% on dirt or gravel, I would just ride slowly through the gravel portions, and optimize my bike for performance on pavement. When I know I am going on a ride that is more than half dirt or gravel, I switch out just the front tire for better control. And FWIW, I use the Panaracer gravel king (the version with side knobs) just on my front tire, keep my Continental road tires for the back wheel.
The others look like they would offer better performance on dirt or gravel, but worse performance on pavement. Also, part of the problem you may have had with your Hard Case Lites is the tire pressure. Not much you can do, but you would want to run your tires at a lower pressure on dirt or gravel than you would on pavement. That doesn't much help you if you do a ride on mixed surfaces, but I can say that in general, when 99% of my riding is on pavement and only 1% on dirt or gravel, I would just ride slowly through the gravel portions, and optimize my bike for performance on pavement. When I know I am going on a ride that is more than half dirt or gravel, I switch out just the front tire for better control. And FWIW, I use the Panaracer gravel king (the version with side knobs) just on my front tire, keep my Continental road tires for the back wheel.
Likes For MRT2:
#3
aka Phil Jungels
I kind of disagree with MRT2, somewhat.
Although the Schwalbe tire you mention is not a gravel or mud or sand tire, it will be a little better than the smooth tire you are running -- but it won't be as fast. The minimal tread it has offers more traction in a variety of surfaces, you might encounter. A 35-37mm wide tire will ride considerably better than the tires on there now, but the tradeoff will be less speed.
I run Schwalbe Marathon Supreme 35 and 40mm tires on my Crosstrail, and can usually ride thru anything except soft dry sand. And it has way less tread than the tire you mentioned. I run 35 on the front, and 40 on the rear, for good handling, and better ride/higher capacity..
Schwalbe makes excellent tires for bicycles, and get one of their tubes for it also.
If you find sufficient space, a 35-37mm tire might be beneficial, but still not a real off road tire.
Sometimes, you just have to walk it thru!
Although the Schwalbe tire you mention is not a gravel or mud or sand tire, it will be a little better than the smooth tire you are running -- but it won't be as fast. The minimal tread it has offers more traction in a variety of surfaces, you might encounter. A 35-37mm wide tire will ride considerably better than the tires on there now, but the tradeoff will be less speed.
I run Schwalbe Marathon Supreme 35 and 40mm tires on my Crosstrail, and can usually ride thru anything except soft dry sand. And it has way less tread than the tire you mentioned. I run 35 on the front, and 40 on the rear, for good handling, and better ride/higher capacity..
Schwalbe makes excellent tires for bicycles, and get one of their tubes for it also.
If you find sufficient space, a 35-37mm tire might be beneficial, but still not a real off road tire.
Sometimes, you just have to walk it thru!
Last edited by Wanderer; 05-18-20 at 11:19 AM.
Likes For Wanderer:
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2017
Location: Northern Shenandoah Valley
Posts: 4,141
Bikes: More bikes than riders
Mentioned: 36 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1446 Post(s)
Liked 762 Times
in
570 Posts
In my experience, the primary factor when it comes to stability on loose surfaces is tire width. A wide tire, even a smooth one, will offer more stability and control than a narrower tire. I have a few bikes in my collection, one with 54-584 tires (often called "650b x 2.1", or "27.5 x 2.1") and, despite not being super knobby, are FAR more controllable off the road than even the 38-622 (often called "700c x 38") all surface tires on my hybrid. If you have loose gravel or loose sand, even the knobbiest 32mm tire will sink right in.
The tightest spot on your bike, as far as tire clearance, will probably be the rear triangle area, probably down at the chain stays. About how wide are the chain stays here?
The tightest spot on your bike, as far as tire clearance, will probably be the rear triangle area, probably down at the chain stays. About how wide are the chain stays here?
Likes For hokiefyd:
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Los Alamitos, Calif.
Posts: 2,475
Bikes: Canyon Endurace
Mentioned: 4 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1041 Post(s)
Liked 928 Times
in
541 Posts
Go the the Bontrager Ultimate. You should be able to fit a 38mm tire on your bike no problem (measure first).
Likes For TakingMyTime:
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: San Diego, California
Posts: 4,077
Bikes: Velo Orange Piolet
Mentioned: 28 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2228 Post(s)
Liked 2,011 Times
in
972 Posts
I am a newbie and need some schooling in tires. Have had a Trek FX4 Carbon Sport for about two weeks and love the way it feels. Riding mostly on urban paths, with asphalt or concrete surface and the stock Bontrager R2 Hard-Case Lite Road Tire is fast.
On Saturday I came upon a short interconnect with hard packed soil and sand in some areas, and I fell, because I lost traction and control. I am sure a more skilled rider would have handled it, but that made me think about getting a tire that can handle a broader terrain. I realize there is no ideal tire, but would like to understand the trade-offs in tire choice and get some example recommendations. I looked for tires with smooth crown (is that the word?) and knobs on the side. For example:
The second question is about width. My stock tires are 32 mm wide, and while I do NOT intend to go full MTB/beach cruiser, can I put wider tires and on the rims? The front fork has a 46 mm clearance, so I was wondering if 35mm width adds some options.
All I want is a bit more confident grip on the occasional sandy or loose gravel patch. Puncture resistance is a must in Arizona. Light weight is the third criterion.
Any suggestion is gratefully appreciated.
On Saturday I came upon a short interconnect with hard packed soil and sand in some areas, and I fell, because I lost traction and control. I am sure a more skilled rider would have handled it, but that made me think about getting a tire that can handle a broader terrain. I realize there is no ideal tire, but would like to understand the trade-offs in tire choice and get some example recommendations. I looked for tires with smooth crown (is that the word?) and knobs on the side. For example:
- Bontrager H5 Hard-Case Ultimate Reflective Hybrid Tire
- WTB Byway Road Plus
- Schwalbe Marathon Plus
The second question is about width. My stock tires are 32 mm wide, and while I do NOT intend to go full MTB/beach cruiser, can I put wider tires and on the rims? The front fork has a 46 mm clearance, so I was wondering if 35mm width adds some options.
All I want is a bit more confident grip on the occasional sandy or loose gravel patch. Puncture resistance is a must in Arizona. Light weight is the third criterion.
Any suggestion is gratefully appreciated.
Some other tires to consider: WTB Riddler and Panaracer Gravelking SK.
Likes For tyrion:
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
As I am learning about the trade-offs involved, and the magnitudes of the various effects, I am grateful for all your meaningful answers.
Grip seems related to the size of the contact patch, and for a given wheel diameter, width and inflation are probably the main determinants. For a casual ride with the wife, I am not going to futz with the pressure up and down. Of course I can slow down, or even walks some short stretches, but ultimately, I am left with width as the main variable. I measured the frame clearance at the chain stays and it's about 50mm, so 38 is about as wide as I can go.
Further, reading around the interwebz, I found out that shoulder knobs may not help that much, or at a minimum, are subject to some debate:
So I decided to upsize to 38mm. Byway was sold out of my size, so I went ahead and ordered the Bontrager H5 HardCase Ultimate. Very interested to see where this road takes me.
Grip seems related to the size of the contact patch, and for a given wheel diameter, width and inflation are probably the main determinants. For a casual ride with the wife, I am not going to futz with the pressure up and down. Of course I can slow down, or even walks some short stretches, but ultimately, I am left with width as the main variable. I measured the frame clearance at the chain stays and it's about 50mm, so 38 is about as wide as I can go.
Further, reading around the interwebz, I found out that shoulder knobs may not help that much, or at a minimum, are subject to some debate:
It’s in the corners where these tires disappoint: The shoulder knobs don’t really help. When you’re on slippery surfaces, you simply can’t lean far enough to engage the shoulder knobs. You’ll start sliding while you’re still on the ‘semi-slick’ portion, and by the time the shoulder knobs engage, you’re already going down.
The opposite is the case on pavement. There you can lean much further, but once you get onto the shoulder knobs, they fold over and the bike suddenly breaks away.
The opposite is the case on pavement. There you can lean much further, but once you get onto the shoulder knobs, they fold over and the bike suddenly breaks away.
#8
Junior Member
As I am learning about the trade-offs involved, and the magnitudes of the various effects, I am grateful for all your meaningful answers.
So I decided to upsize to 38mm. Byway was sold out of my size, so I went ahead and ordered the Bontrager H5 HardCase Ultimate. Very interested to see where this road takes me.
So I decided to upsize to 38mm. Byway was sold out of my size, so I went ahead and ordered the Bontrager H5 HardCase Ultimate. Very interested to see where this road takes me.
#9
Senior Member
As I am learning about the trade-offs involved, and the magnitudes of the various effects, I am grateful for all your meaningful answers.
Grip seems related to the size of the contact patch, and for a given wheel diameter, width and inflation are probably the main determinants. For a casual ride with the wife, I am not going to futz with the pressure up and down. Of course I can slow down, or even walks some short stretches, but ultimately, I am left with width as the main variable. I measured the frame clearance at the chain stays and it's about 50mm, so 38 is about as wide as I can go.
Further, reading around the interwebz, I found out that shoulder knobs may not help that much, or at a minimum, are subject to some debate:
So I decided to upsize to 38mm. Byway was sold out of my size, so I went ahead and ordered the Bontrager H5 HardCase Ultimate. Very interested to see where this road takes me.
Grip seems related to the size of the contact patch, and for a given wheel diameter, width and inflation are probably the main determinants. For a casual ride with the wife, I am not going to futz with the pressure up and down. Of course I can slow down, or even walks some short stretches, but ultimately, I am left with width as the main variable. I measured the frame clearance at the chain stays and it's about 50mm, so 38 is about as wide as I can go.
Further, reading around the interwebz, I found out that shoulder knobs may not help that much, or at a minimum, are subject to some debate:
So I decided to upsize to 38mm. Byway was sold out of my size, so I went ahead and ordered the Bontrager H5 HardCase Ultimate. Very interested to see where this road takes me.
I am looking for a quicker tire then the 50 mm Kenda "Multi surface" my Giant Sedona came with. They are a very good tire for what they are, But it might be fun to try out something closer to a road tire like the H5's. Too bad they don't make a 26" version.
Last edited by xroadcharlie; 06-11-20 at 12:01 PM.
Likes For xroadcharlie:
#10
Senior Member
Thread Starter
When time comes to replace, will look for a tubeless choice in the 38-40 range.
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Lewisville, TX
Posts: 660
Bikes: 1976 Motobecane Grand Touring, 2013 Fuji Absolute 2.1 hybrid, 2000 Mongoose S2000 MTB, 2009 Schwinn Jaguar beach cruiser
Mentioned: 4 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 83 Post(s)
Liked 193 Times
in
99 Posts
I put the plain old Schwalbe Marathons on my Fuji Absolute and they handle everthing well. No problem at all on any surface. YMMV, but they're bulletproof.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Singapore
Posts: 470
Bikes: Voodoo Hoodoo, Linus Libertine
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 106 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 15 Times
in
9 Posts
Just get a street tire that is wide(r). I haven't reasoned any benefits to side knobs. If the majority of your ride is paved, smooth is better. Grooves help if you ride in the wet. The wider the tire is, the more important are the grooves to maintain traction on wet smooth surfaces.
On the skinny side, i have used Panaracer T Serv in 26x1.5 on hard packed soil and find them stable. 26x1.25 feels rough on hard packed soil. Panaracer Pasela in 700x32 feels comfortable on hard packed soil. 1.5 (35mm) starts to feel a bit heavy.
On the big side, i have used Schwalbe Marathon 26x2.0, Kenda K1052 26x2.1, Kenda K841 20x1.95 and find them stable on anything. But slow.
I would say for your kind of riding i would go for 35mm.
On the skinny side, i have used Panaracer T Serv in 26x1.5 on hard packed soil and find them stable. 26x1.25 feels rough on hard packed soil. Panaracer Pasela in 700x32 feels comfortable on hard packed soil. 1.5 (35mm) starts to feel a bit heavy.
On the big side, i have used Schwalbe Marathon 26x2.0, Kenda K1052 26x2.1, Kenda K841 20x1.95 and find them stable on anything. But slow.
I would say for your kind of riding i would go for 35mm.
#13
Junior Member
just wanted to thank you for the info — I just got the H5 ultimate 700x38c this morning and they’re perfect for me on the FX 3. Had been going back and forth between the FX and Verve but ultimately went FX to be more fitness oriented — but the H5 38mm really seems to balance the advantages of the two bikes. Definitely feels more stable for me now on the FX. Thanks again.
Last edited by sanger68; 06-13-20 at 01:36 PM.
#14
Senior Member
Nice! I also put the H5 Ultimates in 38mm width on my 2020 FX3 last August. I wanted a wider 45mm tire, but the LBS said it wouldn't fit. The 38's have been working great for me. Mostly ride on paved paths, but some are packed gravel trails. When I do hit some larger or lose gravel, I need to coast and be careful since I will slide a bit. But all in all, great tires. Also, I run at ~70 psi in the back and ~63 psi in the front. Maybe I'll try a little lower in each per koenbro sometime.
Verve 3 was my runner-up as well
Verve 3 was my runner-up as well
#15
Junior Member
Its funny I actually ended up making my decision to buy the FX last week after reading your posts about your decision process and ultimate purchase from last year, as well as rick53’s comments. Was super helpful And I’m really happy with the bike - have taken it out 7 of the last 8 days after having not biked in years.
Likes For sanger68:
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 113
Bikes: Trek, Schwinn, Huffy
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 101 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 4 Times
in
3 Posts
I have a Trek FX 2 that I bought like 4 years ago. The tires are actually thinner then my wife tires on her hybrid Schwinn but they have performed very well on dirt paths and gravel. I have rode on many kinds of bike paths and surfaces: pavement, gravel, grass, dirt, hills, had no problems with it when the ground was a little wet, and had no issues falling off the bike. I haven't attempted to ride it on a very rugged mountain bike trail or on a very muddy trail, but I haven't yet fallen off the bike on any of trails I have ridden on.
I think the key is air pressure like the other posters said, My bikes tire lists like 65 - 95 psi and I usually only inflate it to like 65 - 70 psi, so maybe thats why my tires have not had a problem on gravel, grass, dirt, or slightly wet surfaces.
I think the key is air pressure like the other posters said, My bikes tire lists like 65 - 95 psi and I usually only inflate it to like 65 - 70 psi, so maybe thats why my tires have not had a problem on gravel, grass, dirt, or slightly wet surfaces.
Last edited by littleArnold; 06-13-20 at 07:30 PM.
#17
Senior Member
Actually, the most important is rider skill, like the OP already suggested. With enough skill you'll be able to anticipate potential problems with traction as well as handle them without crashing if you still happen to overstep the traction limits (or maybe do so on purpose).
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Kips Bay, NY
Posts: 2,212
Bikes: Ritchey Swiss Cross | Teesdale Kona Hot | Haro Extreme | Specialized Stumpjumper Comp | Cannondale F1000 | Shogun 1000 | Cannondale M500 | Norco Charger | Marin Muirwoods 29er | Shogun Kaze | Breezer Lightning
Mentioned: 8 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 576 Post(s)
Liked 1,003 Times
in
488 Posts
Likes For DorkDisk:
#19
Senior Member
Thread Starter
OK, change of plans. The 38mm Bontragers worked well, but basically I was restless and eager to experiment, so got a pair of Rene Herse Snoqualmie Pass in Extralight version, and running them tubeless. The tan wide walls look great!! Very happy.
Took them on a short ride today before work and I am sure it's my imagination's placebo effect but they were faster than the 38mms and basically comparable to the stock 32mm in speed, with LOTS more grip. Not sure that's possible but that's how it felt. Will go on a longer ride tomorrow.
Interestingly, the width fits well in the frame, but these tires are taller, and the radial clearance is minuscule (~2mm) at the seat stays. They didn't seem to rub during the test ride today, but I was surprised by this.
Took them on a short ride today before work and I am sure it's my imagination's placebo effect but they were faster than the 38mms and basically comparable to the stock 32mm in speed, with LOTS more grip. Not sure that's possible but that's how it felt. Will go on a longer ride tomorrow.
Interestingly, the width fits well in the frame, but these tires are taller, and the radial clearance is minuscule (~2mm) at the seat stays. They didn't seem to rub during the test ride today, but I was surprised by this.
Last edited by koenbro; 07-10-20 at 07:57 PM.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2017
Location: Northern Shenandoah Valley
Posts: 4,141
Bikes: More bikes than riders
Mentioned: 36 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1446 Post(s)
Liked 762 Times
in
570 Posts
Took them on a short ride today before work and I am sure it's my imagination's placebo effect but they were faster than the 38mms and basically comparable to the stock 32mm in speed, with LOTS more grip. Not sure that's possible but that's how it felt. Will go on a longer ride tomorrow.
Likes For hokiefyd:
#21
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Went for a 20 mile ride this morning before the day got too hot. Tires feel great and I love the looks (my left hand goes numb after about 3 mile, but there is separate thread about Isozone woes).
Last edited by koenbro; 07-11-20 at 04:31 PM.
Likes For koenbro:
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2017
Location: Northern Shenandoah Valley
Posts: 4,141
Bikes: More bikes than riders
Mentioned: 36 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1446 Post(s)
Liked 762 Times
in
570 Posts
The tires look ace on that bike. And it's a real purdy blue. I think Trek got off their game a little bit just a couple of years ago and seemed to paint all their bikes black. They're getting back into offering some really stunning colors. You just can't beat a blue bike.
Likes For hokiefyd: