Completely off topic but..
#1
Schwinnasaur
Thread Starter
Completely off topic but..
Maybe someone on the forum can explain to me why this is: When drilling holes along the center of cylindrical stock, why does spinning the work piece rather than the drill bit result in straighter holes with less drift. Why d
#2
Senior Member
However, if you mean a fixed drill and rotating the stock to drill it, like having the stock in a rotating lathe chuck and the drill in the fixed tailstock, that doesn't necessarily make the hole more true in axis versus the stock, you can still get drill drift; The relative motion between the two pieces is the same. However, grabbing the cylinder by the outside with a chuck, is inherently more precise in alignment, than standing it up on end, unless it is a very short cylinder, like a plate.
#3
Schwinnasaur
Thread Starter
I think you mean, the drill is spinning quickly to make the hole, while you periodically rotate the stock (which is sitting flat on its end); Assuming yes, this is to try to cancel out any error in perpindicularity between the flat end and the stock cylindrical axis.
However, if you mean a fixed drill and rotating the stock to drill it, like having the stock in a rotating lathe chuck and the drill in the fixed tailstock, that doesn't necessarily make the hole more true in axis versus the stock, you can still get drill drift; The relative motion between the two pieces is the same. However, grabbing the cylinder by the outside with a chuck, is inherently more precise in alignment, than standing it up on end, unless it is a very short cylinder, like a plate.
However, if you mean a fixed drill and rotating the stock to drill it, like having the stock in a rotating lathe chuck and the drill in the fixed tailstock, that doesn't necessarily make the hole more true in axis versus the stock, you can still get drill drift; The relative motion between the two pieces is the same. However, grabbing the cylinder by the outside with a chuck, is inherently more precise in alignment, than standing it up on end, unless it is a very short cylinder, like a plate.
#4
Senior Member
If the cylindrical stock is in the chuck of the drill press and the drill is in a clamp that is itself clamped to the table and the two are concentric, then spinning the stock results in perfect holes without drift, but not the other way around. The weight of stock does not matter. It could be alloy or wood. The fact that it is spinning, cancels out the drift. Your second paragraph above with the lathe is the same condition, but you're incorrect about the drift. If the stock spins, then no drift. If the drill spins and the stock is fixed, there will be drift. If you don't think so, try it.
#5
Schwinnasaur
Thread Starter
Somehow, by rotating, the stock corrects its axis. I am looking for an understanding of that, or at least a reason. I have tried googling and AI and while others noted this phenomenon, no one explained it. I came across this while looking for ways to drill concentric holes for making internally threaded rods. I used this on a bike project where I modified the rear rack on a Brompton to make it more the B when it is in shopping cart mode.
#6
Senior Member
Somehow, by rotating, the stock corrects its axis. I am looking for an understanding of that, or at least a reason. I have tried googling and AI and while others noted this phenomenon, no one explained it. I came across this while looking for ways to drill concentric holes for making internally threaded rods. I used this on a bike project where I modified the rear rack on a Brompton to make it more the B when it is in shopping cart mode.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 02-03-24 at 10:34 PM.