Would you buy used carbon parts?
#26
Senior Member
mstateglfr, I am simply attempting to provide an example of a seemingly intact carbon bar that was visually inspected was not intact, it was faulty after a crash, but showed zero signs of a problem existing. It may have happened 10 years ago, but that does not make it less relevant if it happened yesterday. The fact is that it happened. Sure, alum and steel fatigue, but in my experience they do not encounter catastrophic failure without warning signs the way carbon does.
My son's carbon stem broke off two weeks ago. Hopefully this is recent enough to be relevant. The bike was crashed 18 months ago, and just now the carbon steerer snapped off at the bottom of the stem. There were no visible signs of a problem, it exhibited absolutely no signs of a problem prior to breaking off.
Two months ago a customer brought a carbon bike in for work. Two months may make this less relevant, I suppose, but none the less important. Upon inspection I noticed the top tube was flexible just left of center, but was not flexible just right of center. Using a coin I tested for continuity of sound and compared it to the exact same model we had in the shop. Found out the frame had a hidden crack. I asked the customer what happened and he said that something fell on it in his garage a while ago, but he thought nothing of it. Fortunately it did not fail while riding, and that it was repairable. At some point it surely would have simply broke in two and the customer would have hit the deck.
Here's a relevant example, I hope. Two days ago a customer came in with a carbon mountain bike that had been involved in an encounter with a car. He asked that I look at the bike. Upon inspection the top tube had a fracture in it, but only showed up when I pushed down quite hard on it. Was not visible until I did that. Aluminum or steel would have shown a dent or crease at the failure point.
Got another one that is very relevant. Yesterday I replaced grips on a mountain bike that was from the 90's. Removed the barends (remember those?) and found the handlebar was creased where the barend was clamped. Turns out many years ago the rider hit a tree with the barend. A carbon bar would have cracked immediately or had a hidden fracture that would have failed in short order, and certainly would not go years without breaking off.
Do what you will, but I will never purchase any used carbon part or frame as I have seen enough examples over my 35+ years working in shops to convince me that carbon is great, but only when purchased new.
Food for further thought, this season I have encountered these 4 examples of a carbon part or frame failure, but not a single aluminum or steel part or frame failure, and there are certainly way more metal parts and frames out there than carbon.
My son's carbon stem broke off two weeks ago. Hopefully this is recent enough to be relevant. The bike was crashed 18 months ago, and just now the carbon steerer snapped off at the bottom of the stem. There were no visible signs of a problem, it exhibited absolutely no signs of a problem prior to breaking off.
Two months ago a customer brought a carbon bike in for work. Two months may make this less relevant, I suppose, but none the less important. Upon inspection I noticed the top tube was flexible just left of center, but was not flexible just right of center. Using a coin I tested for continuity of sound and compared it to the exact same model we had in the shop. Found out the frame had a hidden crack. I asked the customer what happened and he said that something fell on it in his garage a while ago, but he thought nothing of it. Fortunately it did not fail while riding, and that it was repairable. At some point it surely would have simply broke in two and the customer would have hit the deck.
Here's a relevant example, I hope. Two days ago a customer came in with a carbon mountain bike that had been involved in an encounter with a car. He asked that I look at the bike. Upon inspection the top tube had a fracture in it, but only showed up when I pushed down quite hard on it. Was not visible until I did that. Aluminum or steel would have shown a dent or crease at the failure point.
Got another one that is very relevant. Yesterday I replaced grips on a mountain bike that was from the 90's. Removed the barends (remember those?) and found the handlebar was creased where the barend was clamped. Turns out many years ago the rider hit a tree with the barend. A carbon bar would have cracked immediately or had a hidden fracture that would have failed in short order, and certainly would not go years without breaking off.
Do what you will, but I will never purchase any used carbon part or frame as I have seen enough examples over my 35+ years working in shops to convince me that carbon is great, but only when purchased new.
Food for further thought, this season I have encountered these 4 examples of a carbon part or frame failure, but not a single aluminum or steel part or frame failure, and there are certainly way more metal parts and frames out there than carbon.
Likes For Danhedonia:
#28
LBKA (formerly punkncat)
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Jawja
Posts: 4,299
Bikes: Spec Roubaix SL4, GT Traffic 1.0
Mentioned: 17 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2208 Post(s)
Liked 960 Times
in
686 Posts
I have purchased a used Carbon bike, it was the ride demo bike. I was able to fully inspect it and happened to work for the store selling it, so....
On that same note I would purchase used carbon accessories from a person that I knew well, perhaps rode with, along with a physical inspection of the part.
I would not order a used carbon part sight unseen.
On that same note I would purchase used carbon accessories from a person that I knew well, perhaps rode with, along with a physical inspection of the part.
I would not order a used carbon part sight unseen.
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Chicago, IL, USA
Posts: 2,880
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1461 Post(s)
Liked 1,484 Times
in
870 Posts
Assuming I was interested in buying a carbon fiber handlebar, stem or seatpost I would be OK buying used carbon parts from a reputable shop or source like Pro's Closet, where I know someone has inspected them. I wouldn't feel any differently about this than I would buying a carbon frame bike or wheels.
I wouldn't buy a used carbon bike or parts from an unknown seller on Craigslist. In addition to undisclosed damage, I'd be worried about fakes. I'm leery buying anything on Craigslist though, so maybe not a great example.
I always find the Bike Forum community to be more concerned about carbon fiber safety than my personal experiences. I know many people (not on this forum) who have bought, ridden and raced on used carbon stuff and have had no substantial issues. I personally have crashed bikes with carbon wheels and other parts and continued to ride them post-crash (in some cases for years), again with no issues. Maybe I've just gotten lucky, but the likelihood of catastrophic carbon failures and/or hidden or undetected damage to those parts seems to be a bit overstated on the internet?
I wouldn't buy a used carbon bike or parts from an unknown seller on Craigslist. In addition to undisclosed damage, I'd be worried about fakes. I'm leery buying anything on Craigslist though, so maybe not a great example.
I always find the Bike Forum community to be more concerned about carbon fiber safety than my personal experiences. I know many people (not on this forum) who have bought, ridden and raced on used carbon stuff and have had no substantial issues. I personally have crashed bikes with carbon wheels and other parts and continued to ride them post-crash (in some cases for years), again with no issues. Maybe I've just gotten lucky, but the likelihood of catastrophic carbon failures and/or hidden or undetected damage to those parts seems to be a bit overstated on the internet?
Likes For msu2001la:
#31
Full Member
In general, no. you have no idea what happened to carbon parts and delamination is generally invisible. But I have bought used CF parts and not had any trouble. Typically these parts are overbuilt to protect against voids in the manufacturing process so they are OK.
#32
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Valley Forge: Birthplace of Freedom
Posts: 1,299
Bikes: Novara Safari, CAAD9, WABI Classic, WABI Thunder
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 366 Post(s)
Liked 457 Times
in
240 Posts
Nope.
https://youtu.be/NQJUSZeJE8A
https://youtu.be/j-SFAB_zK-I
Though I'm a Clyde, so I wouldn't be buying new carbon either...
https://youtu.be/NQJUSZeJE8A
https://youtu.be/j-SFAB_zK-I
Though I'm a Clyde, so I wouldn't be buying new carbon either...
Last edited by stevel610; 09-10-20 at 06:07 PM.
#34
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Nope.
https://youtu.be/W0iMHkYpWFo
https://youtu.be/NQJUSZeJE8A
https://youtu.be/j-SFAB_zK-I
Though I'm a Clyde, so I wouldn't be buying new carbon either...
https://youtu.be/W0iMHkYpWFo
https://youtu.be/NQJUSZeJE8A
https://youtu.be/j-SFAB_zK-I
Though I'm a Clyde, so I wouldn't be buying new carbon either...
Likes For Helldorado:
#35
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Mississauga/Toronto, Ontario canada
Posts: 8,721
Bikes: I have 3 singlespeed/fixed gear bikes
Mentioned: 30 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4227 Post(s)
Liked 2,488 Times
in
1,286 Posts
1 off examples dont prove anything as examples can show used steel and aluminum components also failing. Aluminum rims failing, aluminum bars failing, steel frames cracking, steel forks cracking, seat post clamps failing, etc etc etc.
A 1 off example from your shop that happened a decade ago is what you are using to declare no carbon parts should be purchased used?
A 1 off example from your shop that happened a decade ago is what you are using to declare no carbon parts should be purchased used?
#38
Advocatus Diaboli
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Wherever I am
Posts: 8,635
Bikes: Merlin Cyrene, Nashbar steel CX
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4733 Post(s)
Liked 1,532 Times
in
1,003 Posts
#39
Jedi Master
I rode the Iron Porcupine 1,200k last month. 2 of the DNF's were due to carbon wheel failures, and two other riders needed to borrow replacement wheels due to carbon wheel failures. Considering there were only 34 riders, and at least half the riders were running more sensible 1200k wheelsets, that's a lot of failed carbon wheels in under 800 miles of riding.
#40
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Posts: 1,659
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1248 Post(s)
Liked 1,323 Times
in
674 Posts
I rode the Iron Porcupine 1,200k last month. 2 of the DNF's were due to carbon wheel failures, and two other riders needed to borrow replacement wheels due to carbon wheel failures. Considering there were only 34 riders, and at least half the riders were running more sensible 1200k wheelsets, that's a lot of failed carbon wheels in under 800 miles of riding.
Likes For Atlas Shrugged:
#41
Jedi Master
I don't necessarily have anything against carbon velopig. but I was surprised by the failure rate on that ride, which I agree should have been nothing remarkable. I rode 25 year old peter white built box-section rims with campy cup and cone hubs that have unknown thousands of km's on them and will probably last forever, so that's how I roll.
#42
Junior Member
I would be hesitant to buying used Carbon parts but it would not always no. It would need to be something I could fully inspect ahead of use and would probably do some checks before a hard ride. Certainly would not be my first choice though.