Bike buying decisions: Domane, Allez, Defy
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2017
Posts: 185
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 119 Post(s)
Liked 23 Times
in
18 Posts
Bike buying decisions: Domane, Allez, Defy
I have a 2019 2017 Domane ALR4 (Tiagara group) which has been my main bike. This winter, I set the Domane up as a trainer and really enjoyed it.
Spring is coming, and I'd like to ride again on the road, but I'd like a bike dedicated to the trainer so I don't have to haul one in/out of the basement and can get in mid-week rides if the weather is bad. I ride mainly 1 hour rides, with occasional 90 minute rides, and a very rare, once-in-a-while 2 hour ride. I'm over 50, fairly flexible and still in decent shape, but am no athlete. I don't race, and I don't do long endurance rides. Just comfortable, fun riding for exercise and stress relief, and I do like to go as fast as I can. (edit: I should add I've had the Domane professional fit in January, and it's working for me on the trainer).
I've been shopping the used boards and bike shops since December. Here are the best choices I have seen:
Near to me on Craigslist is an aluminum Specialized Allez 105 group set at a good price. It's a little tired, but still in decent enough shape. I have also been looking at a Carbon Giant Defy 2 105 group set at a local shop at what is the top of my price range.
So, the two questions I have to figure out - A) is the Giant worth +2K on the road for 60 minute rides over the Domane (i.e. does it get me a much better/faster/fun ride), and B) as the Allez is more aggressive, and I'm used to an endurance geometry, will I find the Allez a bad fit as a trainer?
Spring is coming, and I'd like to ride again on the road, but I'd like a bike dedicated to the trainer so I don't have to haul one in/out of the basement and can get in mid-week rides if the weather is bad. I ride mainly 1 hour rides, with occasional 90 minute rides, and a very rare, once-in-a-while 2 hour ride. I'm over 50, fairly flexible and still in decent shape, but am no athlete. I don't race, and I don't do long endurance rides. Just comfortable, fun riding for exercise and stress relief, and I do like to go as fast as I can. (edit: I should add I've had the Domane professional fit in January, and it's working for me on the trainer).
I've been shopping the used boards and bike shops since December. Here are the best choices I have seen:
Near to me on Craigslist is an aluminum Specialized Allez 105 group set at a good price. It's a little tired, but still in decent enough shape. I have also been looking at a Carbon Giant Defy 2 105 group set at a local shop at what is the top of my price range.
- Option 1- get the Allez and put it on the trainer and put the Domane on the road. Reasons for this -- Domane has wider tires and iso speed, so maybe a bit more comfortable
Option 2- get the Allez and put that on the road and leave the Domane on the trainer. Reasons for this are the Allez is lighter and a bit more aggressive, but it is likely less comfortable on our local, crappy roads (narrower tires, no ISO seat post connection)- Option 3 - spend up +$2K over the Allez to get the Giant, make that the new road bike and keep the Domane on the trainer. Reasons for this are - New bike! Carbon! Light on the road! Reasons NOT to do this -- $$$ and the global economic collapse (/jk -- or at least I hope I'm just kidding)
So, the two questions I have to figure out - A) is the Giant worth +2K on the road for 60 minute rides over the Domane (i.e. does it get me a much better/faster/fun ride), and B) as the Allez is more aggressive, and I'm used to an endurance geometry, will I find the Allez a bad fit as a trainer?
Last edited by WT21; 04-09-23 at 08:13 PM.
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2021
Posts: 8,451
Mentioned: 12 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4416 Post(s)
Liked 4,871 Times
in
3,015 Posts
So, the two questions I have to figure out - A) is the Giant worth +2K on the road for 60 minute rides over the Domane (i.e. does it get me a much better/faster/fun ride), and B) as the Allez is more aggressive, and I'm used to an endurance geometry, will I find the Allez a bad fit as a trainer?
Likes For PeteHski:
#3
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2017
Posts: 185
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 119 Post(s)
Liked 23 Times
in
18 Posts
Thanks. It's snowing right now, so still waiting for better weather to at least try the Defy on the road. But it sounds like "is new and shiny work $2K" is the real question
#4
climber has-been
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Palo Alto, CA
Posts: 7,111
Bikes: Scott Addict R1, Felt Z1
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3432 Post(s)
Liked 3,567 Times
in
1,793 Posts
My concern for a trainer-only bike is that it feels roughly the same as my on-the-road bike:
- the contact point locations (saddle, bars, pedals),
- the gearing,
- the saddle.
Likes For terrymorse:
#5
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 14,992
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Mentioned: 51 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6196 Post(s)
Liked 4,811 Times
in
3,319 Posts
For 60 minute rides the lighter bike will be more fun if you live in anything but pan flat terrain. If the bike fits you properly, then it can be fun on longer rides too.
Likes For Iride01:
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2020
Location: Great White North
Posts: 1,226
Bikes: 2013 Cannondale Caad 8, 2010 Opus Fidelio, 1985 Peugeot UO14, 1999 Peugeot Dune, Sakai Select, L'Avantage, 1971 Gitane Apache Standard, 1999 Specialized Hard Rock
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 548 Post(s)
Liked 473 Times
in
302 Posts
Personally, if you like the Trek which is pretty new and looks nice, then why not bring that out onto the road and just pick up something cheaper to ride on the trainer? match the settings of the custom fit and not worry about weight, wheel type, frame material ect... which doesn't really matter when it's on a trainer. It just needs to shift gears properly and be comfortable.
Most of my bikes are older but I chose to put the oldest aluminum road bike on the trainer and then ride my newer bike outside.
Most of my bikes are older but I chose to put the oldest aluminum road bike on the trainer and then ride my newer bike outside.
#7
Newbie
I can relate to to the 1 bike for trainer and 1 or more for roads/trails! Much easier to help you decide to get out and go on the road when the weather suits.
There is downward market pressure on bike prices so perhaps lower prices are on the way. And keep a lookout on CL and FB marketplace. I picked up some very nice bikes for less that $400 - like 2014 Felt Z85 with very low use. And a 90s Trek steel tube that had group set swapped to Campy for $200.
There is downward market pressure on bike prices so perhaps lower prices are on the way. And keep a lookout on CL and FB marketplace. I picked up some very nice bikes for less that $400 - like 2014 Felt Z85 with very low use. And a 90s Trek steel tube that had group set swapped to Campy for $200.
Likes For Jjbailey930:
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2021
Posts: 8,451
Mentioned: 12 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4416 Post(s)
Liked 4,871 Times
in
3,015 Posts
There's no right or wrong answer to that question. It depends entirely on how much you appreciate the bike. The Defy to me is one of those bikes that does everything pretty damn well without being super-exciting or frustrating in any way. It certainly wouldn't hold you back in any way. For $2k I think it's actually very good value for money compared to similar spec bikes. But only you can decide if you need that level of bike. You could make a valid argument that a 2019 Domane ALR4 is all the bike you could ever "need". But that doesn't mean more expensive bikes are a waste of money.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 15,491
Bikes: 2015 Workswell 066, 2017 Workswell 093, 2014 Dawes Sheila, 1983 Cannondale 500, 1984 Raleigh Olympian, 2007 Cannondale Rize 4, 2017 Fuji Sportif 1 LE
Mentioned: 144 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7652 Post(s)
Liked 3,479 Times
in
1,836 Posts
I like the Defy (I ride what is pretty much a Defy clone) and find it exceedingly comfortable. I will Always suggest the Defy as a road bike .... however ... (as others have said) ...
If you have a bike which really works for you (the Domane) why not ride it? It does everything you want and you know it does it to your satisfaction.
You could throw a $100 Craigslist bike on the trainer. If the frame fits your build even a little, set up the bike to have the same contact points as the Domane and it will feel exactly the same ... on a trainer. Weight won't matter, wheels won't matter, tires won't matter .... except for the drive train, parts quality won't matter.
I have an ancient BikesDirect bike which I used on a trainer for a while .... it is a 52, while I ride a 56 or a 58 .... but with a ridiculous stem and a really long aluminum seat post I made it fit. Feels fine even though it looks like a TdF bike (those guys also ride tiny frames with cubit-long stems.) I used my oldest, heaviest wheels and leftover cheapo 23-mm tires I would never ride on the road ..... On a trainer it makes zero difference.
Of course, I would probably get kicked off the site if I didn't advocate N+ .... so buy the defy, And buy a cheap bike for the trainer.
If you have a bike which really works for you (the Domane) why not ride it? It does everything you want and you know it does it to your satisfaction.
You could throw a $100 Craigslist bike on the trainer. If the frame fits your build even a little, set up the bike to have the same contact points as the Domane and it will feel exactly the same ... on a trainer. Weight won't matter, wheels won't matter, tires won't matter .... except for the drive train, parts quality won't matter.
I have an ancient BikesDirect bike which I used on a trainer for a while .... it is a 52, while I ride a 56 or a 58 .... but with a ridiculous stem and a really long aluminum seat post I made it fit. Feels fine even though it looks like a TdF bike (those guys also ride tiny frames with cubit-long stems.) I used my oldest, heaviest wheels and leftover cheapo 23-mm tires I would never ride on the road ..... On a trainer it makes zero difference.
Of course, I would probably get kicked off the site if I didn't advocate N+ .... so buy the defy, And buy a cheap bike for the trainer.
Likes For Maelochs:
#10
Banned
You might wait for a better option. I noticed yesterday that there were some great road bikes for sale at great prices:
Speicalize Roubaix CF Shimano Ultegra $1775
Specialized Ruby CF with Dura Ace $1,775
Trek Madrone CF SRAM $1,075
Orbea Ordu Triathalon CF Dura Ace $950
Giant Defy CF Ultegra $875
Any of these would be a great bike to ride. New these sold for thousands of dollars more than the current asking price.
Speicalize Roubaix CF Shimano Ultegra $1775
Specialized Ruby CF with Dura Ace $1,775
Trek Madrone CF SRAM $1,075
Orbea Ordu Triathalon CF Dura Ace $950
Giant Defy CF Ultegra $875
Any of these would be a great bike to ride. New these sold for thousands of dollars more than the current asking price.
#12
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2017
Posts: 185
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 119 Post(s)
Liked 23 Times
in
18 Posts
I mis-typed the year. It's actually a 2017 Domane ALR4.
I am hoping to test ride the Defy Advance 2 this week. I've been shopping used bikes for about 3 months, and just nothing in my area that wouldn't take some money or work to make it fit, and if I'm going to do that, maybe just get a new bike. Or maybe I just want something shiny
My one last concern is recyclability of a new CF frame. Seems it's completely zero?
I am hoping to test ride the Defy Advance 2 this week. I've been shopping used bikes for about 3 months, and just nothing in my area that wouldn't take some money or work to make it fit, and if I'm going to do that, maybe just get a new bike. Or maybe I just want something shiny
My one last concern is recyclability of a new CF frame. Seems it's completely zero?
#13
Senior Member
I have a single speed Specialized for my trainer. I control pedaling exertion by the resistance on the trainer . No need to buy a bike with derailleurs for the trainer. Single speed bikes can be gotten cheaply.