Canyon as a company sucks. Beware.
#51
Senior Member
- VAT reimbursement is a voluntary service provided by Canyon. No legal claim exists to this service.
- VAT reimbursement is only possible on orders to Germany, Belgium, Italy, Austria, Denmark or the Netherlands. For the Netherlands, you have to follow a special procedure – please contact our partner in the Netherlands in advance.
Last edited by smarkinson; 07-16-19 at 09:25 PM.
Likes For smarkinson:
#52
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: TC, MN
Posts: 39,520
Bikes: R3 Disc, Haanjo
Mentioned: 354 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 20810 Post(s)
Liked 9,456 Times
in
4,672 Posts
Further, the website FAQ clearly state:
- VAT reimbursement is a voluntary service provided by Canyon. No legal claim exists to this service.
- VAT reimbursement is only possible on orders to Germany, Belgium, Italy, Austria, Denmark or the Netherlands.
Likes For WhyFi:
#54
Full Member
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 466
Bikes: Trek Domane 4.3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 193 Post(s)
Liked 50 Times
in
35 Posts
- VAT reimbursement is a voluntary service provided by Canyon. No legal claim exists to this service.
- VAT reimbursement is only possible on orders to Germany, Belgium, Italy, Austria, Denmark or the Netherlands. For the Netherlands, you have to follow a special procedure – please contact our partner in the Netherlands in advance.
So, Canyon has a rep who provided inaccurate information that is inconsistent with its stated policies/guidance on its website. So the question is whether Canyon should as a matter of goodwill credit back an amount equal to the paid VAT amount based on the rep's inaccurate statements or adhere to its stated policies. I don't think there's a legal claim here, given what the website says, but I'm not a German or French lawyer. I have no idea where OP's credit card is from and what rules apply.
#55
Expired Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: TN
Posts: 11,532
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3665 Post(s)
Liked 5,413 Times
in
2,751 Posts
Venting is thought to be good for those who feel they've been mistreated. It doesn't matter whether the mistreatment is real or imaginary. They feel better having vented. BF in their wisdom corral the vents in this remote area. Thanks BF!
Likes For shelbyfv:
#56
Zoom zoom zoom zoom bonk
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: Giant Defy, Trek 1.7c, BMC GF02, Fuji Tahoe, Scott Sub 35, Kona Rove, Trek Verve+2
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 551 Post(s)
Liked 722 Times
in
366 Posts
The correct answer should have been "we think you can get a refund but check yourself".
The correct question should have been "where can I find out about tax refunds?".
The correct question should have been "where can I find out about tax refunds?".
#57
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: Eugene, Oregon, USA
Posts: 27,547
Mentioned: 217 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18373 Post(s)
Liked 4,508 Times
in
3,351 Posts
Right. So the issue is that a VAT refund isn't possible in the OP's situation because of the VAT-refund rules (France isn't a country he could send the bike to).
So, Canyon has a rep who provided inaccurate information that is inconsistent with its stated policies/guidance on its website. So the question is whether Canyon should as a matter of goodwill credit back an amount equal to the paid VAT amount based on the rep's inaccurate statements or adhere to its stated policies. I don't think there's a legal claim here, given what the website says, but I'm not a German or French lawyer. I have no idea where OP's credit card is from and what rules apply.
So, Canyon has a rep who provided inaccurate information that is inconsistent with its stated policies/guidance on its website. So the question is whether Canyon should as a matter of goodwill credit back an amount equal to the paid VAT amount based on the rep's inaccurate statements or adhere to its stated policies. I don't think there's a legal claim here, given what the website says, but I'm not a German or French lawyer. I have no idea where OP's credit card is from and what rules apply.
Apparently the OP was aware of the notes on the web page, but had also talked to employees of the company (with an electronic paper trail). In particular with respect to a payment from India.
Talking to employees should trump the general notes on the web page, especially when there was further clarification such as the India/Germany credit card transaction.
In fact, one should be able to argue that this was a German/India transaction, and there was no business transaction in France, but rather simply an intermediate destination, much as if I shipped my bicycle that I own in the USA to France, rode it in France, then returned with it to the USA. Or, any interaction in France would be limited to the final setup & configuration of the bike.
@deepakvrao, was the bike shipped to a CANYON authorized bike shop in France, or was it shipped to an unattached 3rd party such as a hotel? Did any money exchange occur in France? Payments?
Likes For CliffordK:
#58
Perceptual Dullard
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 2,417
Mentioned: 36 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 918 Post(s)
Liked 1,149 Times
in
491 Posts
I'm in the market for a new bike. I've thought about buying one of their bikes. I was already on alert because Canyon's new trainer ads violate their own warranty. This new incident puts the company on my no-buy list.
In addition to working with your credit card company, I'd probably post to twitter. Companies nowadays monitor social media more than they would an obscure feedback forum. I'd probably emphasize that the company will not back up *any* promise made by *any* customer service employee.
Last edited by RChung; 07-17-19 at 01:34 AM.
Likes For RChung:
#59
Senior Member
Thread Starter
- VAT reimbursement is a voluntary service provided by Canyon. No legal claim exists to this service.
- VAT reimbursement is only possible on orders to Germany, Belgium, Italy, Austria, Denmark or the Netherlands. For the Netherlands, you have to follow a special procedure – please contact our partner in the Netherlands in advance.
Tell me, do you know anything about VAT refund, or did you just jump in to give an uninformed opinion?
What a mess.
Apparently the OP was aware of the notes on the web page, but had also talked to employees of the company (with an electronic paper trail). In particular with respect to a payment from India.
Talking to employees should trump the general notes on the web page, especially when there was further clarification such as the India/Germany credit card transaction.
In fact, one should be able to argue that this was a German/India transaction, and there was no business transaction in France, but rather simply an intermediate destination, much as if I shipped my bicycle that I own in the USA to France, rode it in France, then returned with it to the USA. Or, any interaction in France would be limited to the final setup & configuration of the bike.
@deepakvrao, was the bike shipped to a CANYON authorized bike shop in France, or was it shipped to an unattached 3rd party such as a hotel? Did any money exchange occur in France? Payments?
Apparently the OP was aware of the notes on the web page, but had also talked to employees of the company (with an electronic paper trail). In particular with respect to a payment from India.
Talking to employees should trump the general notes on the web page, especially when there was further clarification such as the India/Germany credit card transaction.
In fact, one should be able to argue that this was a German/India transaction, and there was no business transaction in France, but rather simply an intermediate destination, much as if I shipped my bicycle that I own in the USA to France, rode it in France, then returned with it to the USA. Or, any interaction in France would be limited to the final setup & configuration of the bike.
@deepakvrao, was the bike shipped to a CANYON authorized bike shop in France, or was it shipped to an unattached 3rd party such as a hotel? Did any money exchange occur in France? Payments?
This is right. If the company won't back specific repeated assurances or promises made by their employees, any information you receive from any employee of the company cannot be trusted. *None of it.*
I'm in the market for a new bike. I've thought about buying one of their bikes. I was already on alert because Canyon's new trainer ads violate their own warranty. This new incident puts the company on my no-buy list.
In addition to working with your credit card company, I'd probably post to twitter. Companies nowadays monitor social media more than they would an obscure feedback forum. I'd probably emphasize that the company will not back up *any* promise made by *any* customer service employee.
I'm in the market for a new bike. I've thought about buying one of their bikes. I was already on alert because Canyon's new trainer ads violate their own warranty. This new incident puts the company on my no-buy list.
In addition to working with your credit card company, I'd probably post to twitter. Companies nowadays monitor social media more than they would an obscure feedback forum. I'd probably emphasize that the company will not back up *any* promise made by *any* customer service employee.
Likes For ridelikeaturtle:
#61
Senior Member
Thread Starter
fify
Contextual comprehension is key - my comment was in regards to his complaints of limited buying options in India with the implication that delivery during international vacation was virtually his only option. That's not a terribly compelling "woe is me" story.
Further, the website FAQ clearly state:
Contextual comprehension is key - my comment was in regards to his complaints of limited buying options in India with the implication that delivery during international vacation was virtually his only option. That's not a terribly compelling "woe is me" story.
Further, the website FAQ clearly state:
2. Yes, and because of the website, I asked them thrice whether France wold be OK. I think I could not have done more to stay safe.
Also, if they had given me the right info, I was in Germany the next month. Would have just delayed the order.
#62
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Yup.
#63
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#64
Zoom zoom zoom zoom bonk
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 4,624
Bikes: Giant Defy, Trek 1.7c, BMC GF02, Fuji Tahoe, Scott Sub 35, Kona Rove, Trek Verve+2
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 551 Post(s)
Liked 722 Times
in
366 Posts
My bad. I have used the Australian system a few times which is quite simple and done at the airport. The hard part is finding the counter between passport control and security, especially after the pre flight beers.
#65
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: TC, MN
Posts: 39,520
Bikes: R3 Disc, Haanjo
Mentioned: 354 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 20810 Post(s)
Liked 9,456 Times
in
4,672 Posts
1. Forget the 'woe is me'. Tell me what you would do if a company promised you in writing, say, a 700 dollar discount and backtracked later?
2. Yes, and because of the website, I asked them thrice whether France wold be OK. I think I could not have done more to stay safe.
Also, if they had given me the right info, I was in Germany the next month. Would have just delayed the order.
2. Yes, and because of the website, I asked them thrice whether France wold be OK. I think I could not have done more to stay safe.
Also, if they had given me the right info, I was in Germany the next month. Would have just delayed the order.
#66
Overdoing projects
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Rotterdam, former republic of the Netherlands
Posts: 2,397
Bikes: Batavus Randonneur GL, Gazelle Orange Excellent, Gazelle Super Licht, Gazelle Grand Tourist, Gazelle Lausanne, Gazelle Tandem, Koga-Miyata SilverAce, Koga-Miyata WorldTraveller
Mentioned: 58 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 784 Post(s)
Liked 1,238 Times
in
686 Posts
Nope. You obviously have no clue how VAT refunds work in the EU. It is upto the retailer to decide to participate or not.Every item bought by a foreigner and taken out within a specified period of time is entitled to a VAT refund. Applicable to goods, and not services. Obviously.
Guide to VAT refund for visitors to the EU - ec.europa.eu
Can all goods be bought VAT-free?
No. There are some goods that do not qualify. The facility is intended for goods that could in principle be carried in personal luggage. Goods that have to be exported as freight, for example, and cars and yachts are excluded. Some countries may also exclude other categories of goods.
No. There are some goods that do not qualify. The facility is intended for goods that could in principle be carried in personal luggage. Goods that have to be exported as freight, for example, and cars and yachts are excluded. Some countries may also exclude other categories of goods.
Do I have to leave the EU straight away from the country where I purchased goods?
No. You can buy VAT-free goods even if you are going to be visiting other EU countries before you finally return home, as long as you actually leave the EU with the goods within the time limit. You have to get your documents stamped by a customs officer at the point of exit of the EU – not necessary in the same EU country where you bought it.
No. You can buy VAT-free goods even if you are going to be visiting other EU countries before you finally return home, as long as you actually leave the EU with the goods within the time limit. You have to get your documents stamped by a customs officer at the point of exit of the EU – not necessary in the same EU country where you bought it.
IF, however you shipped the bike out by mail instead of on the plane ride home you might be out of luck. That's not how VAT reimbursements work in Europe.
You would have been better off contacting National tax authorities. They would have the authority to be able to give you the final answer and actually have people trained in this matter.
Hell, send them a message on Instagram and they will likely be able to answer you quickly enough.
I'm still left with a few questions though:
- What kind of address did you ship to in France? A Hotel, home address?
- How long did you stay in Europe?
- How many months after Canyon shipped the bike did it leave Europe?
Last edited by JaccoW; 07-18-19 at 03:04 AM.
Likes For JaccoW:
#67
Senior Member
Been in retail for close to 1/2 a century. Recently had a supplier's rep cost me $500.00. When I brought this to the CEOs attention with documentation he immediately issued a $500.00 credit on my account. This is how a RESPONSIBLE company handles things. Sorry this isn't a "tax" issue, it's a credibility issue. OP was given false information by company rep. Made a purchase based (or partially) based on that information. This is an easy CC dispute the OP can win. Now the "win" might be a return for full refund if Canyon will not cough up the promised VAT tax reimbursement out of their profit. Very sure they netted more than that on the sale. No brainer for a well run company. Based on this thread have no interest in doing any business with Canyon.
#68
Full Member
I am surprised and disappointed at the hostile responses.
Deepak is not evading tax, he is minimizing his tax payments. You seem to be unaware that Indians have the pleasure of paying a customs duty ranging from 40% to 50% of cost of (bike + shipping).
Deepak: As suggested, file a dispute with the payment processor and contact the German Embassy in India for alternatives. Leaving a negative feedback at Trusted Shops | seal of approval, seller rating and buyer protection for online shops may help.
Germany also has effective consumer forums and filing a dispute should help. Google.
Btw, tourists are out of luck with respect to sales tax. No refund.
Deepak is not evading tax, he is minimizing his tax payments. You seem to be unaware that Indians have the pleasure of paying a customs duty ranging from 40% to 50% of cost of (bike + shipping).
Deepak: As suggested, file a dispute with the payment processor and contact the German Embassy in India for alternatives. Leaving a negative feedback at Trusted Shops | seal of approval, seller rating and buyer protection for online shops may help.
Germany also has effective consumer forums and filing a dispute should help. Google.
Btw, tourists are out of luck with respect to sales tax. No refund.
Likes For anga:
#69
Senior Member
OP did nothing wrong.
He did his due diligence, asked the right questions, and if the company - who is responsible for processing VAT refunds - gives him wrong information, they should stick to their word and own their mistake.
OP executed a transaction with a company and asked them the right questions, and that company should have been able to provide him the correct information, and failed to do so - on multiple occasions. The onus is on Canyon to provide correct information about purchases from Canyon, including tax implications for those purposes. VAT is nothing new, and they should have full understanding of this, being a European company.
It's not OP who should hold the bag because yet more idiots in the world can't do their god-damn job right, which is exactly what happened and exactly why OP is in this situation.
Canyon deserves to be put on blast for this. I'm sure they did absolutely nothing with the employees who told him wrong information, they are probably telling other people the same wrong crap. If I had a company, and we told someone the wrong thing that cost them $700, it wouldn't even for a second ever cross my mind to do anything other than process that refund immediately and own my own mistake.
He did his due diligence, asked the right questions, and if the company - who is responsible for processing VAT refunds - gives him wrong information, they should stick to their word and own their mistake.
OP executed a transaction with a company and asked them the right questions, and that company should have been able to provide him the correct information, and failed to do so - on multiple occasions. The onus is on Canyon to provide correct information about purchases from Canyon, including tax implications for those purposes. VAT is nothing new, and they should have full understanding of this, being a European company.
It's not OP who should hold the bag because yet more idiots in the world can't do their god-damn job right, which is exactly what happened and exactly why OP is in this situation.
Canyon deserves to be put on blast for this. I'm sure they did absolutely nothing with the employees who told him wrong information, they are probably telling other people the same wrong crap. If I had a company, and we told someone the wrong thing that cost them $700, it wouldn't even for a second ever cross my mind to do anything other than process that refund immediately and own my own mistake.
Last edited by puma1552; 08-06-19 at 08:18 PM.
#70
laternser
Question was about REFUNDING tax.
How could any company refund a tax paid to government? Refund implies it was already paid to the tax authorities.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
#71
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Alpharetta, GA
Posts: 15,280
Bikes: Nashbar Road
Mentioned: 71 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2934 Post(s)
Liked 341 Times
in
228 Posts
I sympathize with being told a total price by the company to make the sale, and having to pay another amount. It's like the company falsely represented a matter material to the purchase, and there are laws against that. At least in the USA that I am familiar with. But taxes are really between the consumer and the government and are only collected by the retailer on the government's behalf. It's not really a refund from the company (when there is reimbursement). They're just giving back taxes paid but not collected by the governing authority.
While there is a valid complaint about Canyon giving the wrong information about EU tax policies, I'd have to question whether Canyon has any financial liability in this so I'd really not recommend a credit card "fraud" chargeback. I assume since the reimbursement is "optional" for a company, that the consumer can petition the given tax collector directly for a tax refund. If a refund is appropriate. So that's really just a service that the company can provide, right? So it looks like, if you are due a refund, France will provide it. If you're not due a refund, Canyon doesn't owe it to you.
While there is a valid complaint about Canyon giving the wrong information about EU tax policies, I'd have to question whether Canyon has any financial liability in this so I'd really not recommend a credit card "fraud" chargeback. I assume since the reimbursement is "optional" for a company, that the consumer can petition the given tax collector directly for a tax refund. If a refund is appropriate. So that's really just a service that the company can provide, right? So it looks like, if you are due a refund, France will provide it. If you're not due a refund, Canyon doesn't owe it to you.
#72
FLIR Kitten to 0.05C
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Lincoln, Nebraska
Posts: 5,331
Bikes: Roadie: Seven Axiom Race Ti w/Chorus 11s. CX/Adventure: Carver Gravel Grinder w/ Di2
Mentioned: 30 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2349 Post(s)
Liked 406 Times
in
254 Posts
How could any company refund a tax paid to government? Refund implies it was already paid to the tax authorities.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
Being a fellow Nebraskan, I do appreciate a good taxation rant...from someone who lives in a state with perpetual budget shortfalls that is unable to pay its bills or maintain its infrastructure....all while wanting to cut taxes more, and then act shocked they cannot pay their bills.
Likes For Marcus_Ti:
#73
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I am surprised and disappointed at the hostile responses.
Deepak is not evading tax, he is minimizing his tax payments. You seem to be unaware that Indians have the pleasure of paying a customs duty ranging from 40% to 50% of cost of (bike + shipping).
Deepak: As suggested, file a dispute with the payment processor and contact the German Embassy in India for alternatives. Leaving a negative feedback at Trusted Shops | seal of approval, seller rating and buyer protection for online shops may help.
Germany also has effective consumer forums and filing a dispute should help. Google.
Btw, tourists are out of luck with respect to sales tax. No refund.
Deepak is not evading tax, he is minimizing his tax payments. You seem to be unaware that Indians have the pleasure of paying a customs duty ranging from 40% to 50% of cost of (bike + shipping).
Deepak: As suggested, file a dispute with the payment processor and contact the German Embassy in India for alternatives. Leaving a negative feedback at Trusted Shops | seal of approval, seller rating and buyer protection for online shops may help.
Germany also has effective consumer forums and filing a dispute should help. Google.
Btw, tourists are out of luck with respect to sales tax. No refund.
Thanks @anga. Yes, duty in india is 50% on cost of bike plus shipping, and I did nothing wrong/illegal.
OP did nothing wrong.
He did his due diligence, asked the right questions, and if the company - who is responsible for processing VAT refunds - gives him wrong information, they should stick to their word and own their mistake.
OP executed a transaction with a company and asked them the right questions, and that company should have been able to provide him the correct information, and failed to do so - on multiple occasions. The onus is on Canyon to provide correct information about purchases from Canyon, including tax implications for those purposes. VAT is nothing new, and they should have full understanding of this, being a European company.
It's not OP who should hold the bag because yet more idiots in the world can't do their god-damn job right, which is exactly what happened and exactly why OP is in this situation.
Canyon deserves to be put on blast for this. I'm sure they did absolutely nothing with the employees who told him wrong information, they are probably telling other people the same wrong crap. If I had a company, and we told someone the wrong thing that cost them $700, it wouldn't even for a second ever cross my mind to do anything other than process that refund immediately and own my own mistake.
He did his due diligence, asked the right questions, and if the company - who is responsible for processing VAT refunds - gives him wrong information, they should stick to their word and own their mistake.
OP executed a transaction with a company and asked them the right questions, and that company should have been able to provide him the correct information, and failed to do so - on multiple occasions. The onus is on Canyon to provide correct information about purchases from Canyon, including tax implications for those purposes. VAT is nothing new, and they should have full understanding of this, being a European company.
It's not OP who should hold the bag because yet more idiots in the world can't do their god-damn job right, which is exactly what happened and exactly why OP is in this situation.
Canyon deserves to be put on blast for this. I'm sure they did absolutely nothing with the employees who told him wrong information, they are probably telling other people the same wrong crap. If I had a company, and we told someone the wrong thing that cost them $700, it wouldn't even for a second ever cross my mind to do anything other than process that refund immediately and own my own mistake.
How could any company refund a tax paid to government? Refund implies it was already paid to the tax authorities.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
Don't think they could pry money back out of the EU tax system on behalf of you.
Maybe tax payer could by filing the appropriate rebate forms. An accountant may be able to identify the obscure forms required.
20% VAT yipee! Never enough of someone else's money.
By the time you trace this back far more than half of the cost of the bike will have gone into Government coffers by a tax, fee, inspection charge, workers taxes, taxes on imported titanium, environmental fees, real-estate taxes, water taxes, dock taxes and fees, taxes on the tools required to manufacture it, negative interest on the companies bank balance, interest on capital investment, taxes on net, etc etc etc.
The only entity trying to lower the product cost in all of this is the manufacturer, so blame them.
They will be running on the smallest profit you ever saw ... that is why there are very few old bicycle manufacturers.
What Canyon really needs to do is apply for government subsidies and exemptions to lower the cost.
The do after all produce bicycles that lower emissions. Must be a subsidy.
That way they shift the cost to some other less worthy entity.
VAT accounts are ongoing, so the refunded amount will be offset against their next VAT payment to the government, is how it works. I think.
Anyway, long and short, I was refunded 400 dollars as a 'goodwill' gesture. Not 700, but better than nothing. Took ages to get the refund too.
Last edited by deepakvrao; 06-23-20 at 09:24 AM.
#74
Newbie
I'm with you, Deepak. If I give out false or misleading information rather than saying "I'm, not sure, go ask so and so," then I am responsible.
Likes For MrJames67:
#75
Airplanes, bikes, beer.
Join Date: Jan 2020
Location: Off the front
Posts: 763
Bikes: Road bikes, mountain bikes, a cx bike, a gravel bike…
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 398 Post(s)
Liked 788 Times
in
339 Posts
Well, shoot... I’ve only bought TWO bikes from Canyon this year. I wish I had seen this thread a long time ago, because I could have avoided so much joy and happiness if I had not done business with Canyon. This really sucks- I’m a very satisfied customer. Just great. I hate my wonderful life.