Should I trade my bike in for something more practical?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Should I trade my bike in for something more practical?
A bit of background. I’m a new rider, I purchased an entry level mountain bike and hit the trails hard for the first month of riding and decided it’s not really my thing. As an ex-motocross racer, I love the dirt and the adrenaline, but I ride solo and it’s too dangerous out there and frankly, I hated how my mountain bike rode on the street. 95% of my riding is on the street/pavement. I ride my bike to the gym each day, around town to run errands when I don’t want to take my car and the weather is nice out, and just a casual rider who wants a bike to ride around town. I don’t really want to get super involved into a new hobby, so I decided against mountain biking. I traded my mountain bike in for a race bike. I got a good deal on it, it’s a 2014 Opus Allegro 3.0 (full carbon bike). It’s got some upgrades like Ultegra group set and aftermarket hubs. I love how fast the bike is but it’s too small for my frame. I need a large, this bike is a small. After riding my road bike for the last month I decided I definitely want something that can roll fast, but maybe something more practical and more durable than carbon. I don’t have smooth paved city streets, we have cracks in the road, cracks in the sidewalks, curbs I need to jump over, etc. The road bike was very limiting in this respect. I’m a heavy rider (250lbs), and the full carbon bike was super light but I felt like I had to baby it all the time, worrying one bad jump over a curb or hard hit pothole and my bike was finished.
I went to my LBS and they’re willing to trade me my bike straight up for a brand new 2019 Trek Dual Sport 2. The bike features wider tires that can go off road on some basic trails, but still rolls well. I really like the flat handlebars/upright riding position and the comfort the bike has. The bike does have disc brakes over my wheel brakes I currently have, and the bike has more gears. I understand the quality of some components is less than what my bike has, but for my purposes I feel like it could suit me more. One thing I’m on the fence about is the front fork. While I don’t plan to ride my bike on trails, ever – I do like that the bike does feature a fork with lockout, so I can ride it around town but still be able to clear potholes/curbs if I needed to (since I am a big guy, I feel like this is good for me). I’m not concerned about weight of the bike at all. Some people told me to go with a Trek FX3 over a Trek DS2, but the FS3 doesn’t have disc brakes (on the model I’m looking at), and while it does have a rigid fork, I’m not sure if that’s something I really want because I may put more wear on the bike given my weight.
Basically, I’m looking for a solid commuter bike to cruise around town, something that can take a dirt-path or shortcut if need be (which I can’t right now on my road bike). Is a DS2 a good choice?
I went to my LBS and they’re willing to trade me my bike straight up for a brand new 2019 Trek Dual Sport 2. The bike features wider tires that can go off road on some basic trails, but still rolls well. I really like the flat handlebars/upright riding position and the comfort the bike has. The bike does have disc brakes over my wheel brakes I currently have, and the bike has more gears. I understand the quality of some components is less than what my bike has, but for my purposes I feel like it could suit me more. One thing I’m on the fence about is the front fork. While I don’t plan to ride my bike on trails, ever – I do like that the bike does feature a fork with lockout, so I can ride it around town but still be able to clear potholes/curbs if I needed to (since I am a big guy, I feel like this is good for me). I’m not concerned about weight of the bike at all. Some people told me to go with a Trek FX3 over a Trek DS2, but the FS3 doesn’t have disc brakes (on the model I’m looking at), and while it does have a rigid fork, I’m not sure if that’s something I really want because I may put more wear on the bike given my weight.
Basically, I’m looking for a solid commuter bike to cruise around town, something that can take a dirt-path or shortcut if need be (which I can’t right now on my road bike). Is a DS2 a good choice?
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2016
Location: South Carolina Upstate
Posts: 2,109
Bikes: 2010 Fuji Absolute 3.0 1994 Trek 850
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 762 Post(s)
Liked 555 Times
in
322 Posts
didn't read but the answer is no. You should just buy another bike, rinse and repeat
Likes For Flip Flop Rider:
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#4
Senior Member
You traded in your mountain bike for the Opus, was it the same shop now offering to take it back in trade for the Trek ? The Opus has expensive upgrades and might be worth more than they are offering. Have you tried selling it yourself ? Almost sounds like you might be taking a beating with the trade ins.
Post down in the hybrid forum for opinions on current year hybrids, they are all more or less the same, the one you mentioned has hydraulic discs, pros and cons on those. At least take the Opus with you to a few different shops and see if you get a better offer.
And demand a test ride, and a bike fit before you buy.
Post down in the hybrid forum for opinions on current year hybrids, they are all more or less the same, the one you mentioned has hydraulic discs, pros and cons on those. At least take the Opus with you to a few different shops and see if you get a better offer.
And demand a test ride, and a bike fit before you buy.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Menomonee Falls, WI
Posts: 1,834
Bikes: 1984 Schwinn Supersport, 1988 Trek 400T, 1977 Trek TX900, 1982 Bianchi Champione del Mondo, 1978 Raleigh Supercourse, 1986 Trek 400 Elance, 1991 Waterford PDG OS Paramount, 1971 Schwinn Sports Tourer, 1985 Trek 670
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 604 Post(s)
Liked 1,064 Times
in
535 Posts
I didn’t read it either, to long, but enjoy reading the responses, which pretty much gets me to your point.
Tim
Tim
#6
Senior Member
You're trading a lot more more bike than you're receiving.
#7
Senior Member
I am a fairly new rider
I bought a road bike in 2011 and while it was fun, it was harsh and i always wanted to go on the gravel trails but didnt because the little 23c tires
Then in 2016 i bought a gravel bike with 32or36c tires and it was fun for about a month but quickly got boring asf on the paved street sold it and kept on my 2011 road bike
I was still seeking a little more comfort and the ability to hit hard pack.... i ended up on a 2019 Roubaix its got future shock, carbon frame, carbon seatpost and 28c tires
I feel like i can go anywhere now, even off curbs and tear down sidewalks, its super smooth, i can go fast and have the option to go up to 30c tires
If that sounds like you consider a road bike you can stuff 30 or 32 tires in or go for a pure cyclocross/gravel bike to get a mix of everything
other option is always add to the bike stall and get 1 for each
I bought a road bike in 2011 and while it was fun, it was harsh and i always wanted to go on the gravel trails but didnt because the little 23c tires
Then in 2016 i bought a gravel bike with 32or36c tires and it was fun for about a month but quickly got boring asf on the paved street sold it and kept on my 2011 road bike
I was still seeking a little more comfort and the ability to hit hard pack.... i ended up on a 2019 Roubaix its got future shock, carbon frame, carbon seatpost and 28c tires
I feel like i can go anywhere now, even off curbs and tear down sidewalks, its super smooth, i can go fast and have the option to go up to 30c tires
If that sounds like you consider a road bike you can stuff 30 or 32 tires in or go for a pure cyclocross/gravel bike to get a mix of everything
other option is always add to the bike stall and get 1 for each
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Hi,
Yeah I'm considering just selling it myself for $1200 (canadian) and going from there. I didn't trade in my mountain bike to the shop, it was a private deal. I traded a Marlin 5 for my Opus Allegro 3.0, that was a good trade IMO. I LOVE my road bike, don't get me wrong. I love how light it is with the full carbon frame, how fast it rides and how smooth it is...I just don't like my limitations. I'm highly considering, if my LBS will do it- Trade straight up for a Trek FX3 Disc. I'm pretty sure they'll trade for a FX3 but I may have to nudge them to let me get the Disc model.
Yeah I'm considering just selling it myself for $1200 (canadian) and going from there. I didn't trade in my mountain bike to the shop, it was a private deal. I traded a Marlin 5 for my Opus Allegro 3.0, that was a good trade IMO. I LOVE my road bike, don't get me wrong. I love how light it is with the full carbon frame, how fast it rides and how smooth it is...I just don't like my limitations. I'm highly considering, if my LBS will do it- Trade straight up for a Trek FX3 Disc. I'm pretty sure they'll trade for a FX3 but I may have to nudge them to let me get the Disc model.
Last edited by fat2fit; 05-13-19 at 02:43 PM.
#9
Senior Member
Most people transition off of a hybrid onto a road or mountain bike since hybrids generally tend to be mediocre at everything. I will say that if you decide to get one, I recommend also getting a loop handlebar (Jones h-bar, Origin8 Strongbow, etc) since the extra hand positions over a flat bar are really nice.
As far as I know, the current hotness is getting a non-suspended drop bar frame that can clear wider tires and fitting big slicks (650B 47c+, 700C 40c+). They're supposed to be slower accelerating (weight) but similar sustained speed to road tires if you're under 20mph and fine on gravel and non-technical off road, so fairly good at everything but the extremes. Haven't tried it myself.
As far as I know, the current hotness is getting a non-suspended drop bar frame that can clear wider tires and fitting big slicks (650B 47c+, 700C 40c+). They're supposed to be slower accelerating (weight) but similar sustained speed to road tires if you're under 20mph and fine on gravel and non-technical off road, so fairly good at everything but the extremes. Haven't tried it myself.
#10
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Most people transition off of a hybrid onto a road or mountain bike since hybrids generally tend to be mediocre at everything. I will say that if you decide to get one, I recommend also getting a loop handlebar (Jones h-bar, Origin8 Strongbow, etc) since the extra hand positions over a flat bar are really nice.
As far as I know, the current hotness is getting a non-suspended drop bar frame that can clear wider tires and fitting big slicks (650B 47c+, 700C 40c+). They're supposed to be slower accelerating (weight) but similar sustained speed to road tires if you're under 20mph and fine on gravel and non-technical off road, so fairly good at everything but the extremes. Haven't tried it myself.
As far as I know, the current hotness is getting a non-suspended drop bar frame that can clear wider tires and fitting big slicks (650B 47c+, 700C 40c+). They're supposed to be slower accelerating (weight) but similar sustained speed to road tires if you're under 20mph and fine on gravel and non-technical off road, so fairly good at everything but the extremes. Haven't tried it myself.
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 3,096
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1034 Post(s)
Liked 1,292 Times
in
744 Posts
You need to figure out what you really want. You are throwing a lot of money away. You may be better off getting a bike fit, rather than continually changing entire bikes.
#12
Senior Member
Thread Starter
How have I thrown any money away? I literally traded a $500 bike for a bike worth double and haven't done anything else since aside from asking questions.
#13
Senior Member
Edit: The wide tire trend I mentioned is part of the gravel push but other companies are pushing it under different names. WTB wants to call it Road plus and a couple bike manufacturers call it all road instead of gravel and there are options that are basically road geometry with wide clearance (Rondo HVRT, Surly Midnight Special, Open U.P.).
Last edited by grayrest; 05-13-19 at 03:48 PM.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2016
Location: Sacramento, CA
Posts: 458
Bikes: 2017 Surly Cross-Check. 2020 Specialized Turbo Vado 3.0, 2002 GT Dyno Roadster, 2002 Rans Stratus, 2020 Giant Fathom 2, 2011 Trek Pure Sport
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 171 Post(s)
Liked 85 Times
in
62 Posts
If you ride the DS and like the DS, then get the DS. suspension forks (with lockout) really do help on the bumpy roads. (So does a sprung searpost). It's not a full on MTB, and it's not a full on low-rolling resistance road bike, but it suits a casual riding experience on bumpy roads.
#15
Senior Member
The entry-level components on these bikes should be fine and work properly for many years of use. Both bikes use 32 spoke rims and have triple cranks with a medium-wide range cassette - the FX3 has a somewhat lower low gear. The FX3 comes with a 32mm tire - check to see if bigger tires will fit - 38mm and above provide a nice ride at 40 - 50 psi - maybe the shop will switch them out for no charge if bigger tires fit. The DS2 comes with 38mm tires.
Plenty of rack/fender eyelets on both bikes - the only difference is I'm not sure if fenders would work on the front suspension fork of the DS2 - if this matters in your climate. I'm a fan of multi-purpose bikes that are useful for recreation and utility. This type of bike may get ridden more which means you will ride more.
I would not trade your current bike for either of these 1:1 - try to sell your current bike yourself.
Lastly, I'd suggest that you look around at other brands - Giant, Specialized, Raleigh, too many to list. There are many bikes in this category and in your price range. I'm still a fan of drop bar bikes - but those that have the characteristics that you are looking for. For example, the Salsa Journeyman Sora shown below.
Good luck and post your progress.
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 3,096
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1034 Post(s)
Liked 1,292 Times
in
744 Posts
Your Opus Allegro 3.0 when new, had an MSRP of $2198. Bluebook on it now is $680-$704 in excellent condition. But, if it doesn't fit you, or your needs, then it isn't the bike for you. The fit itself can be altered with a new stem, etc., but if it doesn't fit your needs, then it doesn't fit your needs. The Trek has an MSRP of $659.99, so yeah, based on today's bluebook price, a straight of trade isn't bad, provided you end up liking the bike.
You just seem to be wandering aimlessly between bikes, not really understanding what it is you really want. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, and I am not criticizing you, just making an observation. As long as you can get good deals, and afford it, it's great to try different bikes.
You are very fortunate to have a bike shop that will trade, and work with you. Treat that bike shop well. Good luck.
#17
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thanks again for the replies. I can't really afford to spend $700-$1000 on ANOTHER bike, so I'm taking advantage of selling or trading my road bike. The bike is a size small, I need a large. It really is just too damn small for me and I don't feel safe on my road bike with the 110 psi rock hard 23mm tires, its just not for me. I love the speed, but do not enjoy the comfort at all.
After doing extensive research on the internet it seems like everyone is really against front suspension on Hybrid bikes, but as a big rider weight isn't too much of an issue and I do like having that option of being able to go on a bit rougher terrain rather than not being able to. The fork-lockout seems to work well from what I've read, how much more will this REALLY slow me down for commuting around town? Keep in mind, I live in Canada. The roads are awful from the weather and we do have lots of bike lanes and stuff, but I really miss being able to "jump off" or "jump on" curbs and stuff like I did with my mountain bike, that's why I'm leaning towards a dual sport. I'm not going to be riding any trails, maybe just rail road paths and dirt short-cuts that consist of hard packed dirt/grass. I want something less aggressive than a mountain bike, but something I can put wide slicks on for faster rolling speed.
I'm going to be going to my LBS today and test riding the DS2 and something along the lines of a Hybrid with rigid fork as well to compare, they don't have any Trek FX in stock at all (special order), but I will ride a Norco brand or something similar to compare the ride of each bike.
Is the Dual Sport 2 going to be more comfortable than a "Fitness" bike, such as an FX3? The frame seems to have a shorter and lower top bar than the "Fitness" version bikes. I'm wanting something comfortable to ride long distances around town.
Thanks for the help and I'll let you know what I decide later today.
After doing extensive research on the internet it seems like everyone is really against front suspension on Hybrid bikes, but as a big rider weight isn't too much of an issue and I do like having that option of being able to go on a bit rougher terrain rather than not being able to. The fork-lockout seems to work well from what I've read, how much more will this REALLY slow me down for commuting around town? Keep in mind, I live in Canada. The roads are awful from the weather and we do have lots of bike lanes and stuff, but I really miss being able to "jump off" or "jump on" curbs and stuff like I did with my mountain bike, that's why I'm leaning towards a dual sport. I'm not going to be riding any trails, maybe just rail road paths and dirt short-cuts that consist of hard packed dirt/grass. I want something less aggressive than a mountain bike, but something I can put wide slicks on for faster rolling speed.
I'm going to be going to my LBS today and test riding the DS2 and something along the lines of a Hybrid with rigid fork as well to compare, they don't have any Trek FX in stock at all (special order), but I will ride a Norco brand or something similar to compare the ride of each bike.
Is the Dual Sport 2 going to be more comfortable than a "Fitness" bike, such as an FX3? The frame seems to have a shorter and lower top bar than the "Fitness" version bikes. I'm wanting something comfortable to ride long distances around town.
Thanks for the help and I'll let you know what I decide later today.
#18
Full Member
I don't think the front shock is needed. A hybrid with 38-42c tires will offer a much softer ride off pavement than the road bike but still be great for on pavement.
#19
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#20
Senior Member
For what it's worth I just sold my 2018 Giant Roam 3 disc hybrid, which was a very decent bike. No way would I have risked riding up a curb on it but I did jump off curbs out of the seat. I chose a gravel bike as my new ride, it is faster, stronger, more comfortable and goes where the Roam would fall apart.
Lot's of people ride hybrids, but I do believe you would kill the rims by hitting curbs, unless you know how to bunny hip or something.
Lot's of people ride hybrids, but I do believe you would kill the rims by hitting curbs, unless you know how to bunny hip or something.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Highlands Ranch, CO
Posts: 1,221
Bikes: '13 Diamondback Hybrid Commuter, '17 Spec Roubaix Di2, '17 Spec Camber 29'er, '19 CDale Topstone Gravel
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 590 Post(s)
Liked 445 Times
in
260 Posts
My $0.02 Get a full suspension mtb and put on 50mm slick tires. Then you can jump off any curb (or anything) you like, and the suspension will help absorb the landing, and with less risk of taco'ing the wheels. That bike will allow you to go anywhere, except loose mtb. The slick tires, along with locking out the suspension will make it plenty fast, but if you ever want it to go faster, just get a 2nd wheelset with thinner rims and tires.
I wonder why you think mtb is dangerous, even if solo? Most people, including myself, believe the opposite. Though the quick little uphills in mtb might be tough for a someone who weighs 1/8 of a ton. I have a road, a rigid hybrid, and a full-sus mtb. To me, the fun that mtb offers is orders of magnitude more than road or gravel., especially considering you enjoyed motocross.
If I could only have one, it would be a full squish mtb.
I wonder why you think mtb is dangerous, even if solo? Most people, including myself, believe the opposite. Though the quick little uphills in mtb might be tough for a someone who weighs 1/8 of a ton. I have a road, a rigid hybrid, and a full-sus mtb. To me, the fun that mtb offers is orders of magnitude more than road or gravel., especially considering you enjoyed motocross.
If I could only have one, it would be a full squish mtb.
Last edited by Riveting; 05-14-19 at 04:56 PM.
#22
Senior Member
After doing extensive research on the internet it seems like everyone is really against front suspension on Hybrid bikes, but as a big rider weight isn't too much of an issue and I do like having that option of being able to go on a bit rougher terrain rather than not being able to. The fork-lockout seems to work well from what I've read, how much more will this REALLY slow me down for commuting around town?
The main thing that determines your speed is the amount of power you put out. Working against that is body position (aerodynamic drag) and your tires (rolling resistance). Assuming you don't have some sort of MTB knobby tires, aero is the dominant factor once you start going over ~25kph. Specifically, the more upright riding position of a hybrid with flat bars increases your frontal area and you're likely to lose ~3-5 kph from the extra drag. Weight affects your acceleration and speed up hills but it's impact is determined by the combined weight of the bike and rider so even a kilogram increase in bike weight is only a 1-2% change for larger riders.
#23
Full Member
I would get a Giant Tough road. I actually have a 2017 Giant atx lite, which I would recommend if they still sold them. I think the 2018 was called a arx. I use it for dirt road or whatever. The Jones H loop bars are a big part of the versatility.
Last edited by baldilocks; 05-14-19 at 05:36 PM.
#24
Senior Member
Thread Starter
For what it's worth I just sold my 2018 Giant Roam 3 disc hybrid, which was a very decent bike. No way would I have risked riding up a curb on it but I did jump off curbs out of the seat. I chose a gravel bike as my new ride, it is faster, stronger, more comfortable and goes where the Roam would fall apart.
Lot's of people ride hybrids, but I do believe you would kill the rims by hitting curbs, unless you know how to bunny hip or something.
Lot's of people ride hybrids, but I do believe you would kill the rims by hitting curbs, unless you know how to bunny hip or something.
My $0.02 Get a full suspension mtb and put on 50mm slick tires. Then you can jump off any curb (or anything) you like, and the suspension will help absorb the landing, and with less risk of taco'ing the wheels. That bike will allow you to go anywhere, except loose mtb. The slick tires, along with locking out the suspension will make it plenty fast, but if you ever want it to go faster, just get a 2nd wheelset with thinner rims and tires.
I wonder why you think mtb is dangerous, even if solo? Most people, including myself, believe the opposite. Though the quick little uphills in mtb might be tough for a someone who weighs 1/8 of a ton. I have a road, a rigid hybrid, and a full-sus mtb. To me, the fun that mtb offers is orders of magnitude more than road or gravel., especially considering you enjoyed motocross.
If I could only have one, it would be a full squish mtb.
I wonder why you think mtb is dangerous, even if solo? Most people, including myself, believe the opposite. Though the quick little uphills in mtb might be tough for a someone who weighs 1/8 of a ton. I have a road, a rigid hybrid, and a full-sus mtb. To me, the fun that mtb offers is orders of magnitude more than road or gravel., especially considering you enjoyed motocross.
If I could only have one, it would be a full squish mtb.
Assuming you keep it locked out all the time, the extra weight is not going to significantly slow you down. You can feel it when you lift the bike and if you time hill climbs but unless you're pushing for time you're really unlikely to notice the difference if you're not looking for it. Of course, if you leave it locked out then there's really no point in having it. It is possible to ride suspended bikes without a lot of power loss if you pedal in circles. My folding bike is full suspension and I only get noticeable suspension bob (power loss) when I lose pedal technique from spinning too fast or sprinting. I don't mind the suspension on that bike because the small diameter 355 wheels do not deal well with bad asphalt at speed and the suspension keeps them in contact with the road but for 584/622 wheels I'd much rather just run wider tires at lower pressure.
The main thing that determines your speed is the amount of power you put out. Working against that is body position (aerodynamic drag) and your tires (rolling resistance). Assuming you don't have some sort of MTB knobby tires, aero is the dominant factor once you start going over ~25kph. Specifically, the more upright riding position of a hybrid with flat bars increases your frontal area and you're likely to lose ~3-5 kph from the extra drag. Weight affects your acceleration and speed up hills but it's impact is determined by the combined weight of the bike and rider so even a kilogram increase in bike weight is only a 1-2% change for larger riders.
The main thing that determines your speed is the amount of power you put out. Working against that is body position (aerodynamic drag) and your tires (rolling resistance). Assuming you don't have some sort of MTB knobby tires, aero is the dominant factor once you start going over ~25kph. Specifically, the more upright riding position of a hybrid with flat bars increases your frontal area and you're likely to lose ~3-5 kph from the extra drag. Weight affects your acceleration and speed up hills but it's impact is determined by the combined weight of the bike and rider so even a kilogram increase in bike weight is only a 1-2% change for larger riders.
My LBS doesn't even stock many of the FX bikes due to where we live they're not very good compared to the DS
The reason I think mountain biking alone is dangerous is because I live in BC, it's all downhill literal mountains and very sketch if you fly off the side of the mountain and you're out there alone.
Last edited by fat2fit; 05-14-19 at 06:31 PM.