Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   General Cycling Discussion (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Waxing chain, benzene a cancer risk? (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1239996)

Wattsup 10-04-21 04:59 PM


Originally Posted by masi61 (Post 22257028)
Once you get set up on a chain wax system where you rotate 2 or 3 chains, then waxing or changing chains after every ride would not be that time consuming. So long as you use quick links, changing out a chain takes about the same amount of time as putting air in your tires before a ride.

I have the Connex link, so it's quite quick to pop off the chain. I've waxed my chain with plain old Gulf paraffin about 4 times before and after gravel rides so far. It's not just the waxing that takes time. After the wax dries hard, breaking free 118 links takes a while, and then I have to run each link over my single chain ring at least once. I was getting pretty good at it. After each ride, the chain looks clean, but apparently appearances deceive. I melted my wax today and dumped it, and there was a good amount of black debris in the bottom of the crock pot. I was going to try the Silca wax. Not sure what I'll do now.

Maelochs 10-04-21 06:04 PM

Oi.

There are so many things which could cause our inevitable deaths, and people are worrying about chain wax? Have you ever been in a rook=m with a candle burning? Ever eaten cooked meat? You have a lot more chance of dying from injuries while crashing on a bike than from chain wax. And a vastly greater chance of dying from a slip and fall in the bathroom --- so do you not shower, and relieve yourself in a hole outside? Oh, No! the risk of dysentery!

Use a liquid wax, wear a ventilator, or best of all --- stop riding, It is just too dangerous.

And by the last post you are saying waxing takes too long---which is certainly a s serious an objection and "Waxing is fatal." "Waxing is deadly---and it takes too long."

I am taking you seriously, believe me.

Wattsup 10-04-21 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by Maelochs (Post 22257187)
Oi.

There are so many things which could cause our inevitable deaths, and people are worrying about chain wax? Have you ever been in a rook=m with a candle burning? Ever eaten cooked meat? You have a lot more chance of dying from injuries while crashing on a bike than from chain wax. And a vastly greater chance of dying from a slip and fall in the bathroom --- so do you not shower, and relieve yourself in a hole outside? Oh, No! the risk of dysentery!

Use a liquid wax, wear a ventilator, or best of all --- stop riding, It is just too dangerous.

And by the last post you are saying waxing takes too long---which is certainly a s serious an objection and "Waxing is fatal." "Waxing is deadly---and it takes too long."

I am taking you seriously, believe me.

And you could have sprained a finger with that rushed, semi-coherent reply!

WhyFi 10-04-21 06:29 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22256753)
I just read that heating paraffin creates benzene. What do you all think? Here's where I read it. Search on benzene.

https://zerofrictioncycling.com.au/w...-FAQ-v1.3a.pdf

The link that you provide cautions against this only if you're heating the oil to the point of fuming. You don't need to do that. You shouldn't do that. So don't do that.

Wattsup 10-04-21 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by WhyFi (Post 22257209)
The link that you provide cautions against this only if you're heating the oil to the point of fuming. You don't need to do that. You shouldn't do that. So don't do that.

What exactly does "fuming" mean? At some point in the heating process, the wax does begin to give off an door. Is that fuming? Actually, the writer talks about heating the wax too quickly, not to too high a temp. That's how I read it at least.

skidder 10-04-21 06:45 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257137)
I have the Connex link, so it's quite quick to pop off the chain. I've waxed my chain with plain old Gulf paraffin about 4 times before and after gravel rides so far. It's not just the waxing that takes time. After the wax dries hard, breaking free 118 links takes a while, and then I have to run each link over my single chain ring at least once. I was getting pretty good at it. After each ride, the chain looks clean, but apparently appearances deceive. I melted my wax today and dumped it, and there was a good amount of black debris in the bottom of the crock pot. I was going to try the Silca wax. Not sure what I'll do now.

If I had to spend that much time cleaning and re-lubing a chain I just would not ride a bicycle. I ride on pavement probably 80-100 miles per week, sometimes near the beach ('fugitive' sand). I clean my chains once per month with one of those clamp-on Park Tool cleaning devices containing a little bit of Simple Green solution. Lube is 80W gear oil, I've had the same bottle for 10 years.

Paraffin wax: Just heat it up slowly until it melts enough to be as 'workable' as you need it, and do it in a ventilated area. Frankly, I'd be more worried about the fumes from the heating device your using to melt the wax (natural gas, propane, maybe 'white' gas in a camping stove?)

Maelochs 10-04-21 06:53 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257213)
What exactly does "fuming" mean? At some point in the heating process, the wax does begin to give off an door.

And you accuse me of incoherence?

I have waxed a lot of chains, and heated a lot of wax, and at no time did the wax give off a door.

You are just playing here. if you really cared you would have googled the actual facts about paraffin, instead of asking here on BF. But only here on BF can you get so much attention. Doping actual research is dry and dull. Of course, that is what you have to do if you want to learn.

Since you are not doing that, you don't want to learn. Therefore it seems what you want is attention from BF.

Good strategy, i guess.

But yeah ... how's it living under that bridge?

Wattsup 10-04-21 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by Maelochs (Post 22257242)
And you accuse me of incoherence?

I have waxed a lot of chains, and heated a lot of wax, and at no time did the wax give off a door.

You are just playing here. if you really cared you would have googled the actual facts about paraffin, instead of asking here on BF. But only here on BF can you get so much attention. Doping actual research is dry and dull. Of course, that is what you have to do if you want to learn.

Since you are not doing that, you don't want to learn. Therefore it seems what you want is attention from BF.

Good strategy, i guess.

But yeah ... how's it living under that bridge?

First, you don't know what research I did before my post here, second, the Gulf Paraffin I am using DOES begin to give off an odor at some point when heated, which is the reason I posted here, and third....Might be best that you just move along to the next thread.

WhyFi 10-04-21 07:03 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257213)
What exactly does "fuming" mean? At some point in the heating process, the wax does begin to give off an door. Is that fuming? Actually, the writer talks about heating the wax too quickly, not to too high a temp. That's how I read it at least.

Again, from your own link -


Don’t get your wax way too hot – ie slow cooker on low, lid off, or instant pot set to 90dg c, and again things are no more dangerous than boiling your kettle.
As far as the odor -


No the scent is not toxic. Candles have a scent too, and the scent is not toxic, but the candles will be releasing a tiny amount of benzene gas, your not burning wax will not be. As long as it is not too hot so that it is fuming, it is just basically a lubrication candle – without the burning.

indyfabz 10-04-21 08:15 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257250)
First, you don't know what research I did before my post here, second, the Gulf Paraffin I am using DOES begin to give off an odor at some point when heated, which is the reason I posted here, and third....Might be best that you just move along to the next thread.

Like I posted before, just use NFS if you’re so concerned that you needed to start a thread after all you (assumed) research. It’s the best lube in the galaxy. No lie.

Wattsup 10-04-21 08:17 PM


Originally Posted by indyfabz (Post 22257349)
Like I posted before, just use NFS if you’re so concerned that you needed to start a thread after all you (assumed) research. It’s the best lube in the galaxy. No lie.

Heard bad things about that stuff.

jaxgtr 10-04-21 08:24 PM

remember when it was all the rage that eggs were bad for you , and then they weren't.....LOL.... yea me too

cyccommute 10-04-21 09:18 PM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257213)
What exactly does "fuming" mean? At some point in the heating process, the wax does begin to give off an door. Is that fuming? Actually, the writer talks about heating the wax too quickly, not to too high a temp. That's how I read it at least.

Not “fuming”. Smoking. Fuming is different. This description is a good explanation although I would say that “fumes” are more something that is caused by reaction with air like you find with nitric acid or a pyrophoric compound.


Smoke is a fine solid formed by incomplete burning. Fumes are fine airborne particles produced when a solid vapourises and condenses, eg during welding
Things start to get funny when material starts to burn. You can have incomplete combustion which causes the formation of different compounds. Just heating the wax to the melt point is enough to get very small amounts of the wax to volatilize (evaporate) but that’s not hazardous.

Lots of people use a Crock Pot for heating the oil which isn’t a bad idea since you can’t get up to the point where you can burn the wax. If you don’t have a Crock Pot, at least use a double boiler. The condensing steam will provide enough heat to melt the wax without overheating it. Do not put a pan on direct heat to melt the wax. That’s will allow for overheating. Crock Pots and double boilers are easy to find at thrift stores.

tomato coupe 10-04-21 09:19 PM


Originally Posted by jaxgtr (Post 22257361)
remember when it was all the rage that eggs were bad for you , and then they weren't.....LOL.... yea me too

Eggs have always been bad for your chain.

WhyFi 10-04-21 09:43 PM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 22257422)
Crock Pots and double boilers are easy to find at thrift stores.

The small (2qt) crockpots are perfect for waxing chains (bigger means that you have to dump in more wax to submerge the chain) and they're only 10-12 bucks brand new at Target and the like.

Troul 10-05-21 01:53 AM


Originally Posted by tomato coupe (Post 22257426)
Eggs have always been bad for your chain.

what about if they are yolkless?

downhillmaster 10-05-21 02:18 AM

How shocking that a paranoia thread about the potentially deadly effects of waxing a bike chain devolved so quickly.
And who knew that the folks at a for-profit Australian chain testing website were such experts in carcinogens…
:thumb::thumb:

indyfabz 10-05-21 05:40 AM


Originally Posted by Wattsup (Post 22257355)
Heard bad things about that stuff.

That it’s more carcinogenic than benzene?

Maelochs 10-05-21 06:45 AM

The guy is equally concerned about nonexistent toxic fumes and taking too long for bike maintenance. Let's let Darwin decide this thread.

Racing Dan 10-05-21 08:05 AM


Originally Posted by genejockey (Post 22256942)
Not to rain on the parade, but isn't a 'liquid wax' just heavier chain hydrocarbons suspended/dissolved in lighter chain hydrocarbons which evaporate, leaving only the heavies? So, volatile solvent - not generally known to be all that healthy.

Not all. Some (most?) are emulsions. That is wax in water. Emulsion waxes are readily available on amazon if anyone cares to experiment.

Wattsup 10-05-21 08:07 AM

Thanks cyccommute...Your posts always stand out in these threads....informative, expert advice. You obviously know what you're talking about....as opposed to a few here who have no clue! Thanks for stopping by.


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 22257422)
Not “fuming”. Smoking. Fuming is different. This description is a good explanation although I would say that “fumes” are more something that is caused by reaction with air like you find with nitric acid or a pyrophoric compound.



Things start to get funny when material starts to burn. You can have incomplete combustion which causes the formation of different compounds. Just heating the wax to the melt point is enough to get very small amounts of the wax to volatilize (evaporate) but that’s not hazardous.

Lots of people use a Crock Pot for heating the oil which isn’t a bad idea since you can’t get up to the point where you can burn the wax. If you don’t have a Crock Pot, at least use a double boiler. The condensing steam will provide enough heat to melt the wax without overheating it. Do not put a pan on direct heat to melt the wax. That’s will allow for overheating. Crock Pots and double boilers are easy to find at thrift stores.


Bald Paul 10-05-21 08:34 AM

I read a lot of product warning labels. Most things, it seems, will only cause cancer if you live in California.

woodcraft 10-05-21 09:22 AM

PTFE is a problem because it basically never breaks down, and is accumulating in the environment, including in your body.

Using your bike to spread large amounts of it is irresponsible.

https://greensciencepolicy.org/harmful-chemicals/pfas/


I would also argue that scent added to candles is toxic.

https://greensciencepolicy.org/harmf...ls-phthalates/

"...The words “fragrance,” “perfume,” or “parfum” often mean phthalates are present."


https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...2f9ca77266.jpg

Bholz 10-05-21 10:48 AM


Originally Posted by bald paul (Post 22257817)
i read a lot of product warning labels. Most things, it seems, will only cause cancer if you live in california.

haha!

Troul 10-05-21 10:52 AM

my DS leg might be all that my chain will ever need for lubrication as PTFE might be readily available from the pores. Payback time to the chain after all these years of smearing it's alpha grease on my limb!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:55 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.