Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=41)
-   -   SPD power meter (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1235329)

Geo_Zegarra2016 07-23-21 10:13 PM

SPD power meter
 
Does anyone know if Garmin Rally XC200 is the only power meter for MTB shoes? I know there are more options for road power meters but I'm already used to MTB and I feel like it might take me longer to get used to clip and unclip with road pedals. I'm looking to getting a power meter as my first upgrade. Should I invest in learning road pedals? Is there a difference? Will I know the difference between MTB pedals and road pedals? Since I have two bikes one for trainer and road. I plan to put road pedals on my trainer so I can get used to them. That is how I learn to get used to the MTB on my bike. Please any suggestions. I started working out starting with elliptical in June 2020 then cycling in December 2020 and since then I've lost 43 lbs. I am planning to start running :)

Seattle Forrest 07-23-21 10:17 PM

Congratulations on the weight loss!

I used SPD pedals for many years, switched to Keo ones to run power meter pedals. Clipping in and out feels slightly different but it isn't the kind of thing that takes getting used to. 🙂

You have a lot of options that don't involve pedals, like the hub or crank.

Geo_Zegarra2016 07-23-21 10:23 PM


Originally Posted by Seattle Forrest (Post 22155367)
Congratulations on the weight loss!

I used SPD pedals for many years, switched to Keo ones to run power meter pedals. Clipping in and out feels slightly different but it isn't the kind of thing that takes getting used to. 🙂

You have a lot of options that don't involve pedals, like the hub or crank.

Thank you! It was a lot of patience but is definitely paying off. Feel better than ever and I'm so happy to have a lifestyle change. At the age 25, I'm feeling better than ever :) Do you say clipping out during a hill is challenging?

Broctoon 07-23-21 10:42 PM

There are road pedals that clip in and out very easily, especially if you turn the release force adjustment way down. But some people just like the dual sided MTB pedals. I don’t think you’ll have a hard time getting used to a new model.

You’re taking a very wise approach. On your idea to start running, I say “ awesome!” You’ll probably find the riding and running compliment each other nicely. My one piece of advice here is to take it slow. You always hear this, but it bears repeating: don’t get in a hurry to turn up the intensity or distance. Start at a mile or two, be patient and consistent, and only increase your distance by about 10% each week.

Geo_Zegarra2016 07-23-21 10:47 PM


Originally Posted by Broctoon (Post 22155393)
There are road pedals that clip in and out very easily, especially if you turn the release force adjustment way down. But some people just like the dual sided MTB pedals. I don’t think you’ll have a hard time getting used to a new model.

You’re taking a very wise approach. On your idea to start running, I say “ awesome!” You’ll probably find the riding and running compliment each other nicely. My one piece of advice here is to take it slow. You always hear this, but it bears repeating: don’t get in a hurry to turn up the intensity or distance. Start at a mile or two, be patient and consistent, and only increase your distance by about 10% each week.

Thank you! I am planning to run to my dad's job which is two miles back and forth. So about four miles in total. Not sure if that is a lot for a first-timer. The only reason for starting running is because I am planning on doing an 80-mile ride before I leave for grad school in the last week of August. So I hope running does help me. I also want to keep getting fit because is now my new lifestlye. So I don't want to lose everything I've worked for so hard. Today, a MEDIUM shirt fit me.

tempocyclist 07-23-21 11:49 PM


Originally Posted by Geo_Zegarra2016 (Post 22155357)
Does anyone know if Garmin Rally XC200 is the only power meter for MTB shoes?


Pretty much, yeah. There's also the SRM X-Power SPD pedals but they cost a LOAD more.

You could go down the Assioma SPD hack/bodge route, but the Rallys are I think the only off-the-shelf option worth considering.

Seattle Forrest 07-24-21 12:05 AM


Originally Posted by Geo_Zegarra2016 (Post 22155395)
Thank you! I am planning to run to my dad's job which is two miles back and forth. So about four miles in total. Not sure if that is a lot for a first-timer. The only reason for starting running is because I am planning on doing an 80-mile ride before I leave for grad school in the last week of August. So I hope running does help me. I also want to keep getting fit because is now my new lifestlye. So I don't want to lose everything I've worked for so hard. Today, a MEDIUM shirt fit me.

Look into Couch to 5k. You're probably already fit enough to run a mile or two but the connective tissue in your joints needs time to adapt to the impact of running.

MinnMan 07-24-21 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by Geo_Zegarra2016 (Post 22155357)
Does anyone know if Garmin Rally XC200 is the only power meter for MTB shoes? I know there are more options for road power meters but I'm already used to MTB and I feel like it might take me longer to get used to clip and unclip with road pedals. I'm looking to getting a power meter as my first upgrade. Should I invest in learning road pedals? Is there a difference? Will I know the difference between MTB pedals and road pedals? Since I have two bikes one for trainer and road. I plan to put road pedals on my trainer so I can get used to them. That is how I learn to get used to the MTB on my bike. Please any suggestions. I started working out starting with elliptical in June 2020 then cycling in December 2020 and since then I've lost 43 lbs. I am planning to start running :)

Good for you for bucking the pandemic trend. My wife commented today that she saw a friend in person for the first time since the pandemic and that the friend had gained so much weight, her face had changed appearance.

Geo_Zegarra2016 07-24-21 09:33 PM


Originally Posted by Seattle Forrest (Post 22155427)
Look into Couch to 5k. You're probably already fit enough to run a mile or two but the connective tissue in your joints needs time to adapt to the impact of running.

What is connective tissue? I just got my running shoes :)

Geo_Zegarra2016 07-24-21 09:34 PM

is the connective tissue the pain that seems like a spider killing your legs?

Seattle Forrest 07-24-21 09:57 PM

A Runner’s Guide to Connective Tissue

Most connective tissues adapt to training, but there’s a catch: they adapt at a much slower rate than muscle. When you allow your muscle development to outpace connective tissue adaptation, the result can be injury. Runners begin training and their muscles improve rapidly. Encouraged, they increase the intensity and length of their workouts. The next thing they know, they’ve got Achilles tendinosis, tibial tendinitis or stress fractures in their feet. Their connective tissue couldn’t cope with the increased workload, even though their muscles seemed fine.

Check Couch to 5k out, or just start slowly with run/walk intervals. 🙂

topflightpro 07-25-21 05:53 AM


Originally Posted by tempocyclist (Post 22155421)
Pretty much, yeah. There's also the SRM X-Power SPD pedals but they cost a LOAD more.

You could go down the Assioma SPD hack/bodge route, but the Rallys are I think the only off-the-shelf option worth considering.

SRM X-Power dual sided are the exact same price as the Garmin: $1200. It's only pricier if you buy single sided $700 vs $900. And SRM has a much stronger track record of building quality products.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:59 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.