Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=41)
-   -   Chain fell off mid pack (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1242319)

LarrySellerz 11-15-21 05:28 PM

Chain fell off mid pack
 
Hey guys, my chain on my single speed had been falling off recently, so I reduced the slack by moving my back wheel a bit. Today I was in the middle of the pack on a group ride, and my chain fell off, I went over to the side and started yelling "stopping, stopping." Pretty darn embarrassed, I'm trying not to get a reputation for a sketchy rider and this doesn't help my case. Should I take the bike to a bike shop before riding it in the group again? Should I apologize on the facebook group for the mechanical? Have any of you dealt with people who have mechanicals like this, how sketchy is it/how do I build my rep back besides just not having it happen again. Sorry for the blog post lol

Mojo31 11-15-21 05:37 PM

Gold chain or silver?

genejockey 11-15-21 05:38 PM


Originally Posted by LarrySellerz (Post 22308690)
Hey guys, my chain on my single speed had been falling off recently, so I reduced the slack by moving my back wheel a bit. Today I was in the middle of the pack on a group ride, and my chain fell off, I went over to the side and started yelling "stopping, stopping." Pretty darn embarrassed, I'm trying not to get a reputation for a sketchy rider and this doesn't help my case. Should I take the bike to a bike shop before riding it in the group again? Should I apologize on the facebook group for the mechanical? Have any of you dealt with people who have mechanicals like this, how sketchy is it/how do I build my rep back besides just not having it happen again. Sorry for the blog post lol

Did your wheel move in the dropouts?

Sy Reene 11-15-21 05:41 PM

Did any cars drive over the chain after it fell off? Or could you put it back on?

big john 11-15-21 05:42 PM

The fact that you got out of the way and warned everybody should help your cred. Bikes have problems sometimes and if you're trying to get it sorted, that's all others can ask. That said, it's pretty unusual for a ss to drop the chain, no?
Just don't be that guy who always has problems.

Gravel Rider 11-15-21 05:44 PM


Originally Posted by Sy Reene (Post 22308719)
Did any cars drive over the chain after it fell off? Or could you put it back on?

He had 2 spares. :innocent:

LarrySellerz 11-15-21 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by Mojo31 (Post 22308709)
Gold chain or silver?

gold

shelbyfv 11-15-21 05:54 PM

Sup Larry! Did anyone stop while you fixed the chain? If they did you may be OK at least until the next incident.:twitchy: Your chain shouldn't be falling off.

Eric F 11-15-21 05:56 PM

If your chain is falling off on any kind of regular basis, there's something really wrong with your setup. I ride a singlespeed MTB on some pretty technical terrain, and things get banged around a lot. I have had my chain drop zero times. Proper chain tension and good chainring-cog alignment are highly important details in proper SS setup.

Carbonfiberboy 11-15-21 05:59 PM

Single speed, not a fixed hub? If you don't know how to fix it, yes absolutely take it to a shop. Stuff can happen on group rides, which is the reason that our group has admission standards. One can't just show up and ride. If you're worried about rep, get your bike fixed and explain/show what happened and the fix to the ride leader. Don't worry about the rest of the group - they'll be OK after a a few perfect rides. Mechanicals happen.

LarrySellerz 11-15-21 06:03 PM

Guess i'm taking it to the shop, don't like putting money into such a cheap bike (150$) but this can't keep happening. This is a self policing drop ride with no leader, but I don't wanna grind peoples gears too much you feel? Especially because showing up on a single speed is kinda clownish

msu2001la 11-15-21 07:59 PM

I feel

cxwrench 11-15-21 09:22 PM


Originally Posted by shelbyfv (Post 22308745)
Sup Larry! Did anyone stop while you fixed the chain? If they did you may be OK at least until the next incident.:twitchy: Your chain shouldn't be falling off. Is this a single speed you kludged or a proper bike? If it's cobbled, check your chain line and be sure you are using a "narrow wide" chain ring.

Narrow-wide rings aren't used on road single speed, nor on mtb single speeds.

shelbyfv 11-15-21 09:29 PM


Originally Posted by cxwrench (Post 22308986)
Narrow-wide rings aren't used on road single speed, nor on mtb single speeds.

Thanks! I'll edit my post. Just for 1X then?

cxwrench 11-15-21 09:35 PM


Originally Posted by shelbyfv (Post 22308992)
Thanks! I'll edit my post. Just for 1X then?

Exactly, narrow-wide and the clutch derailleurs are what keeps the chain on. :thumb:

MinnMan 11-15-21 09:54 PM

This is some kind of wayward harmonic convergence.

Andy Somnifac 11-16-21 07:29 AM

You may not want a rep as a sketchy ride partner, but if your chain has fallen off multiple times lately, I hate to tell you: You're a sketchy ride partner.

LarrySellerz 11-16-21 08:08 AM


Originally Posted by Andy Somnifac (Post 22309223)
You may not want a rep as a sketchy ride partner, but if your chain has fallen off multiple times lately, I hate to tell you: You're a sketchy ride partner.

people only saw it once lol that's what matters.

Andy Somnifac 11-16-21 08:12 AM


Originally Posted by LarrySellerz (Post 22309263)
people only saw it once lol that's what matters.

So, they're unaware of the pattern and may not give you the space that would be a good idea? That's potentially even worse.

mstateglfr 11-16-21 08:20 AM


Originally Posted by LarrySellerz (Post 22308760)
Especially because showing up on a single speed is kinda clownish

yup

mstateglfr 11-16-21 08:20 AM


Originally Posted by cubewheels (Post 22308990)
Worst thing that could happen in SS, the chain comes off the rear cog and lodge itself between the cog and the dropout, it can lock the rear wheel and take out the rider(s) behind you.

Happened to me twice with the same bike, I managed to fix the problem but can't remember what caused the problem in the first place, it was very long time ago.

Impossible to happen in geared drivetrain due to L and H adjustment

Its impossible, and yet it is a common issue.

Moe Zhoost 11-16-21 08:22 AM

In a single speed setup, a properly tensioned chain should not be falling off. I'd check these: 1) Chain condition - replace it if stretched, 2) Chain rings and cog for any anomalies like bent teeth. Some chainrings have "features" for better shifting; however it's not likely that they would cause a chain drop. 3) proper alignment - is your rear wheel co-planer with the frame centerline? This is done by properly mounting your wheel. Is the chainline right? This may require a different bottom bracket spindle, though respacing the hub may do the trick (but this may require re-dishing the wheel) 4) Frame alignment - If your rear triangle is offset you'll have problems. Check with either an alignment gauge or use the string test. 5)Frame flex - if your chain drops occur when applying a lot of pedal pressure it may mean that your frame is flexing to the point that mis-alignment occurs.

Good luck, mate. I hope you figure it out.

LarrySellerz 11-16-21 08:58 AM


Originally Posted by mstateglfr (Post 22309276)
yup

yesterday there was a dude on a fixie LOL. He chilled in the back though so its cool, this group is pretty lax with the rules.

smashndash 11-16-21 10:20 AM

A video is worth a million words. Show us how much chain slack you have. It's possible that your rear wheel is slipping as you tighten the nut. In that case, you need better nuts and possibly chain tensioners.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:21 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.