Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Help removing rear cassette (SEE PIC) (https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=1290040)

Rooster Ren 03-20-24 04:59 AM

Help removing rear cassette (SEE PIC)
 
I need help removing the rear casette from a sparta ion wheel. I have the tool that fits in the casette and a chain whip, i tried but it is not moving, what is the correct method?

SJX426 03-20-24 06:03 AM

@Rooster Ren - Welcome to BF
1. Pictures are needed, either a link to a web hosted site or post it in you albums under your profile
2. You may have a freewheel instead of a cassette, don't know without knowing more.
3. If you want to remove the sprockets, it is easy if you have a cassette but need two chain whips for a freewheel.
4.A cassette should come off easily with a retaining ring with a counter clock rotation. The tool is typically splined
5. If it is a freewheel, the tool could have splines or lugs in quantity of 2 or four.

Read this: Shimano Cassettes & Freehubs (sheldonbrown.com)

Kontact 03-20-24 06:34 AM

Tried looking at specs on the Sparta website: No Ion model listed, no specs under any bike. But many are 7 speed, and those are usually freewheels, not cassettes. Freewheels need a freewheel tool and a wrench - no chain whip.

cb400bill 03-20-24 06:37 AM

Pic Assist - https://www.bikeforums.net/g/picture/33089631

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...918d6e36fc.jpg

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...4750589602.jpg

Kontact 03-20-24 06:43 AM

That's a freewheel. Tool in freewheel, wrench on tool, hold the wheel and turn counterclockwise. No chainwhip.

Crankycrank 03-20-24 07:13 AM

Also, if it's really stuck on there, put your quick release skewer through the tool and axle to hold it in place and have it tight enough to leave a little bit of play to allow the freewheel to turn a bit when it breaks free. This will allow you to put all your effort into the wrench and not worry the tool will pop out and fecker up the splines.

Kai Winters 03-20-24 07:15 AM

Freewheel removal tool placed in bench vise...wheel with freewheel side down is placed onto removal tool...turn wheel counter/anti clock wise...
While you can use an adjustable wrench the bench vise method provides more leverage?
You may have to give the wheel a mighty turn to break the freewheel free of the hub...most likely you will.
Reverse the above method to reinstall/install the freewheel

smd4 03-20-24 08:14 AM


Originally Posted by Kai Winters (Post 23189803)
Freewheel removal tool placed in bench vise...wheel with freewheel side down is placed onto removal tool...turn wheel counter/anti clock wise...
While you can use an adjustable wrench the bench vise method provides more leverage?

That's always the method we used. Much less chance of buggering up the splines.

MudPie 03-20-24 08:55 AM

Regarding freewheels in general, they can be screwed on pretty tight, since the pedaling action tightens the mounting screw onto the hub. The bench vise method works best since you have a pretty good lever arm (the wheel) to break the joint free. (Some people liken it to a bus driver making a turn.) But if you don't have a bench vise, leave the inflated tire on the bike. Then place wheel vertical on the ground. Position your self over the wheel and use a long wrench (in the horizontal position) and use your weight to unscrew the freewheel. It's a great feeling when it breaks loose. And always a good idea to use the skewer or axle nut to loosely retain the tool into the splines. When re-installing grease the threads.

grumpus 03-20-24 10:07 AM


Originally Posted by smd4 (Post 23189851)
That's always the method we used. Much less chance of buggering up the splines.

And if it's really tight, like tandem tight, have someone else lend a hand.

Trakhak 03-20-24 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by MudPie (Post 23189919)
Regarding freewheels in general, they can be screwed on pretty tight, since the pedaling action tightens the mounting screw onto the hub. The bench vise method works best since you have a pretty good lever arm (the wheel) to break the joint free. (Some people liken it to a bus driver making a turn.) But if you don't have a bench vise, leave the inflated tire on the bike. Then place wheel vertical on the ground. Position your self over the wheel and use a long wrench (in the horizontal position) and use your weight to unscrew the freewheel. It's a great feeling when it breaks loose. And always a good idea to use the skewer or axle nut to loosely retain the tool into the splines. When re-installing grease the threads.

Agree, except for "use the skewer or axle nut to loosely retain the tool into the splines."

There's no downside to clamping the tool with the same (high) force you use to reinstall the wheel in the bike. Once the freewheel has moved even 2 or 3 degrees, the battle has been won. You can then begin loosening the skewer or axle a turn or so at a time while you continue to unscrew the freewheel.

There is a potential downside to not doing so, as holding some tools loosely and attempting to remove some hard-to-remove freewheels can result in damage to the freewheel and/or the tool. I once watched a mechanic in our shop ruin two remover tools in succession before I stepped in.

Kontact 03-20-24 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by Trakhak (Post 23190119)
Agree, except for "use the skewer or axle nut to loosely retain the tool into the splines."

There's no downside to clamping the tool with the same (high) force you use to reinstall the wheel in the bike. Once the freewheel has moved even 2 or 3 degrees, the battle has been won. You can then begin loosening the skewer or axle a turn or so at a time while you continue to unscrew the freewheel.

There is a potential downside to not doing so, as holding some tools loosely and attempting to remove some hard-to-remove freewheels can result in damage to the freewheel and/or the tool. I once watched a mechanic in our shop ruin two remover tools in succession before I stepped in.

Shimano splined tools like the OP is using, or toothed tools like Suntour? I've never seen anyone use a QR on the spline type, or seen those tools fail.

Aardwolf 03-20-24 02:28 PM

Another method for freewheels if you've still got the tire on and don't have a decent vice:

Lock removal tool with QR.
Get a long wrench.
Put the wheel against a brick wall on a hard (cement or tarmac for example) floor - so the tire grips on the floor and the bricks.
Apply the wrench about horizontal and push down.

Bill Kapaun 03-20-24 02:43 PM


Originally Posted by Aardwolf (Post 23190260)
Another method for freewheels if you've still got the tire on and don't have a decent vice:

Lock removal tool with QR.
Get a long wrench.
Put the wheel against a brick wall on a hard (cement or tarmac for example) floor - so the tire grips on the floor and the bricks.
Apply the wrench about horizontal and push down.

Good idea. The street curb may suffice?
IF you have a helper, have the strong one hold the wheel and the weak one step on the horizontally positioned wrench.

ClydeClydeson 03-20-24 02:48 PM

Is that the correct tool, though? That looks like the tool for removing cassette lock rings, not freewheels. THe spline patters on the two are generally slightly different and so they are not perfectly cross-compatible. Also, freewheel spline tools are generally longer so there is more contact between the tool splines and the freewheel splines.

Trakhak 03-20-24 03:36 PM


Originally Posted by Kontact (Post 23190128)
Shimano splined tools like the OP is using, or toothed tools like Suntour? I've never seen anyone use a QR on the spline type, or seen those tools fail.

Thanks for the clarification! You're right, of course. I was thinking of the two-pronged tools used for Suntour and the like.

Aardwolf 03-20-24 03:39 PM


Originally Posted by Bill Kapaun (Post 23190276)
Good idea. The street curb may suffice?
IF you have a helper, have the strong one hold the wheel and the weak one step on the horizontally positioned wrench.

If the wrench is horizontal the downward pressure pushes the tyre into the floor and the wall and there's plenty of grip.

Bill Kapaun 03-20-24 03:48 PM


Originally Posted by Aardwolf (Post 23190328)
If the wrench is horizontal the downward pressure pushes the tyre into the floor and the wall and there's plenty of grip.

My suggestion was for those of less opportunity.
I just use the outside door jamb of my garage if necessary & box end of my 1" combination wrench. It's never failed me.

smd4 03-20-24 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by ClydeClydeson (Post 23190282)
Is that the correct tool, though? That looks like the tool for removing cassette lock rings, not freewheels. THe spline patters on the two are generally slightly different and so they are not perfectly cross-compatible. Also, freewheel spline tools are generally longer so there is more contact between the tool splines and the freewheel splines.

Cassette lockring tools are much shorter.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:51 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.