broke my non-replaceable rear derailleur hanger - options?
 

Hi all, while trying to align a non-replaceable rear derailleur hanger, I cracked it. Embarrassing!

I was repairing an older Schwinn cruiser. It's a cool bike that someone will enjoy.

I'm told I should convert from 7 speed to single speed, since the new hangar might not cover all cogs. I don't really understand this. And, I'm unclear of the steps to install a new hanger.

I need help researching a replacement hangar and freewheel if converting to single speed is the best approach.

What are my options to save this cruiser?

Thanks in advance.

I have an old aluminum Specialized Stumpjumper I saved, the hanger was completely ripped off by someone. I'm using one of these Shimano Hone derailleurs, it mounts on the hub axle: https://www.ebay.com/itm/20295210599...cAAOSwTAheg3Gr

You need the hub, or at least the axle to transplant into another Shimano hub. Oddly the derailleurs are very common but the hubs are hard to find. Also requires a axle slot that's mostly intact and oriented correctly to locate the derailleur.

This is the more basic axle mounted derailleur option, called a claw mount: https://www.ebay.com/itm/11469430001...Cclp%3A2047675

Might not work with a cruiser frame, often they have an odd dropout. Try to post a picture if you get the post count to ten.

Double edit: Actually the claw mount might not work on that.

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...860cd2bf7.jpeg
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...8165fbd63.jpeg

Schwinn cruiser. Go to a motorcycle repair shop, have them weld it and run a M10 x 1.0 tap through after to clean the threads up
Or get it welded and install a dropout saver
https://wheelsmfg.com/presses-tools/dropout-savers.html

Thank you both. Wes, can you point me to a likely hub replacement, or direct me on how to figure out the correct one? Thanks again.

You state that the der hangar is non-replaceable, and you want help finding a replacement.

Does not make sense to me.

I need a solution to resolve a broken non-replaceable hangar.

If your cruiser has moreorless horizontal drop outs.
You may not need a new hub.
If you are willing to live with a chain on a single cog & be happy with it only on that one cog of the many then it is simple. Shorten the chain a few links to account for the non existent derailleur. Put the chain on the cog of choice, slide the wheel back until the chain is tight & retighten the axle nuts.

EDIT: If you have vertical dropouts & can't slide the axle back & forth, but do have a selection of chainrings /cogs around you can install a "ghost ring" to take up the slack. It looks hack-y but, ghost rings work.

Double EDIT: Any frame builder should be able to weld on a replacement. They often have a $100 or similar minimum labor charge.

Thank you, this seems to be a consensus view. I'll post a solution when I'm done.

There is a real risk here. I did this with my Peugeot UO-8; the bike that introduced me to 10-speeds when I was 13. It had enough crashes and "learning experiences" that the dropouts were so distorted getting the plastic Simplex derailleur to align properly on the "claw" hanger was near impossible. So I took it off, dropped the chain onto the middle cog and removed links as you suggest. Worked. Several years later I started racing, (Different bike.) Club vets told me to set this bike up fix gear. Did. Crashed first ride when I tried to coast. And was completely hooked. Since then, I've always had at least one, Now more than half the fleet. More than half the miles in my legs.

So, careful, OP. You are treading dangerous ground.

It's a $100 bike even when fixed.

please remove the image of bike on car rack. It's unnecessary to the conversation. Thank you.

this probably will not work with the existing freewheel as it look like it has the the twists and ramps to help with shifting, meaning the chain will not stay on one cog without a tensioner I have tried and it did not work

dedhed He didn't ask about the bikes value. He asked how to fix it. If we define "fix" as the bicycle being returned to a functional state fit for use as a bicycle, then you will see that useful commentary has been given.

squirtdad If there isn't enough slack to allow the chain to get over the gear teeth & the chain line is reasonably straight like it would be in the middle 1/3rd of the cassette, the ramps/pins/other shifting helper features will never come in to play. Chain angle more than anything else is what initiates shifting. It's a hack, of course, & it can be mitigated by chainring selection of up or down 1 or 2 teeth or possibly in combination with the addition of a half-link to fine tune the available slack with the chosen cog, but it does work. Sheldon Brown even did an article on it. It's under the "Sheldon's Kludges" heading.

that is was not my hands on experience trying this, granted it was on one bike, under time pressure, and with lack of correct tools, so that could be an anomaly. It certainly can't hurt the OP to try, it is pretty much free

Thanks all to responded with solutions. I went with the single speed option.

A single cog in back, with spacers to align to modified chain. Keeping the chain aligned to ring and cog and rim aligned to the frame is key to success.

We think we avoided a chain tensioner. We were about to install it to the frame bolt, assuming we could find a long enough QR bolt. We'll do this if we get a complaint about dropped chain.

Welding the hangar was considered. I found someone who would do it for $40. Would need to have cleaned the threads and fixed paint if that matters. This option would have kept the 7 speed, which is optimal. But, this bike is a give away or used to raise money for charity, Low cost and quick turn around is important.

Thanks again forum-ers.

I didn't know what the ghost ring was until my favorite LBS tech was showing off. A very cool solution, but, got voted down by "less forward thinking" :) mechanics. This bike will go to someone who likely wouldn't know what to do if it fell off.

"If you have vertical dropouts & can't slide the axle back & forth, but do have a selection of chainrings /cogs around you can install a "ghost ring" to take up the slack. It looks hack-y but, ghost rings work."

I think what he is looking for makes sense to the rest of us, hence the number of actually useful suggestions from other members.

My post prompted a clarification from the OP.

How does your post help address the OP's question?

It helps him know that his question was very easy to understand (especially with the pictures), and that it made sense to everyone else.

Unprovable statement, since many thousands of bf members did not post in the thread.

By the way, if you really want to be a moderator, you should volunteer. I'm sure they could use your help.

From the OP
"​​​​​​I was repairing an older Schwinn cruiser. It's a cool bike that someone will enjoy."

Clearly not the op's bike, and cost to repair vs value of bike is a very legitimate concern as to direction repair proceeds.

I'm not sure of the angle of your drop out but you could consider this solution: https://www.amazon.com/Shimano-Compa...ps%2C89&sr=8-8 .

We only need the help because of the rudeness of people like you. Now stop.

Would something like this replacement hanger work ?

https://www.amazon.com/AUTUT-Univers...58306047&psc=1