Formula for tire width for gravel
Noonievut suggested on a recent thread here that there should be a formula to pick how wide a tire to run on gravel. I thought it would be fun to take a stab at it.. here it is.
Of course this is all just a stab in the dark with numbers pulled out of my head. But I did a couple calculations imagining various scenarios and it didn't seem too far off. Feel free to punch up your numbers and see. It is also mainly for fun and maybe for beginners to get a start, don't take it too seriously. |
I use the following formula:
(Weight of Rider + Bike) (in kg) divided by (cycling tips gravel rating x 3) + (riders age divided by 3) Finally, multiply the answer to the above by zero, and add 40. |
Hmm, let me plug into your formula Clyde .. it will take awhile because I have to convert to kg. .. (crank grind crank) .. It looks like I end up at 40mm there. I think my formula is better for me, from experience I like 35-38mm tires the most. My formula is winning! :D
I think we can declare my formula the best gravel tire width formula ever invented based on the data in so far.. |
Originally Posted by scottfsmith
(Post 22091761)
Noonievut suggested on a recent thread here that there should be a formula to pick how wide a tire to run on gravel. I thought it would be fun to take a stab at it.. here it is.
Of course this is all just a stab in the dark with numbers pulled out of my head. But I did a couple calculations imagining various scenarios and it didn't seem too far off. Feel free to punch up your numbers and see. It is also mainly for fun and maybe for beginners to get a start, don't take it too seriously. |
I use the largest tire that'll fit
|
Originally Posted by Steve B.
(Post 22092642)
I use the largest tire that'll fit
THe flaw with the formulas given above (except mine, of course) is that they (a) assume having a tire wider than 'ideal' is somehow a disadvantage on smooth surfaces, and that (b) the type of gravel you plan on riding is the only type you will ride. In fact, any drawbacks from wider tires is miniscule, especially if you add pressure for rides expected to be smooth or paved, and on rough or soft surfaces the wider the better. Anyhoo, isn't the whole point of gravel bikes to be able to take on roads and tracks with which you are unfamiliar? Wider tires mean you can turn down any road or trail without worry. 35mm tires, for instance, are pretty multi-purpose, but on the roughest of roads you need to proceed with great caution. 42 or 45mm tires are damn close to what we used on rigid mountain bikes in the 80s and 90s - they can go anywhere. |
My tire size choice (and PSI) is fully dependent on the surface and the specifics of the ride ( Racing v. Bikepacking v. Gravelling).
There is no panacea. |
I think for a lot of people the widest tire that fits is indeed a good way to go. But many gravel bike owners are in fact doing a good fraction of their riding on the road, and if they also are interested in going fast they will need to make a compromise somewhere. Either that or get another set of wheels. My formula gives a pretty good idea where to compromise. It might be good to be more explicit about the road % in the formula.
|
Originally Posted by ClydeClydeson
(Post 22091768)
I use the following formula:
(Weight of Rider + Bike) (in kg) divided by (cycling tips gravel rating x 3) + (riders age divided by 3) Finally, multiply the answer to the above by zero, and add 40. Only I add 50 at the end... |
I rode a cyclocross bike with canti brakes as a "gravel bike" for about 10 years before they invented "gravel bikes". That bike can only handle a ~35mm or so tire easily. I found that tire satisfactory, for all of the non-paved riding I do, and have a fairly new pair, so I moved them over to my new disc brake GR300. That's how I've picked my gravel tires. I'll probably try a 38- 40 or so when i need new tires. The frame will take ~45mm with 700c wheels and ~2.1" with 650B. I might end up with ~45 or so tires on a set of 650B and keep ~38's on the 700c. I don't see a need for really big tires on a gravel bike. i don't use it for technical or overly rough stuff, that's what my mountain bike is for. I don't use it for dedicated road rides, that's what my road bike is for.
if I had one bike (which is the case when we're traveling... using the above CX bike), I would have two sets of wheels: 35-38mm for non-paved and general use, and 25-28 for dedicated pavement riding when I want to ride in a road group. That's proved to be very useful for the several years we've been traveling that way. |
Originally Posted by scottfsmith
(Post 22094075)
I think for a lot of people the widest tire that fits is indeed a good way to go. But many gravel bike owners are in fact doing a good fraction of their riding on the road, and if they also are interested in going fast they will need to make a compromise somewhere. Either that or get another set of wheels. My formula gives a pretty good idea where to compromise. It might be good to be more explicit about the road % in the formula.
|
Originally Posted by ClydeClydeson
(Post 22092975)
Honestly, this is the best solution.
THe flaw with the formulas given above (except mine, of course) is that they (a) assume having a tire wider than 'ideal' is somehow a disadvantage on smooth surfaces, and that (b) the type of gravel you plan on riding is the only type you will ride. In fact, any drawbacks from wider tires is miniscule, especially if you add pressure for rides expected to be smooth or paved, and on rough or soft surfaces the wider the better. Anyhoo, isn't the whole point of gravel bikes to be able to take on roads and tracks with which you are unfamiliar? Wider tires mean you can turn down any road or trail without worry. 35mm tires, for instance, are pretty multi-purpose, but on the roughest of roads you need to proceed with great caution. 42 or 45mm tires are damn close to what we used on rigid mountain bikes in the 80s and 90s - they can go anywhere. Cycling is great sport for those who love to continuously tinker with things whether it's tires, handlebars, saddles, gear setup, etc. There is a never ending list of things to tinker with. I certainly do plenty of that. I've tried plenty of tires and finally settled on my Specialized Pathfinder Pro size 42 which are fairly speedy on paved when needed. If I felt like I needed to be faster on my gravel bike on paved I would go with my Terreno Zero size 38 tires. I think it just depends on what your goals are and preferences are. For most people in day to day riding wider is better and there are plenty of gravel tires that will at least do okay on paved surfaces. |
My wider gravel tires are slower on the road than my wide road tires which I assume is because of the tread/rolling resistance. But my wide road tires are perfectly capable of keeping up with the fast Wednesday night ride.
The motor, on the other hand... |
Originally Posted by scottfsmith
(Post 22094075)
I think for a lot of people the widest tire that fits is indeed a good way to go. But many gravel bike owners are in fact doing a good fraction of their riding on the road, and if they also are interested in going fast they will need to make a compromise somewhere. Either that or get another set of wheels. My formula gives a pretty good idea where to compromise. It might be good to be more explicit about the road % in the formula.
|
My formula starts with wearing out the tires that came with the bike, and then probably buying something slicker and one size bigger
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:59 PM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.