WhyFi

As mentioned, OS, regular or Endurance, would be my choice.

The new stuff from Silca is supposed to be even better for large punctures... but it's so good that you can't inject it through the valve stem - it needs to be poured in before seating the tires and you add a replenisher every so often (which can be injected through the stem). I might try it when my current supply of OS runs out.