32-35F in steady rain is a huge challenge.
Back in the day when I lived in NE, I used bread bags over wool socks and basic shoe covers.
Nowadays, I use SealSkinz socks (merino with an alleged waterproof membrane) with neoprene covers over the shoes. They keep the feet wet and warm. If it is a longer ride, I bring spare wool socks.
Fishermans gloves is what I used to use for the hands with merino wool liner underneath. They are rubber. I lost them. I recently bought some Japanese fishing gloves based upon Andrew Skurka's review (he is an ultratype backpacker). I have used them in rain but not enough experience to recommend heartily.
I make no attempt at keeping dry in such dangerous conditions. Warm and wet sweat is fine.
I use the bar mitt things when it is really cold but I never tried them when it is 32-35F and raining. I wear a Kora Yak wool hat (super thin) under my helmet and a ShowersPass helmet rain cover. Of course, a buff on the neck. Gore top and bottom.
Last edited by GhostRider62; 01-04-22 at 05:52 AM.