Originally Posted by
HTupolev
It makes sense as a very rough approximation across some common road cassette sizes.
200 pounds, plus say 20 pounds of bicycle, means that a ten pound difference is something like 230 vs 220. That's a 4.5% difference in gravitational resistance on the climb. In reality, the total resistance is going to change by a bit less than that because not all resistance while climbing is gravitational (i.e. there's still some stuff like aero drag).
Meanwhile the difference between a 24T cog and 25T cog is ~4.2%, or the difference between a 27T cog and 28T cog is 3.7%. So these 1-tooth gear ratio changes are in the same neighborhood as the difference in resistance caused by adding 10 pounds on a climb.
The approximation will break down with less traditional arrangements, like if the road bike in question is running a 1x setup with an 11-50 cassette. Then a 1-tooth difference is a 2% change to gear ratio, for instance.
so this only works at the large end of the cassette? Because 11 to 12 is more like 9%. And we’re only talking to Clydesdales? Because 10lb to a 120lb rider is more like 8%
__________________
It's like riding a bicycle