Every one is different in their preferences. I found my one and only Brooks just okay when new. It didn't get better with break in though and when it was really well broken in with full dinples I actually hated it. I am not very fussy about saddles and am fine with most of the saddles that came with my bikes. The worst of them required a few hundred miles of getting used to but I could ride across the country on any of them. That said I do have a preference for WTB Volt saddles.